Low-mid budget Run and Gun cameras in 2021? Sony Fs3?

I don't think it's possible, but if there is an adapter to mount MFT lenses to the L-mount, you could use the 12-35mm in the camera's pixel/pixel mode. Not sure about the quality and if the S5 has it, but if you're not selling the lens - and if it was possible - you could get that super tight once-in-a-blue-moon shot here and there (or use it as a regular lens if the quality is decent).
 
Well the S1 is currently on sale here at the same price as the s5. I was under the impression that the s5 had more of a video focus with features, when I was reading about it a few months back? Do the recent firmware updates address those things the s5 improved?

On Panasonics tech specs online, they list 150mbps as max bit rate, and don't mention anything about all-I, so other than recording limit I don't see any big advantages over the s5.

the s1 can shoot 6K with the new firmware. It can only shoot long-GOP. I'm a big fan of shooting long-GOP. As far as I can tell, the benefits of all-I is mostly that the computer and editing program can read it more quickly and easily. I don't think there's much if any difference in visual quality. But I think that most computers can playback the long-GOP without too much trouble. Or else convert it to proxies.

Personally, I see the big difference between the S1 and the S5 as being the weight. The S5 is 5.9 x 4.3 x 3.8" and 2.25lbs whereas the S5 is 5.24 x 3.82 x 3.23″) and 1.57lbs.

But you can buy the S1 used for less money than the S5 new at this point, if that's a consideration.
 
And interesting point about IBIS being pretty useful VS Sony/Canon's better autofocus (and inferior stabilisation). Both are features that are a bit more forgiving on the kind of operating I do.

Canon's IBIS seems to be better than Sony's although perhaps not as good as Panasonic's. The Sony also uses an "active" IBIS (ie electronic stabilization) as an option on top of the mechanical stabilization. It crops the footage 10% but it brings the stabilization close to Panasonic performance, and I use it often. I would much rather have Panasonic IBIS, however.

And check out that newsshooter review - the face-tracking autofocus on the S5 might be good enough for an interview
 
Also, the S5 has an S&Q mode on the dial but S1 does not. I think I come down squarely in favor of the S5 for you.

You can adapt FD lenses to the L mount. WHich FD lenses do you have?
 
Thanks for all the feedback and input guys. It's been hard to wade through all the options that are on the market now (last time I deep dived into the low-budget end of cameras, there were really only a few options to choose from - Panasonic, Canon 5D and blackmagic - been quite an explosion in things in this price bracket since then).

Also, the S5 has an S&Q mode on the dial but S1 does not. I think I come down squarely in favor of the S5 for you.

You can adapt FD lenses to the L mount. WHich FD lenses do you have?
I just have a 24 and an 85. But I shoot my photography on a Canon FD mount camera (just a hobby), so there is an appeal to building up a nice set of primes that I can also use for my hobby.

Canon's IBIS seems to be better than Sony's although perhaps not as good as Panasonic's. The Sony also uses an "active" IBIS (ie electronic stabilization) as an option on top of the mechanical stabilization. It crops the footage 10% but it brings the stabilization close to Panasonic performance, and I use it often. I would much rather have Panasonic IBIS, however.

And check out that newsshooter review - the face-tracking autofocus on the S5 might be good enough for an interview

How does that Sony 10% stabilisation compare to using NLE's inbuilt stabilisation tools?

the s1 can shoot 6K with the new firmware. It can only shoot long-GOP. I'm a big fan of shooting long-GOP. As far as I can tell, the benefits of all-I is mostly that the computer and editing program can read it more quickly and easily. I don't think there's much if any difference in visual quality. But I think that most computers can playback the long-GOP without too much trouble. Or else convert it to proxies.

Personally, I see the big difference between the S1 and the S5 as being the weight. The S5 is 5.9 x 4.3 x 3.8" and 2.25lbs whereas the S5 is 5.24 x 3.82 x 3.23″) and 1.57lbs.

But you can buy the S1 used for less money than the S5 new at this point, if that's a consideration.

They're also the same price new here, at the moment, with a few sales on the older S1.
 
How does that Sony 10% stabilisation compare to using NLE's inbuilt stabilisation tools?

I think it's the exact same type of thing in theory. Although the in-camera stabilization is probably just lateral pixel moves and none of the warping/distortion that NLEs will do

The in-camera stabilization has the advantage of relying on the camera's gyroscope to know just how the camera is shaking. Whereas the NLE is guessing based on changes in the image. So, the in-camera stabilization has that major advantage.

Which can be translated into NLE use by turning off the camera's IBIS and then loading the footage into Sony Catalyst Browse which will use the gyroscope data to stabilize the image. I've never done that, but it looks like it does an incredible job at the expense of large cropping. But supposedly you want to shoot high shutter speed for best results.

It's all sort of a moot point if the sony A7SIII is more than you want to spend. But if you wait 6 months or a year, they may come out with the sony a7iv which may do 10-bit (who knows) and be like an S5 with some pluses and minuses. Better AF for sure and most likely the same IBIS situation as the A7SIII. Probably $2500
 
To expand a little on my 'C100' answer earlier for 'Low-mid budget Run and Gun cameras in 2021?'

I would be looking for a camera with ND filters. Its the basic thing that makes cameras usable in 'run and gun situations'

And in terms of budget that is probably LS100, C100 and FS700 of which theC100 has some form of usable AF does it not ?

Obvisously with more money one can get get c300, C300ii et al.
 
Well he needs $10000 :)

Ive have bad experience with (tiffen) VND but maybe thats just me. (The FS100 in portugal needed a 6stop+a VND to be at F11 - it put me off for life)

Recently ive been on my nikon Z6 and its already filter chaos. I think I put the 6 stop in my movi case and no idea where the clear one went so Im wandering around with the shiney new 24-70 element exposed to the elements and the 3 stop flopping around naked in my billingham beg getting nicely dulled and fingerprinted up in the bag with my cheese sandwiches, choccy bars and covid hand gel, which Ive lost the lid for.

Its my first no filter camera since the FS100 and it's horrid.
 
I do need $10,000, maybe we can organise a wee whip around? As briefly outlined in my OP, I don't do paid video work full time, and don't really intend to (it's a side gig and hobby to may day job as a market gardener - which isn't exactly a million dollar salary!) so I can't reasonably justify spending a lot more. I've also been off work for a long time due to a surgery just before christmas, so funds are a little tighter as well.

As for built in ND filters - sure they're great. But aside from taking them on and off with fixed ND filters, whats the big disadvantage to a VND that lives on lens VS inbuilt selection in camera (like the c100 has)? If it lives on lens, you don't have your "bag full of too many accessories" issue? Sure, most start at 2 stops or so, but if you're in dark enough conditions you can probably take it off without too much hassle.

But I do appreciate your perspective as someone shooting in this way more often than I, and someone who's had the luxury of inbuilt ND filters! Certainly I very much appreciated them when shooting in patchy cloudy conditions with the Sony fx6 the other week. I struggled to keep things exposed well on the gh4 (no NDs tho), while my colleague with his fx6 managed to keep pretty perfect exposure ("perfect" in the context of the style of doc we're shooting)

But he needs 4K slow motion? And good low light? And he could use a vari ND?
I could live without 4k slow motion, but in 2021 it feels like it already makes things a bit dated. It's been an occasionally frustrating compromise on shoots with the gh4 over recent years, particularly as I use slow motion on most corporate shoots (gets me out of jail when I'm asked for 30 seconds of b-roll of someone using a scanner and I've only got a few minutes to set up - so minimal lighting and no sliders etc).
Yeah, good low light is important - it's been probably one of the most frequent hindrances for my work with the Gh4.
 
I think it's the exact same type of thing in theory. Although the in-camera stabilization is probably just lateral pixel moves and none of the warping/distortion that NLEs will do

The in-camera stabilization has the advantage of relying on the camera's gyroscope to know just how the camera is shaking. Whereas the NLE is guessing based on changes in the image. So, the in-camera stabilization has that major advantage.

Which can be translated into NLE use by turning off the camera's IBIS and then loading the footage into Sony Catalyst Browse which will use the gyroscope data to stabilize the image. I've never done that, but it looks like it does an incredible job at the expense of large cropping. But supposedly you want to shoot high shutter speed for best results.

It's all sort of a moot point if the sony A7SIII is more than you want to spend. But if you wait 6 months or a year, they may come out with the sony a7iv which may do 10-bit (who knows) and be like an S5 with some pluses and minuses. Better AF for sure and most likely the same IBIS situation as the A7SIII. Probably $2500
Yeah it's moot because of the price of the a7sIII - unless something comes up at a good buy second hand. I was mostly just curious about how well it compared theoretically to the more powerful computation of a proper editing rig. But being able to use the cameras gyroscope isn't something I considered and makes a lot of sense.
 
And in terms of budget that is probably LS100, C100 and FS700 of which theC100 has some form of usable AF does it not ?

Obvisously with more money one can get get c300, C300ii et al.

I suppose the pocket 6k should be added to that list (no AF)
 
Reading your op mentions xlr short setup times doco work “a proper video camera” and a million things that says c100
 
Reading your op mentions xlr short setup times doco work “a proper video camera” and a million things that says c100

Yep. It does have a few limitations that might make it less viable for me (where a little more manual control and little extra set up time affords some greater options with the compromise of SLR form factor). It's certainly a lot of compromises at this price point. As a counterpoint, which I didn't bring up, but I have occasionally found it very useful to shoot on what looks like a hobbyist photography camera. We shot a project in a conservative area of morocco, where video cameras would've caused problems for the subject we were working with (being a couple of white people in her village was already a bit controversial) so going with a wireless lav and a naked handheld mirrorless camera got us coverage we would never have gotten. Obviously that's a very niche scenario, but I have also notived some interview subjects are more relaxed in front of a small SLR/mirrorless vs a bigger more built up "professional" looking rig.
 
You should wait until NAB if you can...maybe something new will catch your interest in 2 weeks (although availability will most likely be at a later time).
 
It's actually in October this year. [facepalm]

Was supposed to start in 10 days. Didn't even notice the new date that was changed a while ago.
 
About the S5 autofocus, ahalpert seems confident, but my experience with DFD autofocus in the GH5S (great camera for the money in many ways) has not been encouraging.

The initial acquisition is okay, but it will periodically wobble slightly off-focus and back again, as if to check for best focus. You can barely tell it does this if you’re staring at the in-focus subject. However, if you have ‘bokeh balls’ in an out-of-focus background, they cyclically grow and shrink in a very obvious way during this quick autofocus wobble.

Does this matter? Depends whether you need a professional sheen to your work, I suppose. I’m no pro but I can’t stand it.

With moving subjects, the GH5S autofocus is near-useless in 24p mode. Often loses focus entirely and takes seconds to slowly get it back. Works a bit better (still unreliable) at higher frame rates.

Otherwise the S5 is interesting for having a huge amount of video features that no other full-frame camera has at a similar price. The IBIS is also impressive:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XojLmiYr3Ho

Though for a static shot, any IBIS is probably fine – but then why not a tripod?
 
100% accurate. I call it an "AF patience test" and have recommended the bokeh & light grow/shrink test in about a quarter of my posts on here (not really, but I stress it).
 
Back
Top