Tired of the unnecessary AF100 vs. DSLR polemic.

Ah. Not to worry. They were probably using the GH1's LCD on that preproduction model, and that LCD ghosting is a well known phenomenon on the GH1. But it's strictly an LCD issue, it doesn't show up in the footage. And the AF100 production models will have a substantially improved LCD over that one. So basically what you're describing will have nothing to do with the AF100.

Well that seems to make a lot of sense to me....it seemed unlikely to me that something like that should have gone unnoticed.
 
I get much wider fields of view with my 7-14 lens. It yields equivalent FOV to the Canon when the Canon is using about a 13mm lens. You can match 17mm on the 5D with 9mm on the AF100, and you can get that from a couple of Olympus lenses or the Panasonic 7-14 zoomed to 9mm, or of course if you can afford it you could get the 8mm Master Prime and be wider too.

The idea that the m43 format can't do wide-angle is an incorrect notion. The m43 format has lenses that can go wider than any currently-available lens I'm aware of for a "full frame" camera.

No, what I mean is that those are TS lenses. (Tilt and Shift - 24mm and 17mm) So far I have not seen any TS equivalents in terms of the same focal length for the Panasonic. Of course I could spend hours and hours in post to try and reproduce that, but why bother?

Another example is that when I need fast and wide, there really are not many options at 2x (4/3"). At the equivalent focal lengths there are mostly only zooms like the ones you have described and they are not fast enough, especially for low light work. An F1.4 is very useful and useable at wider angles, especially because there is automatically greater depth of field beyond 1 or 2 meters, and when you are working in a tight corner of a Parisian cafe at night, without the ability to cart in a bunch of lights, this kind of thing can save you.

Given, the choice between owning my own lenses in those situations and trying to compete with production companies for expensive lens packages, where I need to guarantee astronomical insurance situations for a set of Masterprimes or Cookes, well, I think you can guess what choice seems to make the most sense. Especially now that multiple cameras are in play. This is why I have always maintained that the so called DSLR revolution is just as much about the ability to own your own lenses as the cameras you are buying.

On the flip side I do appreciate the lens multiplication of the Panny and 7D for the speed they offer me on the telefoto side. It means I can buy an inexpensive 85mm f1.4 to round out a set of lenses and dispense with a 70-200 f2.8 for 5 times it's price, and I don't even need lens stabilization, because it is so lightweight. Further, with a 5D, a 7D and an AGF100, my standard 4 lens set is now equivalent to 12 focal lengths, and each with a capacity to open to f1.4.

That is an example of taking advantage of the complementary nature of all of these cameras together, and there is no reason why people cannot be thinking more in this way.
 
Last edited:
We're rescheduling our stuff, will be shooting after Thanksgiving. In the meantime, I'm sure some footage will come from the forthcoming Japan trip next week.

have you confirmed though that the japan thing will have fi nal production model? I thought there was a disagreement iwth you and Bloom regarding that and you were saying it may not be final production model?

And just out of curiosity what is it exactly YOU will be shooting? Is it more like tests as in charts and such or is it mroe like an actual test short like crews.tv with the model thing?
Please test dynamic range rigorously it's the only thing I care about! I want to see it tested next to 5dmkii on same exact chart and settings as I'm buying either an af100 or 5dmkii if af100 is not up to snuff
 
I don't have anything to sell. Well, I sell books, but I don't sell cameras.

As for a DSLR for filmmaking -- people are doing it all the time. Check out the thread from Marlon Ladd on "The Jones'". It looks fantastic. I wouldn't do it, I find the workability issues simply not worth the hassle. I'd much rather work with a product that provides the minimum basic featureset that I like to work with. Other folks have different standards.

What I find abhorrent about the DSLR is the prospect that by its very nature it might ruin shots. That when you shoot wide-angle, or anything in sharp focus, if there are repeating patterns in your scene, it might lead to a blurry wash of purple/orange all over your footage. I find that completely unacceptable. And, I just don't like the limited ability to work with them. I bought two of the things -- a 7D and a GH1. I tried to work with them. I even used the 7D for some of the scenes on my new Lighting For Film & Television DVD. And after its limitations screwed the pooch on one particular shot, I said "never again".

We used a GH1 for two multi-award-winning films. I've been there and done that. And I really, really don't want to have to do it again. For those who can't possibly afford any other alternative, and who don't mind working with the limitations, hey -- some gorgeous work can be done with one of those. But what I don't understand is -- if you had any possible other alternative, why wouldn't you take it? I sure would.


Perks of ? Of an AF100 over a DSLR, or ?
The main imaging benefits of the AF100 over a DSLR are the incredibly reduced aliasing, the elimination of the purple/orange moire, and an overall sharper image, and the elimination of the fixed-pattern noise, and the ability to do a wide variety of framerates in slow- and fast-motion, at 20 different framerates in 1080p, and a more-robust, artifact-resistant codec.

Other than that, the main benefits of the AF100 are workflow related. Single-system audio, incredibly wide range of lens options, exposure tools like zebras/spotmeter/waveform, stuff like that. Workflow things like if you wanted to attach an external recorder, you can, and you can even output 1080/24pSf. Ability to connect to professional monitors through HD-SDI, and to professional mics through XLR input, including line and mic level, and supplying phantom power. Remote control of focus, iris, and start/stop. Simultaneous viewfinder and LCD panel so operator and 1st AC can each have their own display. Focus position to the foot and inch, and zoom position in millimeters, read out on the display. Ability to record longer than 10 minutes (up to 12 hours in one continuous take). Freedom from overheating so the camera will always be ready to shoot no matter what. There are dozens and dozens of workflow improvements and such, that you may or may not find necessary for your work.

If you don't find any of those workflow features necessary, and you don't mind the aliasing and moire issues, and the time limits aren't a problem, then the DSLR may very well be the ideal solution for you and the additional cost of the AF100 might be complete overkill.


Well, again, it depends on how you work, and it also depends on whether your clients care about what type of camera you're using. If one client chooses you over someone else because you've got a bigger/fancier/more-impressive camera, well, that may seem silly but hey, if that one job brings enough dough to pay for that camera, then it was worth it, right? On the other hand, if no client cares at all about what camera you're using, and neither do you... then ... why spend a dime more than you have to?

Oops! I dont know why I thought you were a Panasonic rep lol. Thanks for the information. Do you know when any footage from the 100% complete model with be arriving?
 
have you confirmed though that the japan thing will have fi nal production model? I thought there was a disagreement iwth you and Bloom regarding that and you were saying it may not be final production model?
It's obviously not going to be a final production model; the unit doesn't ship for another 8 weeks. My understanding is that what we will be seeing is the first "production line sample", known as a "PL" model. That's the first time they've put the pieces together that would, if finalized, be what a final model would be made out of. However, it is not finalized. In terms of software, I'd call it a "release candidate" for the hardware -- it might actually end up being final hardware, if no bugs or showstoppers are found. Or there may need to be revisions to the hardware, depending on what the shooters discover or comment on. The only way this would be an actual "production model" is if absolutely everything works absolutely perfectly first time out of the box. While that's possible, I would find it highly unlikely.

Even if the hardware is finalized at this point, the software will still have a good several weeks that it could undergo refinement. The software can be flashed onto the hardware the day before shipping if they decided to, so they could keep refining and updating for the next seven or eight weeks.

And just out of curiosity what is it exactly YOU will be shooting? Is it more like tests as in charts and such or is it mroe like an actual test short like crews.tv with the model thing?
Let's put it this way -- I'm not going to be doing charts, and I'm not going to be doing some walking-around-town handheld montage. And that's all I'm gonna say.
 
Do you know when any footage from the 100% complete model with be arriving?

Stay tuned to DVXUser. The real footage that you want to see will be coming in early December. There will probably be some stuff coming out of the Japan VIP trip, but as just discussed, I wouldn't expect that to represent final version. And I don't know if the shooters on that trip will be posting stuff from that anyway, as I don't know if the codec is finalized yet and if the imaging is stabilized at the point where they want footage released. It may be, it may not be.

Folks should realize that on the HVX200 launch (which followed this exact same schedule almost To The Day), the very first footage was released in early December. So we're still comparatively early in the process. I know everyone wants to see stuff, but ... it's premature. And I know some people think the schedule is too tight, all I can say is we went through this exact same process with the HVX200, and I shot the world's first footage on that, and we shot that starting about November 29th, and showed it at DV Expo, and released it on the web about December 3rd or so. The AF100 is following almost the exact same schedule.

So it's coming. Give it a month.
 
Yup -- and the excitement isn't just limited to the new tools. New distribution avenues are opening up like crazy, new talent has a better chance than ever of getting noticed. Great cameras/lighting/sound at low prices, free distribution.....Exciting times indeed. Is there a 'New Business Model' thread somewhere?
 
Something beneficial:

Good news everyone. My friends and I have put our resources together ( about 23$ ) and have driven around montreal to find the best tools to create a time machine that will allow December 18th to come faster than you can imagine

So far we have a prototype:

Time%20Machine.jpg


will keep you posted.


but in all seriousness. The release of this cam cannot come fast enough! My mouth is watering to use it.

I thought the December 18th date was incorrect info from a couple of stores. Did I miss something? Has the release date been moved up to the 18th?
 
I thought the December 18th date was incorrect info from a couple of stores. Did I miss something? Has the release date been moved up to the 18th?
As far as I know the date has never changed and is still Dec. 27th. Anyone saying otherwise is, unfortunately, misinformed. I'll ping Jan and ask her to clarify if the date has indeed been moved.
 
As far as I know the date has never changed and is still Dec. 27th. Anyone saying otherwise is, unfortunately, misinformed. I'll ping Jan and ask her to clarify if the date has indeed been moved.

Alright thanks. Yea, I spoke to a couple different stores and have heard both the 18th and the 27th, but I was pretty sure that I read on here that it was still the 27th.
 
I am, of course, not sure about this, but I sincerely believe that virtually every ASC (and BSC, CSC, etc.) DP would very much disagree with that statement.

DSLRs are a great value - I love mine - but let's not get carried away comparing them to the resolution, DR, or feel of film or digital cinema cameras (which, even amongst themselves, differ). Not to mention the aliasing, moire, and codec problems. The image that comes out of the camera is just not on par with "what audience are used to seeing" in theaters.

Indeed - and even networks have studied that audiences do not like ugly images - now more than ever. Lie to Me shot 1 episode on 5D - they got hundreds of letters of complaint from regular people.
 
Indeed - and even networks have studied that audiences do not like ugly images - now more than ever. Lie to Me shot 1 episode on 5D - they got hundreds of letters of complaint from regular people.

Really? House shot one episode on the 5D and Tattersal is still using it on House. Lie To Me shot an episode on the 5DII, and the first we're hearing of it is from you? The internet was on fire when they did it for House, but not a peep for Lie To Me. Just how did this momentus event get by this forum or Planet 5D for that matter? Please supply a link and episode title.

They are using it on Hawaii 5-0, and the director is thrilled.
 
I am, of course, not sure about this, but I sincerely believe that virtually every ASC (and BSC, CSC, etc.) DP would very much disagree with that statement..

Since you said every DP, I'll just say that Gale Tattersall and obviously ASC Shane Hurlbut would disagree with you as they would say the 5DII is on par with "what audience are used to seeing" in theaters and television. Hurlbut will be releasing Act of Valor and of course Tattersall used it for 100% aquisition for an episode of House and is still using it on House.



DSLRs are a great value - I love mine - but let's not get carried away comparing them to the resolution, DR, or feel of film or digital cinema cameras (which, even amongst themselves, differ). Not to mention the aliasing, moire, and codec problems. The image that comes out of the camera is just not on par with "what audience are used to seeing" in theaters

I'm looking forward to getting my AF100 as much as the next guy but let's not get carried away short changing the 5DII. It is being used by DPs on big productions and not as a crash cam but as an A cam. I just watched an interview with the director of Hawaii 5-0, and he says he's using them as a main camera in dialogue sequences. He also mentioned that they're being used all over in the industry. Actually, I wasn't even aware Hawaii 5-0 was back as a series. Who knew?
 
I would love to see even one of these letters.

dEar Lye to mE-
I don likes the pikchers that came offa that there Cannon 5Dee camra.
they is full of all kinds Aleeus and Moirays, I don like what how it looks on my pickcher tube.
please refrane from usin it agin.
thanks you.
yours true Lee, a reglar person
 
Who cares? Its not an either/or issue. Its a 'Which camera can I afford, that will give me the aesthetic that I want and allow me to shoot the way I want?' The answer will be different for different people and different projects.
 
Back
Top