"Grid Down" a film by Shawn Nelson

The title makes me automatically think of cannibalism. Long pork they call it.
It makes me think of a few other things that I can't write. Hopefully they are included...
Looking forward to checking it out.
 
Actually, the title reminds me of my experience at the 'Great San Diego Blackout' of September.

It was actually a little spooky.
 
Actually, the title reminds me of my experience at the 'Great San Diego Blackout' of September.

It was actually a little spooky.

Precisely, what I meant. When the power goes down and stays down... people go hungry.
Water & ammo become currency. It really is a scary premise.
 
SPOILER REVIEW: Do not read further if you haven't watched the short:

First off, I came into this with high expectations. The Rook Moves still is in the back of my head as one of my all time favorite DVX shorts. No pressure, huh? Well you did it to yourself! :grin:

The good: I REALLY like the lighting in the opening scene (even when the lights go out). Actually, I liked the lighting in every scene. Also, your set design was stellar. As was audio. The whole thing was top notch from top to bottom. Very very nice. Great costuming as well. Your lead male really sold the whole piece as well. Very emotional and believable. Beautiful final scene. This piece felt like a part of something bigger. Something that I would watch, too. I was really drawn into this. Oh, and last but not least, the music in this was perfect.

The not as good: I would say first off the compression. I'm assuming that from the 100mb limit. It created odd banding on the atmosphere that I know wouldn't be there on your camera. The slow motion water at the very beginning confused me. I didn't understand why it was slow. Also, the lead woman seemed a little stiff turning on the water in the bathroom. Almost like she was sidestepping the sink.

Favorite part: Neighbor comes in with a ... combat shotgun?! What is that? I didn't see it coming, and I seriously said, "Ohhhhh!" out loud.
 
REVIEW!

Alright so I was definitely looking forward to this one given your thread and past entries, and I definitely enjoyed grid down

What I liked - the environment that your characters were in was sold really well. The boarded up windows were a nice touch, though they did seem a little pointless in the situation as they didn't seem very secure, though that was all an afterthought so it didn't affect the story negatively to me. The image was nice and crisp, and some of the shots had really nice lighting. Also the main guy did a very good job

What I didn't like as much - let me preface by saying some of this is little things that are definitely opinion based, and I have always had high expectations for your work and in turn I tend to nitpick a little more for stuff like that.

Ok so first, I loved your lead actor, the guy was awesome, but the woman I was not a fan of. Most of her dialogue seemed forced and emotionless. The lighting on the man when he asks about going in to work in the beginning when he is at the window. I don't know what it was but it just seemed really weird to me. As mentioned earlier the compression hurt the visuals a little as there was some banding going on in the environment, but I try not to be too tough on that as we all had to deal with that. Lastly, the concept is great, the actors did pretty darn good, and visually it is stunning, but plain and simple, to me this is not a 6 minute story and that hurt it. It would work great as a web series or a longer short/feature maybe, but in my opinion you are missing a lot of the chaos in the beginning of the outage, as people begin to realize what will happen, and of course, it was a very open ended ending. All that to say that I think 6 minutes was too ambitious, but on the flip side I would REALLY love to see this thing expanded!

In short, it was a GREAT film, looked awesome, and had some solid acting, but I would have loved to have more of a closed story (though that probably isn't possible in the time frame)
 
As usual, really well done Shawn. A good story well told gets me everytime....and you always come through.
It's nice to see a positive message in films these days.
Congrats to cast & crew!

:thumbsup:

Spoiler:

Here are my thoughts & questions:
- actors did a great job.
- Loved the set design, but yes, those boards would have done nothing to keep people out...but who cares...it's a film people!
- comments on compression, banding & pixel-peeping should be a non-issue in a fest like this.
- Was the guys wife pregnant?
- I don't think the Army guys would just take his word that he sold the gun...that through me a bit.
- They really should get a peep-hole on that front door!
- "Don't go in there today"... was that the required line? Seemed a strange thing for her to say...
- Everything was top-notch! (shot choices, edit, CC, SFX, dialogue, score, etc.)

Hawk: Neighbor comes in with a ... combat shotgun?! What is that?
I have a Mossberg 12 gauge pump with the same folding stock and heat shield ...so, no surprise for me!
(don't come knocking at MY door when the grid goes down :happy:)

Lastly... This was a scary subject to think about (that's why we should all have some supplies at hand), but wasn't a 'scary' film to me. Just the same, one of my favorites because of it.
 
Slept on it

Slept on it

Well I slept on it.
I couldn't figure out why I couldn't give this high marks.

The acting was good
The look was good
The mood was great

And yet I didn't like it when it was over. So I slept on it.

Spoiler: What would have worked for me
The end wasn't strong enough to make it an ending after the quality of the first half.
For it to work for me I needed that last scene to be haunting - I needed to see the city in chaos from a distance - I needed their reaction on their decision - I wanted to see them look at where they were going and have "a moment" where they look at each other - and confirmed without words that they were committed to each no matter what they were going into face. That would have sealed what at least I think the story was partially about.
Hope this is good feed back.
 
Thanks everyone! I deeply appreciate the commentary.

And on the banding...yeah, h264 is maddening. I wish we could just go Vimeo with this, then we could all upload 500mb files. I made a 300mb 720p file that still had some banding, but looks a lot better. I played that on my AppleTV at my wrap party last night.

As for the open endedness of it, that's very deliberate. Does a DVXUser entry have to be a closed loop?? Several crew argued with me and said dvxusers will penalize me for not serving up the dvxuser cliche'd twist/close final beats. Perhaps. Though I'd like to think I could do the opening note of a saga and still do well in a fest, I guess we'll see.
 
I loved the look of this film, I was pissed when it ended, I wanted more, I wanted to see some of the adventure they were going on. I dug the atmosphere in the room, made for a nice warm look with the sun coming through the boarded up window. The acting was really good, although the youngest girl was the weakest link. Thought she could have been more convincing, but dont get me wrong, she was ok. And I dont feel it hurt the film, But as A director, i'm pretty anal about acting.
 
I've watched it and suddenly it was finished... Which means I liked it.

It has a kind off open end...If this was the first of a serial...I would watch the next one.
 
At first I thought the guy was simply behind on his bills and they were cutting off his utilities. Until the 18 days text. Then I had to rethink what was going on. The cut to 18 days later seems a bit radical. They went down that fast? I couldn't hear the guy outside speaking at 1:30. Okay - it's the cops. Wanted his gun just like that in the states? When ya pry it from my cold ... No water? They couldn't survived 18 days without it, so they must be scrounging somehow. Love the acting! Interesting gun the neighbor has there. How can you tell a shotgun isn't cocked and a shell fed? I know it's "Grid Down" but I've been without electricity many time for a week plus - no big deal. We enjoyed talking, board games, and candle light. Now lose water - that's another thing. Very harsh. Hard to see if that was smoke in the electrical corridor. If so, was it to mean an attack of some kind? Wouldn't they have know? Loved the acting, loved the cine, story - needed more fleshed out.
 
Hmm, it looks good and the actors did great, but it's a scene. Well a couple scenes. We see now, then bam jump 18 weeks, then a little conflict and then over. This really pulled me in and then done. It really needs and deserves more time. You gave us a tasty bone to chew on, but not enough meat. Was it scary, yeah enough I would say. Overall good job.
 
Drama ensues.. Oh the drama.

solid entry Shawn! I'm not sure it was really scary in terms of the festival specs or expectations, but that's all subjective. Much like art and music. Who's to say what's scary? I know if my wife was preggers and we were without the subtleties of life, I'd be pretty damn scared in that situation. It makes you ask.. Who do you trust and how far are you willing to go to protect those you loved?

That is where I wish you kept going with it. Chop it in half and continue to story to give us a clear solid ending. Give us another another final act of the leads that they were truly 'neighbors'... not just a couple who gave them another 'shot' of life. Walking away 'into the sunset' left me with questions of what happens next. Perhaps throw in one last stand with the law and a choice your lead is left with again to protect his family.

push it further. either that, or write a 4 page script to nail the limitations of a 6 minute festival entry.

Can't wait to see what you come up with next.
/j

btw.. not sure what's up with that new epic, but i expected some better CC. Seemed very flat to me. no punch or range of colors. :)
 
Back
Top