Tired of the unnecessary AF100 vs. DSLR polemic.

People's fantasy about making movies is that they can take a small tool, point it at something and then see it played back to them with all the dramaticness of the feature films and commercials they are used watching. DSLRs somehow hint to this fantasy, and the Canon's are are the most known. This is why it's considered cool.

I remember watching behind the scenes footage from a Bourne film with a friend. He became utterly disapointed for some reason when he saw how little action was actually involved in making action scenes. It was mostly men with toolbelts rigging vires here and there, and lots of people waiting around. It's all very constructed.

Leo: Why didn't you just rent or borrow a 5d? Clients will from time to time request something that you might disagree on, even something stupit. This happens in every business and industry. In my experience, the most professional people will communicate to you what they want to achieve and why, and then leave the expert to finding out how.

But not always, and at the end of the day they are paying, it's their product that will either succeed or fail in achieveing their goals. And they should be allowed to make their own mistakes.

Yes, we get passionate about our art and craft. But making commercials is first and foremost a business, right?
 
Leo: Why didn't you just rent or borrow a 5d? Clients will from time to time request something that you might disagree on, even something stupit. This happens in every business and industry. In my experience, the most professional people will communicate to you what they want to achieve and why, and then leave the expert to finding out how.

This was early on in the 5D rise to coolness and we did not know a 5D bid had been requested, not even by the agency, but actually by the end client. Maybe his fourteen year-old kid told him how cool the 5D was. Also, I've got this very funny habit of trying to do my best work for every client. This is more than just business to me; sometimes it's better to walk away than to be complicit in the creation of a bad job.

I hasten to add that under optimal circumstances and in skilled hands, the 5D can do a very good job. I've got a friend who just shot a food spot with his 5D and it looks damned good, certainly good enough for the local cable buy.

Would it have been better on Red? Of course.

Furthermore, there are situations where the 5D is the preferred choice; perhaps you need a very, very narrow DOF; maybe you're mounting a crash cam in an impossibly dangerous or tight place. Haul out the 5D and be a hero.

On the other hand, a video camera that can render footage unusable because of moire or aliasing, that can't record more than 12 minutes, that heats up under not so extreme conditions and shuts down, that has the ergonomics of a German U-boat, and has only very expensive lens options for follow focus, is, shall we say, challenging.

It is, however, very cool.

I can't wait until mine does only what it does very well; stills.

Good shooting and best regards,

Leo
 
And there is your answer, right there. You ask why there's the combativeness, and then you make a statement implying that a still camera is technically superior to a product you haven't used or seen, even when the 5D has demonstrably got serious issues that the new product doesn't.

If you want to stop the war, you'll have to stop lobbing grenades. :)

Agreed. Thing is, people usually don't like been told that they have just wasted a load of money on something that is no good; well perhaps for stills photographs.

I know people in the UK and USA from 10 years ago who used to do and say everything they could to justify their $,125,000 AVID edit systems when because they had already bought them. I said Apple's FCP did the same thing for $5,000 and they hated it.

Just because you own it, doesn't mean it is the best. I own a 10 year old petrol guzzling BMW 7 series, nuff said.

It's all about the right tool for the job, if your client is happy with aliasing and moire rainbowing all over their corporate DVD, then the 5D MK2 will have them creaming their jeans with excitement.
 
I hasten to add that under optimal circumstances and in skilled hands, the 5D can do a very good job. I've got a friend who just shot a food spot with his 5D and it looks damned good, certainly good enough for the local cable buy.

Would it have been better on RED? Of course.

Hmm, this looks interesting...


I hasten to add that under optimal circumstances and in skilled hands, the RED can do a very good job. I've got a friend who just shot a food spot with his RED and it looks damned good, certainly good enough for the local cable buy.

Would it have been better on F35? Of course.



I hasten to add that under optimal circumstances and in skilled hands, the F35 can do a very good job. I've got a friend who just shot a food spot with his F35 and it looks damned good, certainly good enough for the local cable buy.

Would it have been better on Film? Of course.



I hasten to add that under optimal circumstances and in skilled hands, the Panaflex can do a very good job. I've got a friend who just shot a food spot with his Panaflex camera and it looks damned good, certainly good enough for the local cable buy.

Would it have been better on IMAX? Of course.


...where do you draw the line?
 
It's all about the right tool for the job, if your client is happy with aliasing and moire rainbowing all over their corporate DVD, then the 5D MK2 will have them creaming their jeans with excitement.

That's exaggeration at its finest. I love the prospect of the AF100 as much as the next guy, but this is sickening. I shoot with my 7D all the time and especially down-converting to SD DVD, I don't see any more artifacts than your standard video issues. Seriously, fanboys make me lose the will to live...

If Panasonic is encouraging this kind of behavior, then I'll have about as much respect for them as a company as I do right now for holier than thou RED. Maybe I'll wait to see what Canon offers in 2 years, jeeze.

DSLR lovers need to get over the fact that the AF100 is the next step in the revolution. AF100 lovers need to accept the fact that DSLRs got you here.
 
Last edited:
Well, i just didn't get a job because i dont have a 5D.

I'm a HMC150 owner, and since i heard about the A100 (in april i think) i decided not to buy a DSLR.

Two months ago i bought the GH1, to adapt myself to the AF100 workflow. And i tried to do that job with the GH1 (unhacked), but it didn't successful. Some clients here are "blind" about the wonders of 5D.

Sometime ago i was talking to a friend, informing him about the AF100 and he said to me: "BUT THATS A VIDEO CAMERA!", like i was telling him a a crazy idea.

Well my point is: we have to deal with the ignorance of people. I have nightmares to think about the assumption of the market (ignorant people) prefer the 5D over AF100. So all that makes me ask:

How you think would be the best way to prove, to ignorant people, the superiority of the AF100 over DSLR?

Thanks.

It's simple. Ignorant people need to be educated in sound bites. While holding your AF100 up where they can see it after they've said I want it done on the 5DII, you say:

1 "This is a 5D on sterioids"

2 "This is the son of 5D. The 5D gave birth to this." (shaking it in front of their face)

3 "The 5D was so incredible, they invented this! ...and it's even better!!!"

4 Slowly waving the 5D in front of their face "This is not the camera your looking for." (then holding up the AF100 quickly) "This is!!"

Just some suggestions.
 
Which is why you only buy the camera that you will use everyday. If you are still photographer and that is your bread and butter, then you get the right tool for the job. If you are a video shooter, invest in what you think will get you the most work, you may find that is in reality a 1/3" fixed lens cam for event work. Be realistic about your needs. There are enough dslr's out there that if that is what you need for a job you can probably get one for the day. Network with other shooters and hire the 5D11 guy to assist and bring his cam, problem solved.

I live in a very small market, and rental is not an option. I make due for the most part with a couple of Hv20's, but I know who to call to get a 7D or 5D2, a dvx, xh-a1, hpx170, etc. There are no RED's here, and no need for it. I'm hoping to scrape together the resources for an AF100, or a similar competing product if one reveals itself in the coming year, and if I get it I will be the go-to guy for that in my market, hopefully. I'm not a still's photographer, so I haven't felt the need to jump on that bandwagon, knowing the problems associated with the video. The cameras locally are owned by, wait for it, professional photographers that make money taking pictures. The video function is an afterthought, and they don't even typically have enough batteries or memory card to use the cam for significant video use.

If you are filmmaker hoping to make the best film you can on your own dime and shoot it yourself, this may be the camera for you. If you are a young aspiring cinematographer, who wants to shoot narrative work and can afford to own a camera and work for free, then great. The jobs that expect you to have a camera pay so low that it is hard to justify having anything good, you'd make more money as a PA on a real shoot that rents.
 
...where do you draw the line?
C'mon, Perrone. Be real. The 5D is not designed for this purpose. It can cause shots to go straight to hell. The Red, the F35, and film will never do that. You're talking about the difference of shoehorning a $2500 stills camera into doing the job that a properly-engineered, purpose-built product will always be superior on.
 
PerroneFord;2148733 ...where do you draw the line?[/QUOTE said:
Do you really not know the difference in what is required to do a good job with the 5D vs. the other cameras? None of them require "optimal" conditions. They can shoot anything including fine patterns that destroy the 5D, they work in harsh environments, they are not limited in subject matter and movement they way the 5D is. This is basic stuff and you should know it.

On skill level, I maintain the poorer the camera, the more skill is required. It's harder to light for a narrower dynamic range, it's harder to predict and control for jello, aliasing, and moire. Don't you know that?

Does that draw the line for you? It should.

Leo
 
C'mon, Perrone. Be real.

I'm trying...

The 5D is not designed for this purpose.

Agreed. Doesn't mean it's worthless, or can't peform the duties put before it. I heard all these same alias/moire issues 30 years ago shooting stills. We actually had class assignments to capture them, so we shot chrome car grills or screen doors. We used to see it on the nightly news when Walter Cronkite would wear a bad tie, or on 60 Minutes when Andy Rooney would wear a particularly bad jacket.


It can cause shots to go straight to hell.

Operateive world is CAN. I've shot 2 movies on a 5D and I shoot twice a week on the T2i and not ONCE have I lost a shot to aliasing or moire. Doesn't mean the cameras won't exhibit it. Just means it's not as prevalent as some would have us believe. And a great deal depends on the subject material.

The Red, the F35, and film will never do that.

Sure they will. I've seen moire pattern off film from the 60s. And I've seen the RED blow up highlights just like any other video camera will. I remember reading about how one DP was disappointed with how the Genesis blocked up in the blacks, and gave some ugliness on skin tones as they fell into shadow. All cameras have flaws. Just depends on how hard you want to nitpick them. The 5Ds certainly stand out more than a RED's or a F35s, no question about that.

You're talking about the difference of shoehorning a $2500 stills camera into doing the job that a properly-engineered, purpose-built product will always be superior on.

Yea, maybe so. But what is the RED if it's not a $20k camera shoehorning into a job best left to 35mm? Each have their limits, though the limits may well be quite different.
 
Do you really not know the difference in what is required to do a good job with the 5D vs. the other cameras?

Yes, I know the difference. Frankly, I am just sick of ppundits and people with something to sell saying that people need to buy the latest and greatest product to produce quality work. When the FACTS are people were doing superior level work years ago with cameras that aren't 1/10 of what is available to us today. My first commercial piece was shot in the 80s on a VHS camera. As was a LOT of the commercial work back then. I can remember when Hi8 was good enough for broadcast TV.


None of them require "optimal" conditions. They can shoot anything including fine patterns that destroy the 5D, they work in harsh environments, they are not limited in subject matter and movement they way the 5D is. This is basic stuff and you should know it.

If you honestly think the RED is not limited in how it can be shot, I've got some beachfront property in Arizona for you to buy. Yes, the limitations are less than the 5D, and less than an EX1, and less than other cameras as well. But they are still there.

On skill level, I maintain the poorer the camera, the more skill is required. It's harder to light for a narrower dynamic range, it's harder to predict and control for jello, aliasing, and moire. Don't you know that?

So, why not encourage people to improve their skills? Yea, it's harder to light for 7 stops than 12. Just like it was harder to light for 4.5 stops back in the 80s. And it was harder to make sure you didn't get any strong sources in frame so it didn't flare. And it was harder to do a LOT of things. Technology got better.

I am not the major defender of DSLRs. I was VERY late to the game on them because I didn't believe in them. I still mistrust them for a lot of work. But I have the luxury of shooting on other cameras. I chose my EX1 instead for my last film because I knew I'd need a lot of movement and I couldn't lock down the sets the way I might have liked to. But that doesn't mean the DSLRs are not viable tools. You work with the tools you have. Those who say the 5D are the ONLY tool you ever need are delusional. Just as those who seem to claim the 5D cannot produce good work. Two sides of the same coin as far as I am concerned.
 
And there is your answer, right there. You ask why there's the combativeness, and then you make a statement implying that a still camera is technically superior to a product you haven't used or seen, even when the 5D has demonstrably got serious issues that the new product doesn't.

If you want to stop the war, you'll have to stop lobbing grenades. :)

Ummm...Barry, I believe that statement I made is what is commonly known as an example of IRONY.
Seems like we are a bit emotionally over-invested in this, no?

Well, at least you put a smiley face there at the end.

Further, what totally amazes me is how quickly some folks adopted completely partisan positions, when they really don't have to.
Because that is what exactly this thread turned into. Very instructive in it's own way.

So to remind you all the point of this thread:

The unnecessary AF100 vs DSLR polemic
.

1) These cameras don't need to be mutually exclusive. Yes folks they actually can work together.
2) The reality is that MULTICAM is an unexpected and perhaps even more important offshoot of the DSLR revolution.
3) The inexpensive nature of DSLR's make them likely companion pieces for some time come.
4) DSLR's will continue to evolve, just as video cameras will. No reason to get stuck on the particular shortcomings (or strengths for that matter) of one particular model today.*

*Which is just as true for the AF100 as for the 5D Mark II.

Pronouncing "the death of (fill in the blank)" is really silly.
Just as silly as saying someone else is not a pro if he or she decides to shoot a video with a DSLR two years from now.
The business of trying to predict the future or defining what constitutes a pro based merely on a different set of choices than one's own, is a very tenuous one indeed. And completely unnecessary.

So get over it folks.

And have a nice day.
 
Last edited:
ive shot films with the 5d and whats looking great are DOF shots. close ups. anything with DOF.

but if it involves electric lines, any kind of lines, detailed bricks, any patterns, you're F~cked. it even aliases on gravel, and grasses/foliage.

so for me, if i want a wide deep shot, i wouldnt use a 5d as its gonna f~ck up the footage real bad.
I wouldnt use a 5d for an entire scene unless the scene passes my checklist. lines, patterns and fine details
 
Ummm...Barry, I believe that statement I made is what is commonly known as an example of IRONY.
Seems like we are a bit emotionally over-invested in this, no?
Not at all. My response was emotion-free. But I was very sure of what was gonna happen next, and ... it did. So like I say, people should quit lobbing grenades if they want the "versus" to stop.

Further, what totally amazes me is how quickly some folks adopted completely partisan positions, when they really don't have to.
Because that is what exactly this thread turned into. Very instructive in it's own way.
But not new. We've seen this a million times.

4) DSLR's will continue to evolve, just as video cameras will.
Doesn't this fall under the category of "predicting the future"? :)

No reason to get stuck on the particular shortcomings (or strengths for that matter) of one particular model today.*
Actually, though, there is. And that is, there has been a huge wave of misinformation propagated about what these things can and cannot do. And it's gotten to the point where it's really -- there is no better word for it -- ridiculous. I saw a guy shooting a 40-minute press conference on a 7D. Why? It's absolutely the wrong product for that job, but there's been so much hooplah over the "DSLR Revolution" that it seriously seems like people are (and yes I'll say it) AFRAID to be seen shooting on anything else. It's comical. And sad. At the same time.

It's also unhealthy for the business, and for the client. I stand for the triumph of reason and rationality over irrational hype. I say we find out what these things can do, and what they cannot do, what jobs they're best suited for and what jobs they are ill-suited for, and make that information available, and let each individual pick what they want to use. And if something new comes out that's better-suited for the purpose than what someone is using today, well, that's gotta be just too dang bad.

As for worrying about the particular strengths or weaknesses of today's model: People are shooting today. Future models are irrelevant -- they need to know what today's products do. I think people should be aware of what the strengths and weaknesses of the available products are. And when there's a chance that they could end up with lousy or even unusable footage, I think that they need to be forewarned so that they can make an educated choice. What I find unacceptable is if someone listens to the hype, thinks "oh, this new $2500 consumer stills camera is as good as a Red, I'll shoot my footage on it" -- and then gets screwed and comes back and says "why didn't anyone tell me?!?!" At least some of us are trying.

I'm the first to say the AF100 is not a jack of all trades. There are some things it does really well, but there are some shooting scenarios that it's not best suited for (such as sports, or news). I have no problem pointing that out. Just like I have no problem pointing out that the DSLRs are problematical for many shooting scenarios, including anything long-duration, sports, news, live events, or anything involving wide-angle deep-focus shots.

Pronouncing "the death of (fill in the blank)" is really silly.
Okay, then how's this: the AF100 will not "kill" the DSLR.
It'll just drag it in the alley and kick the **** out of it.:nads::grin:

The business of trying to predict the future is a very tenuous one indeed. And completely unnecessary.
Fortunately we don't really have to. All we have to do is look at what's available and announced, and decide what we want to use on our current projects. The future will take care of itself, and every one of us will be shooting on something different five years from now, than we're lusting after today. Even the Red users, who thought that they were buying the end-all, be-all, "obsolescence is obsolete" camera, are trading it in just two years later for the newest, modular, end-all-and-be-all, "obsolescence is REALLY obsolete!" model. And two or three years from now, they'll likely do it again.

The ONLY thing that matters, the only thing that's relevant, is what we can work with right now (or, what we'll be working with when we actually do start working).
 
Last edited:
I'm having a hard time understanding what the status of most dvxusers are. People on here act like they are constantly putting out feature films that have major distribution or footage that is being broadcast on major cable networks all the time. I would think that the farthest MOST people's footage is going is vimeo or youtube. Yes an af100 is a great camera and so is a dslr. Both can produce great images for web based content. If you're "so" professional then why are you not shooting on film or RED? Some of you get so caught up in camera specs that you forget that there is a world of avg people who is prob your audience that don't care what youre shooting on and are actually impressed by dslr footage. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-rqu-hjobc i know a lot of people can find 1000 things wrong with this video but its been viewed by 1,000,000+ people and avg people who don't care about cameras used, like it and I feel like at the end of the day this is all that matters along with getting paid for your work. Some of yall need to come to grips with yourselfs. Why are you spending $5000 on a camera when you're more than likely producing a video that you're not getting paid for and you're prob coming out of pocket to produce along with only 500-1000 people will see when you can do the same thing for $800 and the people that see it will prob not think twice weather or not it was shot on an af100 or dslr. I understand we love cameras but make smart financially decisions as well.
 
Last edited:
You ask why there's the combativeness, and then you make a statement implying that a still camera is technically superior to a product you haven't used or seen, even when the 5D has demonstrably got serious issues that the new product doesn't.

Ummm No, Barry. I made a joke.
Kinda says it all that it was taken seriously though.


But that's ok I forgive you.
Every proud parent has the right to think their new baby is the most beautiful.
Even if it is a little bit irrational.

:violent5:
 
Last edited:
They are all just tools in the tool chest. And while I may really like my fancy magnetic philips head screwdriver, I'm not going to use it when a flat head is demanded.
 
C'mon, Perrone. Be real. The 5D is not designed for this purpose. It can cause shots to go straight to hell. The Red, the F35, and film will never do that. You're talking about the difference of shoehorning a $2500 stills camera into doing the job that a properly-engineered, purpose-built product will always be superior on.

It's very understandable why non-technical people have a hard time sometimes understanding these things. What constitutes good enough and what is "shot straight to hell"? I've sat in a pre-production meeting for a feature where a potential DOP explains in a "matter of fact" tone that the new Red camera is OK for some things, but you can't do fast pans or shoot wide daylight exteriors with it (or something of the sort). The director, who was not technical and had shot on film his whole career, just accepts this explanation. Now someone else comes and says 5D sometimes produces unusable results, however, the RED will never send a shot "straight to hell".

It has to be admitted that this all is quite relative and people have very different standards on what they consider usable. Also people on the producing/directing side sometimes run into camera wielding people who simple do anything to push the technical part of the project forward, sometimes at the expense of other factors (production design, shooting days, etc) and sometimes they will use hyperboles, trusting nobody else understands what they are talking about and just accept whatever toy or format they fancy using.

Not saying there aren't good reasons not to use the 5d. But if an Ad agency requests a 5D and then doesn't change it mind when the DP says it not usuable ... let's say I'm not very shocked.
 
Back
Top