Tired of the unnecessary AF100 vs. DSLR polemic.

I'm having a hard time understanding what the status of most dvxusers are. People on here act like they are constantly putting out feature films that have major distribution or footage that is being broadcast on major cable networks all the time. I would think that the farthest MOST people's footage is going is vimeo or youtube. Yes an af100 is a great camera and so is a dslr. Both can produce great images for web based content. If you're "so" professional then why are you not shooting on film or RED? Some of you get so caught up in camera specs that you forget that there is a world of avg people who is prob your audience that don't care what youre shooting on and are actually impressed by dslr footage. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-rqu-hjobc i know a lot of people can find 1000 things wrong with this video but its been viewed by 1,000,000+ people and avg people who don't care about cameras used, like it and I feel like at the end of the day this is all that matters along with getting paid for your work. Some of yall need to come to grips with yourselfs. Why are you spending $5000 on a camera when you're more than likely producing a video that you're not getting paid for and you're prob coming out of pocket to produce along with only 500-1000 people will see when you can do the same thing for $800 and the people that see it will prob not think twice weather or not it was shot on an af100 or dslr. I understand we love cameras but make smart financially decisions as well.

I think part of that answer is the fact that only a few people are actually talented in the realm of directing and cinematography... When they shoot something on a DSRL and it doesn't look good they blame aliasing and the fact that "it's not a REAL video camera". You could 100% percent shoot a feature film on a 5D and it would be indistinguishable from what audience are used to seeing. Most people do not want to accept this. Most people just don't have an eye for it, so they blame the cameras short comings instead, no matter how minute they may be. Luckily, Panasonic built in a fail-safe for wannabee film-makers with their AF-100... 8-bit video. Is 8-bit adequate? Of course. Is 8-bit video any less cinematic? Nope. But Panasonic knows that when people get their hands on this affordable "cinema-machine" and their footage and movies still suck... they're going to need something to blame so that they'll keep buying their future products to chase their film-making pipe-dream.

The AF-100 is an amazing camera. I love the idea of full 1080p slo-motion. And I'll probably buy just for that reason alone. But is it superior to the 5D. Nope. 5D still has the better look. Full-frame is just amazingly immersive and the lens choice is better and more flexible. These thing matter to ARTISTS, but not so much for tech junkies and fan-boys who love their codec and resolution horsepower. The 5D isn't just "cool". It's the best LOOKING video machine to date. And I must re-emphasize the fact that I used the term "LOOKING"... because the QUALITY is debatable and is obviously not the highest. But the look of the 5D is simply unrivaled... only maybe by the 65mm look. Those who use the "term" cool to describe the 5D are obviously those who are not getting good results with one. Will they take the responsibility though? Of course not! Blame the codec! Blame the aliasing! "IT'S DOESN'T HAVE A PRO CODEC THAT'S WHY MY FOOTAGE DOESN'T LOOK PRO... IT'S DEFINITELY NOT MY DIRECTING OR CINEMATOGRAPHY SKILLS. IT'S A STILL CAMERA. I NEED A GIANT FILM-LIKE CAMERA TO MAKE PRO IMAGES!"

There are two kinds of people in this revolution right now. Those who are getting great cinematic-looking images out of these DSLRs... because they understand that they basically have a mini-35mm camera at their disposal and they have always known that composition and content are king. These people will be the future directors and cinematographers that will shape the next step in the industry. The second type are those that complain that it is still not cinema "quality". They use the term "quality" because they cannot replicate that big-screen "look". They will always focus on this "quality" and never stop until they have 10k RAW 16-bit footage. Who cares about what you're shooting if it going to a "cinema-quality" codec right? That's all that matters. These people will constantly be supported ans re-assured by their peers, because after all, they're probably in the same boat as well.
 
Last edited:
DVXuser I miss the way you were. You know before anyone with a camera from Costco could come debate industry pros on the superiority of their camera. Those were the days.
 
You could 100% percent shoot a feature film on a 5D and it would be indistinguishable from what audience are used to seeing.

I am, of course, not sure about this, but I sincerely believe that virtually every ASC (and BSC, CSC, etc.) DP would very much disagree with that statement.

DSLRs are a great value - I love mine - but let's not get carried away comparing them to the resolution, DR, or feel of film or digital cinema cameras (which, even amongst themselves, differ). Not to mention the aliasing, moire, and codec problems. The image that comes out of the camera is just not on par with "what audience are used to seeing" in theaters.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps you could provide a link to your work so we can see some of this 5D footage that is indistinguishable from what we see in feature films.

Good shooting and best regards,

Leo
 
i feel for you Leo, losing the gig on red to a 5d

but I work in the agency, on the other side of the line. And they just don't want to deal with red post.
Bring em in, stich em up, kick em out. Time is money
 
I think part of that answer is the fact that only a few people are actually talented in the realm of directing and cinematography... When they shoot something on a DSRL and it doesn't look good they blame aliasing and the fact that "it's not a REAL video camera". You could 100% percent shoot a feature film on a 5D and it would be indistinguishable from what audience are used to seeing. Most people do not want to accept this. Most people just don't have an eye for it, so they blame the cameras short comings instead, no matter how minute they may be. Luckily, Panasonic built in a fail-safe for wannabee film-makers with their AF-100... 8-bit video. Is 8-bit adequate? Of course. Is 8-bit video any less cinematic? Nope. But Panasonic knows that when people get their hands on this affordable "cinema-machine" and their footage and movies still suck... they're going to need something to blame so that they'll keep buying their future products to chase their film-making pipe-dream.

The AF-100 is an amazing camera. I love the idea of full 1080p slo-motion. And I'll probably buy just for that reason alone. But is it superior to the 5D. Nope. 5D still has the better look. Full-frame is just amazingly immersive and the lens choice is better and more flexible. These thing matter to ARTISTS, but not so much for tech junkies and fan-boys who love their codec and resolution horsepower. The 5D isn't just "cool". It's the best LOOKING video machine to date. And I must re-emphasize the fact that I used the term "LOOKING"... because the QUALITY is debatable and is obviously not the highest. But the look of the 5D is simply unrivaled... only maybe by the 65mm look. Those who use the "term" cool to describe the 5D are obviously those who are not getting good results with one. Will they take the responsibility though? Of course not! Blame the codec! Blame the aliasing! "IT'S DOESN'T HAVE A PRO CODEC THAT'S WHY MY FOOTAGE DOESN'T LOOK PRO... IT'S DEFINITELY NOT MY DIRECTING OR CINEMATOGRAPHY SKILLS. IT'S A STILL CAMERA. I NEED A GIANT FILM-LIKE CAMERA TO MAKE PRO IMAGES!"

There are two kinds of people in this revolution right now. Those who are getting great cinematic-looking images out of these DSLRs... because they understand that they basically have a mini-35mm camera at their disposal and they have always known that composition and content are king. These people will be the future directors and cinematographers that will shape the next step in the industry. The second type are those that complain that it is still not cinema "quality". They use the term "quality" because they cannot replicate that big-screen "look". They will always focus on this "quality" and never stop until they have 10k RAW 16-bit footage. Who cares about what you're shooting if it going to a "cinema-quality" codec right? That's all that matters. These people will constantly be supported ans re-assured by their peers, because after all, they're probably in the same boat as well.


I definitely agree with the tone of your post that shot composition and quality filmmaking get lost in the technical shuffle sometimes.

Thing is, I see that same sorta effect on the DSLR side too. I noticed a whooooole slew of new random rack-focus jerk off shots just for the sake of showing off this new available technique. That's no better than being excited over 10bit 4:4:4 colorspace.

It's rare to see quality, basic, simple composition from either camp as far as I'm concerned. The look of DSLRs is so new and cool that I think alot of people fail to notice how utterly bland and uninteresting alot of the material shot on them is.

Content is and always will be, king.
 
5D moire exists and is really ugly.

5D moire exists and is really ugly.

I am tired of hearing people say that moire and aliasing on the 5D is exaggerated. We ended up having to shoot a huge part of our series last year with the Red because of the terrible moire that cropped up in the 5D. It really sucked because I had just purchased the 5D and some nice Canon lenses, and was so jazzed to shoot with it. As soon as I pointed my 5D at the triplets who were dressed in private school girl student outfits. OMG. The plaid pattern on the skirts almost made me cry. MOIRE GALORE. I didn't see this type of moire in any of the sizzle videos that many people, including myself, were salivating over when the 5D first came out. Luckily I had done a couple of 5D camera tests as soon as I got the camera, so I was able to save our shooting schedule. And before you reply... changing the skirts was not an option. :-) On the bright side, my camera wasn't a total bust. At least I was able to shoot some awesome promo pictures with it. Like this one. Needless to say, I have put in a pre order for my AF100. I will be shooting the rest of the series with that. :-)

Code_Z_Promo.jpg


For more info on Code Z, visit our website
http://www.codeztheseries.com/
 
You could 100% percent shoot a feature film on a 5D and it would be indistinguishable from what audience are used to seeing.

If your movie is all talking heads, at night time, with narrow DOF and shown on youtube, absolutely. In that mode it takes advantage of every strength the 5D, 7D and GH1 have.

Shoot a city scape with bricks, tiles, grates in good lighting and you'll have... a mess that intrudes too much on the images to concentrate on the story.

Its not that you can't shoot with wild sound and sync in post, avoid patterns, etc. but no matter how much you try you're going to lose some shots.

Yes I do have two DSLRs. I don't use them when I 'm paying 5 actors and 3 crew members for the day. Its not cost effective.
 
I'm having a hard time understanding what the status of most dvxusers are. People on here act like they are constantly putting out feature films that have major distribution or footage that is being broadcast on major cable networks all the time. I would think that the farthest MOST people's footage is going is vimeo or youtube...
I can't speak for anyone else, but I've regularly projected things shot on my DVX & HVX on a 50' wide screen in a local theater that our church rented. Lately, we've been projecting them up on a 16' x 9' screen in a smaller venue. I've seen DVX, HVX, T2i, and GH13 footage blown up at that size, and as long as the content was solid, nobody complained about the look from any of them. This was true, even of the DVX on the 50' screen.

I strongly suspect that the reason most DSLR users aren't being hammered by moire issues is that everything they shoot is now shallow DOF. This is all the rage (for the moment), somewhat akin to Hollywood pushing out stuff in 3D that has no discernable plot, but hey... IT'S IN 3D!!!

For the commercial work that I've been doing lately, I take the HVX and the GH13, mount them to the same tripod, and use the GH13 for a shallow DOF closeup of whatever the HVX is shooting. If the GH13 doesn't look the way I want, the HVX is still my A camera, so I'm not stuck with unusable footage. (This has happened a couple of times, making me glad that I didn't try to do the job with the GH13 alone.)

Are people going to insist on using a 5D? Yup... just like they're going to complain about the "crop frame" of the AF100 because it's not FF (eye roll)... or because it's listing at $4795. I'm not going to fight them. If they want me to shoot something and don't specify a camera, I'll shoot it like I am now, and with an AF100 at the end of December. If they want me to use an iPhone 4, then I'll learn to work within its abilities and limitations, and deliver the best product I can.

The most important thing is to learn the skills that will transfer from one camera to the next, rather than spending a lot of time figuring out the idiosyncrasies of just one. That's like becoming the grand guru of Object Pascal, and waking up the next day and realizing that the rest of the world is now using C++/C#/Objective-C/etc. Learn the underlying skills and techniques that haven't changed in 40 years, and you'll be insulated from the changes of technology. - Tim
 
i feel for you Leo, losing the gig on red to a 5d

but I work in the agency, on the other side of the line. And they just don't want to deal with red post.
Bring em in, stich em up, kick em out. Time is money

What are you talking about? Any high school kid with Final Cut can edit Red footage in their sleep. Load in the footage, cut, push out to the satellite. Done.

There is no magic to Red post; nothing special, completely routine. Color grade with Apple Color or any program you wish.

PM me and I'll bring your agency guys up to speed.

Good shooting and best regards,

Leo
 
What are you talking about? Any high school kid with Final Cut can edit Red footage in their sleep. Load in the footage, cut, push out to the satellite. Done.

There is no magic to Red post; nothing special, completely routine. Color grade with Apple Color or any program you wish.

PM me and I'll bring your agency guys up to speed.

Good shooting and best regards,

Leo

There's plenty of times when its a spot with budget and r1mx is a defacto choice. Post house handles the pipeline.
The pre rocket stigma still exists and I'm sure you are aware of it. If it's in house they seldom run with red. Maybe the Foundry are set to change all that with storm.
I'm not your enemy Leo, nor am I the decision maker. Mine was a sympathetic post. I'm just telling you the conversations I overhear.
 
There's plenty of times when its a spot with budget and r1mx is a defacto choice. Post house handles the pipeline.
The pre rocket stigma still exists and I'm sure you are aware of it. If it's in house they seldom run with red. Maybe the Foundry are set to change all that with storm.
I'm not your enemy Leo, nor am I the decision maker. Mine was a sympathetic post. I'm just telling you the conversations I overhear.

I did not take your comment as an attack, I'm just trying to clear the misconception that posting Red footage is any different than anything else. Load, Grade if necessary, Cut, Distribute. No different from any other video format.

Good shooting and best regards,

Leo
 
If Crank 2 was shot on a canon xh-a1 and little hg-100 cameras or paranormal activity was shot on a sony fx1 please explain to me how a feature cannot be shot on a dslr?
 
Nobody's saying it "can't" be done. Of course it could be done. The question is whether it should be done, or if you should use a more-appropriate tool for that job.
 
It certainly can be. But it is important to remember that the choice of camera for those films actually played a role in how the movie came across - i.e., raw and gritty for Crank 2 and "real" and/or home-movie-esque for Paranormal Activity. Another good reference of this is the Blair Witch Project. And, unless I'm mistaken, there was a very significant amount of high-end post production work on these films.

What I disagree with is that these cameras look "indistinguishable from what audience are used to seeing". Which, in the case of most films, they aren't.

And, really, the fact that such cameras were chosen for the specific visual aesthetic they provide for movies like Crank 2 and Paranormal Activity prove that point. They look different than the traditional film/digi-cine acquisition. It's not inherently a bad thing and can lead to reasonable artistic choices.

But just because something gets shot with X or Y doesn't mean it looks the same as Z. A fine case for this argument is the Hurt Locker. It is a very-well shot film with many very dynamic scenes. But it doesn't look like 35mm or typical digi-cine because it isn't. It's 16mm. Not a bad thing, but different. The graininess enhances the war imagery and lends a sense of grit and dirt that makes it somewhat more real and poignant.

The real question then is: What does the 5D aesthetic offer that makes it something one would choose over another format? 1/4" DOF? 115+ degree Field of View? Muddy 4:2:0 color? Aliasing/Moire?
 
I can't speak for anyone else, but I've regularly projected things shot on my DVX & HVX on a 50' wide screen in a local theater that our church rented. Lately, we've been projecting them up on a 16' x 9' screen in a smaller venue. I've seen DVX, HVX, T2i, and GH13 footage blown up at that size, and as long as the content was solid, nobody complained about the look from any of them. This was true, even of the DVX on the 50' screen.

I strongly suspect that the reason most DSLR users aren't being hammered by moire issues is that everything they shoot is now shallow DOF. This is all the rage (for the moment), somewhat akin to Hollywood pushing out stuff in 3D that has no discernable plot, but hey... IT'S IN 3D!!!

For the commercial work that I've been doing lately, I take the HVX and the GH13, mount them to the same tripod, and use the GH13 for a shallow DOF closeup of whatever the HVX is shooting. If the GH13 doesn't look the way I want, the HVX is still my A camera, so I'm not stuck with unusable footage. (This has happened a couple of times, making me glad that I didn't try to do the job with the GH13 alone.)

Are people going to insist on using a 5D? Yup... just like they're going to complain about the "crop frame" of the AF100 because it's not FF (eye roll)... or because it's listing at $4795. I'm not going to fight them. If they want me to shoot something and don't specify a camera, I'll shoot it like I am now, and with an AF100 at the end of December. If they want me to use an iPhone 4, then I'll learn to work within its abilities and limitations, and deliver the best product I can.

The most important thing is to learn the skills that will transfer from one camera to the next, rather than spending a lot of time figuring out the idiosyncrasies of just one. That's like becoming the grand guru of Object Pascal, and waking up the next day and realizing that the rest of the world is now using C++/C#/Objective-C/etc. Learn the underlying skills and techniques that haven't changed in 40 years, and you'll be insulated from the changes of technology. - Tim

For the most part, I agree with this. Once again this thread is not about arguing the merits of one camera vs. another. It's about using these cameras in tandem. That's why I started it. It's about how easy and inexpensive it is now to have 2nd and 3rd cameras. If I purchase an AF100 it will be for using it based on it's particular qualities too. Yes the 5D has issues. Do I need to throw the baby out with the bathwater? No. It's great to be able to have access to a multitude of lenses and using them at the angle of view they were intended for. For instance, I can use my wide angle TS lens at the angle it was intended for and for which there is currently no equivalent in 4/3". Further, the 5D can and does produce great looking images, and not occasionally. Often.

For me the either/or polemic is ridiculous. All of these cameras can be used in a complementary fashion and the point is, they are. Trying to be monotheistic about this, in saying that only one camera can solve all my problems is ridiculous. Though I imagine it is comforting to think that one is enlightened and everyone else is not, if they have not made the same choices.

The fact is I do interviews all the time where I have a camera on each subject as well as the entire scene. This is something that just was not financially feasible a few years ago. For bread and butter work this is a godsend, and I am certainly enjoying that I can throw all of them in a single small backpack if needed.

When the AF100 comes out I may consider purchasing one for filling the gap in areas which the 5D's are lacking. However, I certainly don't need to purchase 3 of them.

Lastly, i have debated talking about this, because I know everyone will only focus on this part and ignore all the rest in this post (which is my more important point) but despite accusations to the contrary, (ahem, Barry) I have indeed already used the AGF-100 here in Paris. (More precisely known as the AGF-101 here.) One of the reasons I wanted to test it is because I would like to do quick pans occasionally without some of the standard DSLR issues. Sadly, I found the Panny did not perform particularly well on this front. I found a strange kind of stuttering or breakup occurred around verticals in the pans and the Panny rep couldn't explain it. Probably it's the bitrate.

Now, wouldn't it be ironic if we had to call the likes of a Mr. Trammel Hudson to help us out on that one?

Or even more surprisingly for some here, continued using our GH13's for this very same reason.


:-)
 
Last edited:
Trying to be monotheistic about this, in saying that only one camera can solve all my problems is ridiculous. Though I imagine it is comforting to think that one is enlightened and everyone else is not, if they have not made the same choices.

As my Granny said: In God's garden a lot of different creatures live.... ;-)

Coming from "old school" I tend to believe though, that the AG-AF will fit into more "slots" over all than a lot of other cameras - especially concerning a more dramatic/cinematic work. While the main focus here in this forum is on the celestial beings of THE MAGNIFICENT SENSOR and THE ETERNAL CODEC, two gods of grandest and utter importance, yes.... we should lay some attention also at the often overlooked goddess of GRACIOUS HANDLING. And here the AG-AF seems to be in a new league too as - in danger of repeating an implicitness- it brings together most of what we like in DSLR's with what some/a lot/ most of us may need from a film/video-camera. I for my part will know better if this holds true hopefully in December.

Meanwhile we will keep and use the GH13 though - and even may buy a GH2 later if the 25p thing is settled - as an addition, a complementary tool. And for me "that's all folks"....
 
Last edited:
Nobody's saying it "can't" be done. Of course it could be done. The question is whether it should be done, or if you should use a more-appropriate tool for that job.

That is all I needed to hear from you then. I understand at the end of the day you have to sell a product (af-100) but the way you've been downplaying dslrs you would think that they are completely useless tools for filmmaking. I come from a strickly music video background so I don't deal with recording audio and the shots I use don't last longer than .23 secs at a time so I guess I don't understand the pain of using a dslr from "filmmaking" standpoint. But I have seen other people do it and I know it's possible. Speaking of this all can you help me understand the perks I am getting as a music video director seeing that I don't record audio and moire and aliasing is not a big deal to me? I plan on buying this cam but I'm kind of stuck on the fence right now? Right now my reason for buying is I'm sure my immediate competition will not be able to purchase this cam so I will be able to provide a different look from all the other music video directors using dslrs. I'm not really sure it will bring me more customers per say but I guess it would boost my ego. That counts for something right? lol
 
Last edited:
@dtjohns1,

That's a very unfair thing to say about Barry. He doesn't have a camera to sell. The GH1 is also made by Panasonic and he hasn't been overly complimentary about the mud its capable of producing in certain situations.

Memorize Duke's proclamation: "All cameras have strengths and weaknesses."

DSLRs are capable of great DOF control, they're compact, they have changeable lenses and they're cheap.

They also have several notable drawbacks not found in most video cameras. That does not make them horrible at everything, merely problematic at certain things. If you have the luxury of shooting that way fine. If time is no object and you're on a strict budget they can be just the thing you want. For bigger productions that is not usually the case.

Potentially (we'll see when it actually comes out) the AF100 will combine some of the best aspects of both. It will still fall under Duke's proclamation and therefore have weaknesses. For instance, the lack of a power zoom will make it less useful for certain action events.

Even so the AF100 should be a significant improvement. Just because Barry, or some others, likes the AF100 for the things he shoots doesn't mean a DSLR isn't right for you, but most people aren't shooting only music videos. A movie has different requirements.
 
Back
Top