OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
Good grief LOL. Is there some sort of memo I missed that states I must use whatever format a recorder records to for editing? We wouldn't say that about the AF100's AVCHD would we? What makes this any different? Even an HVX had to process the footage off the P2 Cards to unpack it before you could really do much with it.
 
Good grief LOL. Is there some sort of memo I missed that states I must use whatever format a recorder records to for editing? We wouldn't say that about the AF100's AVCHD would we? What makes this any different? Even an HVX had to process the footage off the P2 Cards to unpack it before you could really do much with it.

Currently I'm just in the habit of Keeping masters of my work in the recorded format. Recording uncompressed would make me have to change my ways.
 
Then change your ways...just pretend the Prores file you transcode to is your master :) Anybody using a KiPro would have to do the same...
 
A $345 device that let's me chose what kind of compression I want to work with in post (not that I would compress) and have uncompressed master footage standing by?

Sign me up!
 
Then change your ways...just pretend the Prores file you transcode to is your master :) Anybody using a KiPro would have to do the same...

Yeah that's probably what I'll end up doing.

Store them on normal HDDs, they are cheaper than SR tapes now.

Frank

Yeah I thought about that as well. My habit has me a half full closet of D5 tapes from when I used to shoot a lot of film, might have to make room for some hard drives too.
 
For me I am thinking of scenes where I am doing visual FX work. With this and a decent sized SSD my cost footprint is so much lower than any other option. I have no problem myself with the AF100 codec on almost everything I use it for. But for that last little bit where I do need the 4:2:2 to make my life easier, this is great!
 
This is a real bargain at this price. As someone else pointed out earlier, it's a nice design concept, very simple looking. Not sure it will be a direct contender to some of the other recorders ( the Sound Devices recorders look amazing ), as it's essentially a headless device.
 
I have to agree that having 10 bit uncompressed master footage is great in this form factor and price.

My only concern is that storing and backing up that data, apart from the price of acquisition media even with projected price drops, is a factor that has to be taken into account.

Tape backup for 10 bit uncompressed will take forever, and redundant magnet media will also get pricey.

That being said, this portend the future.
 
I have to agree that having 10 bit uncompressed master footage is great in this form factor and price.

My only concern is that storing and backing up that data, apart from the price of acquisition media even with projected price drops, is a factor that has to be taken into account.

Tape backup for 10 bit uncompressed will take forever, and redundant magnet media will also get pricey.

That being said, this portend the future.

I think it's good to think about the now, but yes let's consider that the near future holds large SSD drives at lower costs. If we keep sticking to tape based mechanism or magnet media, we're going to continue to spend much more money than we actually have to to archive and backup.

IT's a good time to begin phasing out moving parts and tapes, this is a great step toward that as there's no quality compromise to begin with.

When SSDs are larger and cheaper in the next two years, the shift we take now will make more sense.

Let's also consider the cons of TApe Based Archiving and Magnet Media: That means the deck must exist from now until eternity, and manufacturers and service centers need to stay alive in case decks go down. Not to mention, again, production costs of the actual media, keeping factories open for niche tasks such as, where as a Hard Drive manufacturer has a much greater purpose in our current society, extending beyond the media industries to simple tasks and computing.

The beginning of a shift isn't always easy for everyone, especially those long established in a certain way, but by the time we hit the large transition it'll be a lot easier...

... And I won't have to sit at a desk to watch down a tape for three hours... blarg.
 
I have to agree that having 10 bit uncompressed master footage is great in this form factor and price.

My only concern is that storing and backing up that data, apart from the price of acquisition media even with projected price drops, is a factor that has to be taken into account.

Tape backup for 10 bit uncompressed will take forever, and redundant magnet media will also get pricey.

That being said, this portend the future.

Of course. I think that a lot of us have really gotten spoiled with the use of cheap media storing compressed footage. At least for now, with the current price of SSDs, this device reminds me very much of the film workflow, where the first thing you had to do was calculate the total amount of rawstock, processing and printing/transfer costs. Just like with a film, or highend tape productions, budgeting for your storgage needs, based on anticipated total running time and shooting ratio is going to be something that using a device like this is going to necessitate. That is not a negative. It is a consideration.
 
How long would it take to compress 60 minutes of uncompressed 10-bit 4:2:2 to something like ProRes or Cineform ?

I just did a test. 1 minute of 10-bit 4:2:2 to Prores in MPEGStreamclip. I was reading from the same HD that I was writing to in the transcode and it took 1minute 30seconds even on my 4 year old 2xdual-core 2.66GHZ MacPro.

Imagine doing it from one hard drive to another that's hooked up via FW800, thunderbolt, or what about trans-coding the footage reading from the SSD to a GRAID FW800, the read speed would be insane. When you consider the slower copying speeds of CF cards, I think things even out somewhere.
 
i'm hoping apple with their FCP update will have a wicked new version of compressor, full 64 bit overhaul, and lightning fast. Honestly, things like mpeg streamclip and media encoder are really great. and snappy. but I've done a great deal of encoding tests, and I feel like nothing really encodes truest to the original source image than compressor. media encoder always made it over saturated and expanded the contrast. mpeg streamclip always boosts the gamma a touch. I blame it on quicktime all together, but with a really optimized 64 bit encoder (mpeg streamclip isn't even 64 bit) batch encoding on set for editorial from uncompressed shouldn't slow anybody down anymore than offloading from media cards.
 
this device reminds me very much of the film workflow, where the first thing you had to do was calculate the total amount of rawstock, processing and printing/transfer costs.

Come on David, a 600GB SSD for 950 Euros lasts about one hour (24p 1080 10bit) - more than you usually shoot at one day.
If you buy two and download one while shooting with the other one, you can go on for ever. and they are - contrary to film - reusable. So for 2000 bucks you get 2 hrs of "reusable stock"- how much did we get with P2 for the same money?

Frank
 
Can someone confirm at NAB with the BM folks if they intend to have a compressed codec for this baby? Thanks.
 
Back
Top