OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
Ki Pro Mini from B&H - $2000 + Battery Source + CF Cards = yikes...

This thing is $345 with build in battery and you can get three 256GB SSD's ($500 a piece) and have just hit the cost of the KiPro mini by itself, with 1.5hrs of recording time. That's not too shabby. Also consider you could just get two hard drives and swap them. Dumping time for one of these drives is insanely fast. It'll be done copying and ready to go before you likely start shooting with the other one or soon after you start.

I guess I'm not seeing what you guys are seeing. All I see is beauty with this thing...minus a few unanswered questions like how can I mount it.
 
it would have been nice if they could made it roll over recording, at the gigabytes you'll be eating up. 10 bit uncompressed yuv quicktime is a little over 7 gb a minute.

but I love the fact that it's no frills. simple, to the point. I honestly always hated a lot of the touch screen stuff with some of these recorders that's only doing 10 bit 422. this means the BM unit is gonna be more rugged, nice and light, lower power consumption, and no worries of not being able to use the unit if the "screen dies"

uncompressed workflow isn't as intimidating as people think. the reason it's so cheap is because it IS so simple, and they don't have to pay licensing fees to apple for pro res, avid for dnxhd, and to cineform (now with gopro) just a rugged hardcore unit that does 1 thing and 1 thing only. record 10 bit 422 at all the single link framerates and resolutions.

if you really just want to have pro res HQ from start to finish, shoot to SSD, and dock it to a computer, and transcode to your offload drives. encoding from no compression is a lot faster than encoding from something with compression. there's no decompression factor before the compression. OR if you think your computer isn't up to snuff to give you adequate speed in encoding. you still have options

encode later, delete uncompressed files.
or, and this may sound complicated but it really isn't. at the price of this unit, have another one, hook it up to their ultrastudio. capture in real time from the filled up SSD to pro res HQ. may sound redundant, but it's a standard workflow for a lot of high end digital cinema cameras to do real time capture after the highest quality footage is shot, especially with high speed cameras. at the pace an average commercial, feature film, short film etc. goes, there's more than enough time to do that, and it would still cost less than an average high end laptop.
 
Yep, that's another thing I see people liking this for. Anyone who wants to get away from the Prores doesn't have to start with it anymore...yes it still requires transcoding but now you can pick what you want later. Hey...it's a step forward in the right direction for some of you. Stop waiting for someone to make a recorder that lets you do Cineform, Prores, and all that in one.
 
This will not KILL the Nano, ki pro, etc. It only records uncompressed video as far as I can tell. I as well as many others need compressed (less compression than in camera) video for daily use and uncompressed is just overkill for most work and introduces a much tougher workflow
 
The price is way cheaper than P2 cards - one Intel 600 GB SSD comes at 939 Euro and records one and a half hour of uncompressed 10bit 24p - so what´s the point?

The point is that uncompressed 10-bit 422 runs at a maximum of 237 MB per/sec, or 834 GB per/hr. (That megabytes.)

p2 footage is compressed and runs at a maximum of 100 Mb/s. (That megabits.)

You have to compare apples to apples, not Mac pun intended. That's the point I'm making.
 
Do you really believe that the pixel size difference between a 1/2" sensor and a 1/3" sensor results in a difference in precision equivalent to 1024 steps vs 256? I find that hard to believe. Especially from what I've seen from the hpx370's 1/3" chip (which I'm guessing are going to be the same chip in the hpx 250) with the noise reduction turned off compared with an ex1 on the same shoot.

Not exactly what I was getting at. The ex1/r with an SNR of 54db only benefits from a 10-bit pipeline when the sensor is at it's native WB (5600k), you are throwing plenty of ~5600k light at it, and you're at 0db of gain. When all the circumstances are correct, the S/N is just good enough to actually benefit from a storage format recording more than 8 bits. Otherwise, the noise is too much, and it gets dithered right back down to around 8 bits worth of distinguishable chroma and luma difference. Almost everything I shoot with that camera is going to a 10-bit container, I've had plenty experience with it's shooting circumstances and it's 10-bit post. It really is on the edge of benefiting from 10-bit, with 3 1/2" sensors regarded for (at the time) their low noise. So yes, I believe with even smaller chips, the edge would get crossed and the benefit (or at least, most of it), will likely disappear. That, and the fact Panasonic never shares their SNR numbers. That does nothing but worry me. It does seem however that they have at least released the S/n ratio for the 370, which clocks in at 56db. So if the new Pannys do share the same chipset, and exactly the same processing, then they could have an edge. I just feel that the high end processing in the 370 that retains that snr will not get carried over to this new, more affordable line.
 
Last edited:
This will not KILL the Nano, ki pro, etc. It only records uncompressed video as far as I can tell. I as well as many others need compressed (less compression than in camera) video for daily use and uncompressed is just overkill for most work and introduces a much tougher workflow

I don't understand what makes it tougher? If you have this kind of file from the camera you can trans-code it to anything you want including Prores. Yes the other recorders do it right to Prores for you already, but anybody using the on-board codec is already transcoding on import (many are), so what's the difference? I don't plan on editing the Uncompressed files, and I doubt most buyers of this plan to either.
 
Not exactly what I was getting at. The ex1/r with an SNR of 54db only benefits from a 10-bit pipeline when the sensor is at it's native iso, you are throwing plenty of ~5600k light at it, and you're at 0db of gain. When all the circumstances are correct, the S/N is just good enough to actually benefit from a storage format recording more than 8 bits. Otherwise, the noise is too much, and it gets dithered right back down to around 8 bits worth of distinguishable chroma and luma difference. Almost everything I shoot with that camera is going to a 10-bit container, I've had plenty experience with it's shooting circumstances and it's 10-bit post. It really is on the edge of benefiting from 10-bit, with 3 1/2" sensors regarded for (at the time) their low noise. So yes, I believe with even smaller chips, the edge would get crossed and the benefit (or at least, most of it), will likely disappear. That, and the fact Panasonic never shares their SNR numbers. That does nothing but worry me.

Yeah, but what I mean is from comparing footage from the hpx370 and the ex1 in the same conditions, the hpx370 outperforms the ex1...and that's with the 370's awful noise reduction turned off. So I believe if the hpx250 is using the 370's chips, it will absolutely benefit from 10-bit. The 370 certainly does.
 
The point is that uncompressed 10-bit 422 runs at a maximum of 237 MB per/sec, or 834 GB per/hr.

p2 footage is compressed and runs at a maximum if 100 Mb/s.

You have to compare apples to apples, not Mac pun intended. That's the point I'm making.

So on more expensive P2 cards, I can record less time in less quality for a higher price.
I want the best possible quality with cheap (MB per Dollar), available, non generic media off the shelf.

Yeah, and compressed material at 100 Mb/s is a bad thing in my book.

Frank
 
Incredible for the price. How can you complain about the price? What's the next best option for recording uncompressed? If you have a project that needs uncompressed, then you have the budget to buy plenty of SSD.

For the F3, this is a no-brainer. It's be "nice" if it did HQ ProRes...just for the convenience of skipping L&T in FCP...but that might all change tomorrow anyway...
 
Yeah, but what I mean is from comparing footage from the hpx370 and the ex1 in the same conditions, the hpx370 outperforms the ex1...and that's with the 370's awful noise reduction turned off. So I believe if the hpx250 is using the 370's chips, it will absolutely benefit from 10-bit. The 370 certainly does.

Definitely, check my post again. I added to it after finally finding the S/N numbers for the 370. Like I said though, what worries me is that the high end processing in the 370 that is a big part of that s/n will not get carried over to this new affordable line of cameras. We just saw the same thing happen with the sony f3 and fs100. The fs100 uses the same chip, so everyone was expecting the same DR and s/n. Sadly, they skimped on the processing and the s/n took a hit. We'll just have to see!
 
Incredible for the price. How can you complain about the price? What's the next best option for recording uncompressed? If you have a project that needs uncompressed, then you have the budget to buy plenty of SSD.

For the F3, this is a no-brainer. It's be "nice" if it did HQ ProRes...just for the convenience of skipping L&T in FCP...but that might all change tomorrow anyway...

Yea we'll see what Apple has up their sleeves. Either way the speed of SSD copying (as opposed to the transfer speed of CF cards) and there being no need to decompress the file before compressing it for transcode to whatever editing format you'd like to use, I bet this method is actually FASTER, if not really close anyways.
 
You shooting uncompressed?

yes sir, to either uncompressed 4:2:2 10-bit, or to Cineform @ film scan 2 most of the time. But this is enough off topic chat for me.

Now I want one of these recorders! At this price, you can even get away with picking one up and using it as a stopgap measure until you can afford something else.
 
So on more expensive P2 cards, I can record less time in less quality for a higher price.
I want the best possible quality with cheap (MB per Dollar), available, non generic media off the shelf.

Yeah, and compressed material at 100 Mb/s is a bad thing in my book.

Frank

Why compare the cards then?

Not every shooter will want or need to shoot uncompressed.

So comparing p2 card pricing with SSD card pricing provides what insight into what?

Each product has a target market and user and ultimate delivery medium. But pejorative comments about p2 card capacity and price serves what purpose?
 
Last edited:
Definitely, check my post again. I added to it after finally finding the S/N numbers for the 370. Like I said though, what worries me is that the high end processing in the 370 that is a big part of that s/n will not get carried over to this new affordable line of cameras. We just saw the same thing happen with the sony f3 and fs100. The fs100 uses the same chip, so everyone was expecting the same DR and s/n. Sadly, they skimped on the processing and the s/n took a hit. We'll just have to see!

Possibly, but the 370 and 250 shoot to the same codec and medium, so I think it'd actually be easier to use the same processing than develop new processing that's worse. The AVCCam versions of the HPX250 on the other hand will likely have worse processing just like the F3 to FS100...but of course they'll be 8-bit anyway so it won't matter.
 
Back
Top