Tired of the unnecessary AF100 vs. DSLR polemic.

Even so the AF100 should be a significant improvement. Just because Barry, or some others, likes the AF100 for the things he shoots doesn't mean a DSLR isn't right for you, but most people aren't shooting only music videos. A movie has different requirements.

I understand Barry's position and he and I have had some go-rounds on this and other matters. For me the problem was that certain people proclaimed the DSLR's "unusable" and frankly that's B.S. I looked at my renders last night from my sports footage, shot at 1080/30p. It looks terrific. Even though I had low light. And I was able to get some excellent still shots on the same lens just moments later.

I was a late adopter to the DSLRs because like many others, I just didn't see them as game changers in the world of "video". I still don't. I do see them as game changers in the world of hybrid capture (stills and video) and they have certainly made wonderful inroads into microbudget film.

But as this thread tried to say from the beginning, why is there SUCH railing against the idea of co-existence? These product (AF100 and that ilk and the DSLRs) can easily occupy the same set and do different tasks.
 
+1 again.

DSLRs are great for what they provide. Great motion video at a cheap price. And yes, that can be good enough for you, your shoot, your project.

BUT, notice the one limiting factor in those above statements? YOU. You and your production are the limiting factor. I personally have been shooting with video for a few years. Never shot a film, I've done many hundreds of short vids. Never worked on a proper production set.

I think slot of us are in that situation. We shoot video for clients or for these little music videos, weddings, shorts or whatever. In the end, most that are making these comments and "judgements" have never been part of a proper large production. We don't actually know the demands there and we really don't have the experience to comment or make recommendations.

DSLRs are capable, and on big sets as House has proven. However, that doesn't mean there can't be another/better tool for the job. And I fully believe that often people get by with DSLR because it's what they can afford, and it's all they know, NOT because it's the best tool for the job. I'm all for the cheap cams bring huge quality to the masses, but let's be honest, just because our camera can shoot 1080p doesn't mean we really know how to make a proper production.
 
I shoot with a GH13 because its the best i can currently afford. Simple

I have just lined up a couple of music video's and will re-invest the money into a AF-101 because thats how far the money will go.

If i line up a few big one's i'll grab a RED.

Not too fussed tho, just love shooting, and think i am ALREADY getting results, even with just one GH13

you can judge that for yourselfs if you wish - :grin:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpqf6GF3WlU

I admire the passion involved on both sides of the argument tho.... you lot clearly feel strongly about your craft !
 
Last edited:
often people get by with DSLR because it's what they can afford, and it's all they know, NOT because it's the best tool for the job.

And this is exactly what I said to an interviewer yesterday who tied to bait me into saying that this camera is a DSLR killer. I stand with what I said in that interview and that is that this camera, the AF100, was designed for folks that want shallow depth of field and an HD video camera. We saw our customers putting 35mm adapters onto their HVXs and HPXs and thought there has to be a better way of putting a product together for that target customer. Someone that only has $2500 to spend is not necessarily going to fork up another $2495 to buy the AF100, they only have $2500. For those that have the money, the AF100 has the toolset that will service the need; shallow depth of field, no moire or aliasing, great audio and VFR in 1080p.

I too am pretty tired of this DSLR vs the AF100 and while the original post said he was tired of it, he threw gasoline on the fire with what he thought was a joke, about his technically superior 5D cameras. I didn't read it as a joke. The 5D will deliver technically superior still shots, granted, but I would challenge that concept in the world of video.

Anyhow can we get back to talking about stuff that can be beneficial?

Best,

Jan
 
Jan,

While your around, I do have a question regarding this AF100.

Firstly, thanks for giving some shape to the mission of the camera. It seemed positioned as an HVX200 with a big sensor, and that appears to be what you're saying. More than once I've been frustrated with Panasonic's decisions to go 95% on these cameras and then just leave that last bit out. The AF100, for me, seems to follow in those footsteps in at least one regard. It's a brilliant concept, and while I am not the biggest fan of the m43 system I understand why the AF100 has it. But I cannot understand why Panasonic chose to leave it with the codec it has. While I am pleased that Panasonic is moving away from thin raster codecs, it just seems crazy to me to leave it at 24Mbps and 4.2.0 color. Yes the codec is efficient. But why not offer a 50Mbps AVC option (aka an AVC-Intra lite). Honestly, the camera deserves it, and it really completes the offering.

And lest anyone reads this as me taking cheap shots at Panasonic, I said the same thing about the Sony EX1. Awesome camera, left short by a dumb codec choice. Especially since Sony already HAD the codec at broadcast bit rates in other models.

Jan. Is there a possibility of pushing that AVC codec in the future with a firmware update? With Sony, potentially Canon, and JVC perhaps looking to make competitors, I'd imagine this would be one weakness they would attack off the bat.

Just curious and I'll understand if you'd rather not answer.
 
Multi-cam interviews with DSLR's? Eeewww.... 'Hindrance' would be an inadequate word...'impossible' might be more like it. I was thinking indie film work, where all scenes are few minutes max. Being able to play with experimental projects at a low/no budget level is just plain fun. For paying gigs, I'll stay a bit more traditional in my equipment selection - I've had enough grief in my life already.
 
And this is exactly what I said to an interviewer yesterday who tied to bait me into saying that this camera is a DSLR killer. I stand with what I said in that interview and that is that this camera, the AF100, was designed for folks that want shallow depth of field and an HD video camera. We saw our customers putting 35mm adapters onto their HVXs and HPXs and thought there has to be a better way of putting a product together for that target customer. Someone that only has $2500 to spend is not necessarily going to fork up another $2495 to buy the AF100, they only have $2500. For those that have the money, the AF100 has the toolset that will service the need; shallow depth of field, no moire or aliasing, great audio and VFR in 1080p.

I too am pretty tired of this DSLR vs the AF100 and while the original post said he was tired of it, he threw gasoline on the fire with what he thought was a joke, about his technically superior 5D cameras. I didn't read it as a joke. The 5D will deliver technically superior still shots, granted, but I would challenge that concept in the world of video.

Anyhow can we get back to talking about stuff that can be beneficial?

Best,

Jan

Something beneficial:

Good news everyone. My friends and I have put our resources together ( about 23$ ) and have driven around montreal to find the best tools to create a time machine that will allow December 18th to come faster than you can imagine

So far we have a prototype:

Time%20Machine.jpg


will keep you posted.


but in all seriousness. The release of this cam cannot come fast enough! My mouth is watering to use it.
 
Perrone,

If you want me to answer that question then ask it in a thread of its own, or search my posts on this site as I have already answered that question. To answer it here serves no purpose other than to have it buried one more time.

Thanks,

Jan
 
Perrone,

If you want me to answer that question then ask it in a thread of its own, or search my posts on this site as I have already answered that question. To answer it here serves no purpose other than to have it buried one more time.

Thanks,

Jan

Understood,

Sorry, didn't realize you had answered it. I'll go do a search!
 
For instance, I can use my wide angle TS lens at the angle it was intended for and for which there is currently no equivalent in 4/3".
Curious, what angle of view are you finding that there is no 4/3 equivalent for?

in saying that only one camera can solve all my problems is ridiculous.
Is anyone saying that? I think we've all been pretty consistent that there is no such thing.

Though I imagine it is comforting to think that one is enlightened and everyone else is not, if they have not made the same choices.
Yes, that does seem to be a rather pervasive attitude. I prefer to explain what each product does, and let the end user decide for themselves what is best. Jerry Seinfeld did a bit where he talked about cell phones, and what is it with everyone wanting you to buy the same cell phone that they bought... same thing.

One of the reasons I wanted to test it is because I would like to do quick pans occasionally without some of the standard DSLR issues. Sadly, I found the Panny did not perform particularly well on this front. I found a strange kind of stuttering or breakup occurred around verticals in the pans and the Panny rep couldn't explain it. Probably it's the bitrate.
Would be interesting to know what issue you're talking about. I have quick-panned the AF100 to death and not found any issue. And the bitrate yields footage that is superior to breakup than the DSLRs so that most certainly shouldn't be the issue. And this same codec has been in use in HMC150s, HMC40s, and HMC80s since 2008, so if there were a problem with the codec surely we would have heard about it by now. Did you record this footage with this issue? What frame size, what frame rate, all that stuff...
 
Barry, thanks for your efforts in keeping us informed. I've had stunningly consistent "good to great" quality imaging on the 150. I've had some pretty good wow video too. It's been a great format to shoot in and with uncompressed audio a major limit o the 150 is now greatly improved in terms of the ability to handle certain sound environments. I can also hope that the headphone out is also a lot cleaner. The 150 does have some background hiss or something that's present at high monioring levels. Overall shooting to SD cards on the 150 has been a dream but it does require a mental focus when handling the cards. You have to have a clear system for transporting, backing up, handling.. the whole deal. It isn't as care free as the P2, but it's also not a media that requires a lot of worry and or consternation, Albeit with the exceptions to the rule which are on the forums about cards going bad. Moving from a limiting p2 workflow I now get to have somewhat of a smug disposition. When people ask how much memory you have and I get to say "lots" or enough us to go and shoot a 24 hour film contest and never stop shooting or some derivative.
 
That is all I needed to hear from you then. I understand at the end of the day you have to sell a product (af-100) but the way you've been downplaying dslrs you would think that they are completely useless tools for filmmaking.
I don't have anything to sell. Well, I sell books, but I don't sell cameras.

As for a DSLR for filmmaking -- people are doing it all the time. Check out the thread from Marlon Ladd on "The Jones'". It looks fantastic. I wouldn't do it, I find the workability issues simply not worth the hassle. I'd much rather work with a product that provides the minimum basic featureset that I like to work with. Other folks have different standards.

What I find abhorrent about the DSLR is the prospect that by its very nature it might ruin shots. That when you shoot wide-angle, or anything in sharp focus, if there are repeating patterns in your scene, it might lead to a blurry wash of purple/orange all over your footage. I find that completely unacceptable. And, I just don't like the limited ability to work with them. I bought two of the things -- a 7D and a GH1. I tried to work with them. I even used the 7D for some of the scenes on my new Lighting For Film & Television DVD. And after its limitations screwed the pooch on one particular shot, I said "never again".

We used a GH1 for two multi-award-winning films. I've been there and done that. And I really, really don't want to have to do it again. For those who can't possibly afford any other alternative, and who don't mind working with the limitations, hey -- some gorgeous work can be done with one of those. But what I don't understand is -- if you had any possible other alternative, why wouldn't you take it? I sure would.

Speaking of this all can you help me understand the perks I am getting as a music video director seeing that I don't record audio and moire and aliasing is not a big deal to me?
Perks of ? Of an AF100 over a DSLR, or ?
The main imaging benefits of the AF100 over a DSLR are the incredibly reduced aliasing, the elimination of the purple/orange moire, and an overall sharper image, and the elimination of the fixed-pattern noise, and the ability to do a wide variety of framerates in slow- and fast-motion, at 20 different framerates in 1080p, and a more-robust, artifact-resistant codec.

Other than that, the main benefits of the AF100 are workflow related. Single-system audio, incredibly wide range of lens options, exposure tools like zebras/spotmeter/waveform, stuff like that. Workflow things like if you wanted to attach an external recorder, you can, and you can even output 1080/24pSf. Ability to connect to professional monitors through HD-SDI, and to professional mics through XLR input, including line and mic level, and supplying phantom power. Remote control of focus, iris, and start/stop. Simultaneous viewfinder and LCD panel so operator and 1st AC can each have their own display. Focus position to the foot and inch, and zoom position in millimeters, read out on the display. Ability to record longer than 10 minutes (up to 12 hours in one continuous take). Freedom from overheating so the camera will always be ready to shoot no matter what. There are dozens and dozens of workflow improvements and such, that you may or may not find necessary for your work.

If you don't find any of those workflow features necessary, and you don't mind the aliasing and moire issues, and the time limits aren't a problem, then the DSLR may very well be the ideal solution for you and the additional cost of the AF100 might be complete overkill.

Right now my reason for buying is I'm sure my immediate competition will not be able to purchase this cam so I will be able to provide a different look from all the other music video directors using dslrs. I'm not really sure it will bring me more customers per say but I guess it would boost my ego. That counts for something right? lol
Well, again, it depends on how you work, and it also depends on whether your clients care about what type of camera you're using. If one client chooses you over someone else because you've got a bigger/fancier/more-impressive camera, well, that may seem silly but hey, if that one job brings enough dough to pay for that camera, then it was worth it, right? On the other hand, if no client cares at all about what camera you're using, and neither do you... then ... why spend a dime more than you have to?
 
Last edited:
Something beneficial:

Good news everyone. My friends and I have put our resources together ( about 23$ ) and have driven around montreal to find the best tools to create a time machine that will allow December 18th to come faster than you can imagine

So far we have a prototype:

Time%20Machine.jpg


will keep you posted.


but in all seriousness. The release of this cam cannot come fast enough! My mouth is watering to use it.

Awesome..... but what sensor size is your time machine and has it shallow DoF enough.....? ;-)

My cine rental guys here in Germanistan tell me they may have "The Thing" end of November - so I have hope but also my doubts....
 
Last edited:
man time is flying faster than I thought, Barry it's already november 4 you promised footage by late november I think it was? Can you say roughly when, are we talking november 20+ that you will have final production model ACVHD footage? Or more like early december?
 
Curious, what angle of view are you finding that there is no 4/3 equivalent for?


Is anyone saying that? I think we've all been pretty consistent that there is no such thing.


Yes, that does seem to be a rather pervasive attitude. I prefer to explain what each product does, and let the end user decide for themselves what is best. Jerry Seinfeld did a bit where he talked about cell phones, and what is it with everyone wanting you to buy the same cell phone that they bought... same thing.


Would be interesting to know what issue you're talking about. I have quick-panned the AF100 to death and not found any issue. And the bitrate yields footage that is superior to breakup than the DSLRs so that most certainly shouldn't be the issue. And this same codec has been in use in HMC150s, HMC40s, and HMC80s since 2008, so if there were a problem with the codec surely we would have heard about it by now. Did you record this footage with this issue? What frame size, what frame rate, all that stuff...

I use the Canon 24mm TS, and occasionally I rent their 17mmTS as well.

I think the one and only type mentality (not saying you have it) is inherent in the whole moving on to the next greatest thing. It seems like people need this in order to reassure themselves that they have made a good investment.

I guess what I have been saying is that the days of reliance on a single camera are waning. I know that many clients for instance would prefer to have 2-3 inferior cameras, than a single RED today, and NOT because they are not knowledgeable. They want more dynamic edits and greater choices than before. I really do believe that DSLR's have profoundly changed things that way. I don't think that the genie will be put back in the bottle on that one, and I know that my business has more than doubled since last year in the midst of a recession merely because I have decided to completely embrace this. As a result I think many people and clients will become accustomed to having multiple cameras and even camera types on sets. How many of us can afford 3 fully configured RED's + lens packages on a set? Not many. But we can all more or less get our hands on a couple of DSLR's and a Panny, with photo lenses. That is a profound shift.

In terms of the pans on the AGF101, unfortunately I was not allowed to keep any of the footage, because they didn't want it out in the public domain before a specified release date. I would describe what I saw as a sort of rolling shutter artifact where the top half of a frame was leading in advance of the bottom half, so a vertical element like a light post gave the impression of ghosting if I did some quick pans. Very strange. I know that the DP whom I came with was like "no way" and was pretty disappointed. Don't want to scare anyone here, but I was a little underwhelmed to be honest. Who know maybe they had a problem with that particular body...
 
In terms of the pans on the AGF101, unfortunately I was not allowed to keep any of the footage, because they didn't want it out in the public domain before a specified release date. I would describe what I saw as a sort of rolling shutter artifact where the top half of a frame was leading in advance of the bottom half, so a vertical element like a light post gave the impression of ghosting if I did some quick pans. Very strange. I know that the DP whom I came with was like "no way" and was pretty disappointed. Don't want to scare anyone here, but I was a little underwhelmed to be honest. Who know maybe they had a problem with that particular body...


I can't imagine what this might be, but it has no relationship to what the AF-101/100/105 is was or will be. Would you kindly PM me with your name and your DPs name, where you are from and I will track down and find out what it is that you saw. We are a pretty tightly knit group here on this camera.

Best,

Jan
 
man time is flying faster than I thought, Barry it's already november 4 you promised footage by late november I think it was? Can you say roughly when, are we talking november 20+ that you will have final production model ACVHD footage? Or more like early december?
We're rescheduling our stuff, will be shooting after Thanksgiving. In the meantime, I'm sure some footage will come from the forthcoming Japan trip next week.
 
In terms of the pans on the AGF101, unfortunately I was not allowed to keep any of the footage, because they didn't want it out in the public domain before a specified release date. I would describe what I saw as a sort of rolling shutter artifact where the top half of a frame was leading in advance of the bottom half, so a vertical element like a light post gave the impression of ghosting if I did some quick pans. Very strange. I know that the DP whom I came with was like "no way" and was pretty disappointed. Don't want to scare anyone here, but I was a little underwhelmed to be honest. Who know maybe they had a problem with that particular body...
Ah. Not to worry. They were probably using the GH1's LCD on that preproduction model, and on that LCD ghosting is a well known phenomenon on the GH1. Freaked me out when Jack and I encountered it on the set of "Depth of Phil", I can assure you! But it's strictly an LCD issue, it doesn't show up in the footage. And the AF100 production models will have a substantially improved LCD over that one. So basically what you're describing will have nothing to do with the AF100.
 
I use the Canon 24mm TS, and occasionally I rent their 17mmTS as well.
I get much wider fields of view with my 7-14 lens. It yields equivalent FOV to the Canon when the Canon is using about a 13mm lens. You can match 17mm on the 5D with 9mm on the AF100, and you can get that from a couple of Olympus lenses or the Panasonic 7-14 zoomed to 9mm, or of course if you can afford it you could get the 8mm Master Prime and be wider too.

The idea that the m43 format can't do wide-angle is an incorrect notion. The m43 format has lenses that can go wider than any currently-available lens I'm aware of for a "full frame" camera.
 
Back
Top