Low-mid budget Run and Gun cameras in 2021? Sony Fs3?

Good food for thought Samuel. AF would be very useful, but I've not ever had it in all my camera work so will manage without it. Is IBIS more important? It's hard to say - it'd be nice to be mobile with less rigging. Both features are beneficial for my work - it seems unlikely I could have both at this price point. Good to have pragmatic expectations about the S5's AF if I do go that way.
 
Fuji x-t4 has beautiful image, IBIS, 4K 50p, 10 bit internal, better AF than Panasonic, small and unobtrusive...
 
I actually discounted the xt4 early on, will revisit it now I have a little more clarity about my options. We used a friends xt-2 for a little extra coverage at a gig a few years ago, and was surprised by how nice the image was. The company my Dad works for it getting taken over by fujifilm in the coming weeks, so he'll have a staff rate as well..

But aside from AF, the feature set does seem more geared to photography than video vs the S5. Internal 4:2:2, scopes and waveforms, 5.9k out, better DR, but the Fuji as AF and produces a beautiful image in camera.
 
The DR is (notably) less. It seems like a camera aimed at people who are photographers and dabble in video.
.
 
The X-T3 was a very popular and successful camera, and the first larger-sensor 4K/60p mirrorless. It scored a pretty decent dynamic range on CineD's lab tests, but those are what they are, and not for everyone (but they do seem consistent).

The X-T4 just never quite caught on the same way with 2020 being a very big year for cameras. And not enough internal change for people to care.

For continuous and reliable results, Fujifilm's focus will let you down as well, eventually. It's Sony or Canon...that's it, very unfortunately. (Hopefully RED keeps improving.)
 
Good to know re: the AF. I think at the moment it looks like the s5 or perhaps a second hand Sony Fs5 is the way to go for me. The blackmagic pocket 6k looks very interesting with the ND filters, but likely a bit too much rigging needed for my style of shooting.
 
My opinion about ND is that to me it's only really worth it if it's electronic because you can then beautifully massage it if you're attempting to shoot at a consistent aperture.

With the traditional 2-4-6+ stop rotating filters, I often found myself switching back and forth between strengths and discovering that sometimes they are too much or not enough and I'm unwillingly adjusting my aperture and/or shutter speed.

Obviously, I'll take any internal ND versus none at all, but a nice variable ND is really useful too.

I am about to pick this one up. 1.5-11.5 stops covers anything I could possibly use it for, and the 82mm size will be able to adapt to smaller lenses with step rings.

https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1576590-REG/b_w_68_032182_82mm_true_match_vari.html

Always having the 1.5 stops isn't ideal, and I'd much prefer a thumb dial that can cycle through electronically rather than sometimes loosening the filter while turning it or putting smudges on the edges of the glass, or moving it from lens to lens, but there are always compromises as you most likely have learned by now in this thread (if you haven't before).
 
Once you get accustomed to the Sony variable ND (which first appeared on the Fs5, I believe) it's hard to go back to anything else. Especially for working quickly.
 
Thanks all.

I’m going to go with an s1/s5 (both are reasonably similar, with trade offs on either side that aren’t a huge deal to me - so will go on price) or a second hand fs5 from eBay, which is a similar price to the s5/s1. Need to sit down and do a side by side, and consider how important ergonomics is to me vs weight/inconspicuousness/packability (contradictory things I value).
 
i think fs5 is the way to go if you really want the video camera body, nd, controls, etc. but i don't think the low-light performance will compete with the s5, even with a speedbooster? i'm not sure. and i don't think it has usable af. dynamic range may be lower. and a lot of people don't like the colors from the camera and find the log footage tough to grade. Not to mention that it lacks IBIS and gyroscope data for post stabilization. but people have shot great-looking stuff with it. both options have their advantages.
 
Last edited:
IMO, besides the obvious eND, all the FS5 has going for it is the small body with switches (WITHOUT its accessories built-up).

Everything else is inferior to the S1/S5 including the image (which the FS5 requires an external recorder to look its best).

You named it all...definitely worse in low light, no AF, no IBIS, older S35 sensor (from 2015) vs. the full-frame one.

The eND is worth its price. But is having a camera body making it faster to switch WB or gain presets/etc. better than everything else in the S1/S5, I don't think so. Especially when the final product (the image) is most important (at least to me).

And if you're trying to sometimes stay inconspicuous, you'll have to learn to love the EVF, lol.

Sony FS5 Mark II.jpg
 
The Fs5 does have AF, and it's passable. In face detect mode I find it pretty decent, as long as you don't throw anything too challenging at it. It's not great, but it can work (although it pales in comparison to the AF on the FX6—but that's an unfair comparison).

The EVF is terrible, as is the stock LCD. I know some people relied on the EVF but in three years of owning the camera I'm not sure I ever used it in a real world shooting situation.
 
Meant no modern AF like touch/object tracking, sensitivity controls that actually work well, and in low-light it's practically useless (but you can stay that about all of the cameras back then before 2015).

Maybe for simple interviews it would be passable for the OP.
 
Yeah, I'm mostly thinking about it being "good enough" + better formfactor with built in ND and XLRs (I used my gh4 as a b-cam to an fs5 II a couple of years ago on shooting a live performance in a club, and the colour, low light and DR was still much better than my gh4, even if not quite at the standard of new larger sensors). But, I'm going to do some looking at different rigging options with the s5 and Panasonic's XLR hot shoe (or maybe a juiced link if I can find one second hand) to see if I can rig it up in a similarly ergonomic way (top handle, shoulder rig) without it becoming finicky and janky.
 
Yup, that's right...which is why it will never happen.

Even if it's "phase-detect" it will be defined by its programming.
 
PS - I did a studio dance shoot on Saturday with 3 Sony cameras (a7siii, 2x a7riii). Sony AF is amazing. We quibble over the drawbacks and limitations. And to be sure, this was an easy shoot from the standpoint of finding the subjects because the background was low-contrast white walls or black fabric. But the AF just handled it so well. I set all cameras to the same AF settings at the beginning and never had to change it. Dancers flying around, the camera whipping around them, it didn't matter. I'm not sure which is better - how much faster you can shoot that way than manually, or the fact that you nail shots that would be nigh impossible manually.

And as for what the cheap gear can do these days... At one point, the director (a dance photographer) wanted a high-angle shot and suggested we use a ladder. But I put the ronin-s on a light stand and hoisted it up so I could circle around the dancer with the camera at that angle. Then when I boomed down, the director used her iphone to tilt up the ronin because I couldn't reach the joystick. And every change of rig/iphone remote connection is so fast. We were flying.
 
Ideal use of technology.

As far as AF, when you're frequently filming moving people or wide-open FF interviews, there is just no better feature you can have in your camera.
 
Back
Top