Empire - Lawrie Brewster - New Age Film

Man when it first started I'm like woah this is looking good already (the effects) the effects are really good! Some of the sound (dialog) sounded like were still in the green screen room. Need some fixing there. Good job on getting extras....or cloning the same person? lol You had some good music flowing in there. Good story too! Great job overall!
 
Visually stunning. So many of the images were disturbing in such a perfect way. It did seem to come in chunks, but the theme was never lost. And the music was beautiful. The only thing that kind of yanked me out of the experience of watching it was the audio for the dialogue – it didn’t sound like it was recorded cleanly and sometimes felt out of place for the setting or for the proxmity of the shot. Other than that it’s a wonderful film and I enjoyed watching it (and will likely watch it once or twice more).

I’d make a joke about why those French soldiers have Socttish accents, but I’m afraid I’d be dismissed as an ethnocentric idiot who didn’t read your previous posts regarding that very subject.
 
Stunning! Disturbing...almost creepy...in a great way. Definately a visual masterpiece. I'm impressed!
 
Thank you gentlemen for the feedback.

As you know Noel no film is complete without a big er furry beasty! I'm also delighted you got the idea - i mean its fairly intepretative but is intended that way too. Too many films begin with... 'we gotta get the stuff but we only got 1 hour!' yeah...

Lawsuit cheers mate thanks i much appreciate your feedback and yep your quite right, i shot/edited/fx it all bar Leo and Sarah's(and act haha) in 2/1/2 weeks to make the deadline but now ive got time to fix it up even better so its deffo on the cards! I'm delighted with your visual poetry comparison as you see that really is the angle here. There is a dreamlike quality (or should i say nightmarish quality.)

Ramsaur thanks bro, ive got a lot of respect for the musicians that helped, but we are going to improve on the soundtrack afterwards as we were totally rushed, and doesnt show these artists (in there own right) at there best! But yes one of my favourites is Sarah's song :)

Landfill yes the story and its mini vignette like depiction really does rely on the mood of the film to hold it together - for those it works with (at least overall) i hope it brings a surprisingly 'big story' (though tbh the story is simple the ideas are 'bigger') i guess. hehe oh and yes thanks for sparing me the joke!!! lol - yep and deffo will fix up your recommendations too.

Thank you HCPROD much appreciated, and yep ALMOST creepy! Just you wait - the next one will be eveeeen MORE creepy hehe!
 
Lawrie...wow...I'm going to have to watch this a few more times before I comment. I watched it twice last night and again this morning. There's SO much to grasp in this one. Standby for review....

(and I won't hold your comments about my 'private collection' against you...LOL!)
 
Last edited:
What a delicious little nightmare. Am going to watch again, but wanted to say I was very impressed with the imagery.

Two things that would make this better:

Sound. The recording of the lines is all over the place. Also, I feel like there was a lot of wind in there to cover up sound flaws. I dunno if you did the mix, or what, but something like this you want a pro on it for sure. Match up a pro sound mix with your visuals and it will send this over the top.

Acting: Nothing against your guys, but the next time you tackle something insane like this, pay special attention to the acting. Getting each and every moment to be extremely truthful is another thing that will send this over the top.

Take a look at Guy Madden, maybe the best "experimental" filmmaker going these days. This reminds me a lot of his work. But he's been doing this for decades and there's a lot to learn from him.

But I really loved this and it's on the list of things to watch over again. Love many of the images, and the mixture of absurdity and abstraction. Right up my alley.
 
Nice work on the VFX- looks like you put a lot of work into it, and it shows. The one thing that really stood out to me was the level of the wind- I think it was too present in the mix and it really overpowered the dialogue at times. I also didn't care for the performance of the boy. But I did like the overall concept / idea. Congrats on the entry. :)
 
I didn't 'get it' but I'm not sure I should.

I like the FAT soldier starving in war time? And the kid's little drawn on mustache, kinda funny.:)oh, I forgot the Yeti, good times.
 
Hi Lawrie,

That was a very complex and artistic film. You can see that there is a large potential of creativity in it - for sure an outstanding work, which isn't part of the usual mainstreem-films. I think you are a very ambitious filmmaker and my first thoughts went to 'Dreams' by Akira Kurosawa. Especially the fragmentary nature and the cold and static atmosphere let me think about it. I enjoyed your film, even if I feel that there is something what isn't really rounded, which let me miss the full impact of an film like one of the 'Dreams'. I have the idea that you have put too much in it and maybe 'Less is more' could help to give it the right impact.

All above very enjoyable and I liked the part of the music very much, which sounds a bit french.

Congratulations

Susanne
 
Bit more for you now Lawrie, having my first coffee and waking up watched it again to kick me off.

First off, as I completely expected, every detail included in the visuals was extremely well thought out. It was like watching poetry.

So, I implore you to do a remix of the sound and get that as sweet as possible. THis would just take it that step further and remove the small distractions.

I loved it.
 
Ladies and gentleman,

Thank you for the kind compliments, and of course the constructive criticisms as well (well... except for you Chris Keaton you can kiss my ass ;) hehe

Yes Mark your quite right, and likewise Noel - i will definately be taking your advice and going over the sound with a fine tooth comb hehe it was really a victim of the time left to get the film done :P

Thank you Susanne also, and yes i immediately rushed out to check out Akira Kurosawa's Dreams, (I'd seen it ages ago) but yes the Snow short story is mystical and magical and i absolutely loved it.

I think mines is a little evocative of that particular short film you mention (albeit nothing ill make will compare with him hah!)

Ryan E - thanks a kind compliment coming from a good DoP like you sir, yep the kid i think is fairly forgiveable however ill definately take into account the wind volumes too.

It is only right to try and keep making this film better as it fulfils an important dedication in my mind also.
 
(I tried to channel the voice and spirit of Lawrie himself in writing this review, so bear that in mind, for those of you who've had your work so deliciously skewered by Mr Lawrie.)

Lawrie what a total trainwreck of visual poetry. It reminded me very much of Dave Mckean's artwork on Acid, Speed and whatever other psychotropic you can throw in there. Maybe a little peyote eh?

The little kid with the painted on moustache... didn't get it the first time watching it (and this is something that begs to be watched again just to be sure you saw what you just saw) and then understanding dawned through the fog of self-imposed psychosis. Everything here was planned, and everything was intentional (except for the inconsistent and maddening sound) and I was more than happy (drugged) to follow you down the rabbit hole.

My what an interesting ride. When my Peyote wears off I'll have to watch this movie again.

I loved your extras and your transitions. Really put the green screen to good use. Some of the acting was weak, but only some of it. The boy in particular was quite painful to listen to. Love the imagery you got with the dancing ghosts. I get the feelign that some clarity of story was sacrificed either for time constraints or for style. Not really clear there.

An ambitius project to be sure and could benefit from MUCH better sound (I get to say it this time) as well as a better choice for the boy. If you fix the sound, please use someone elses voice.

The last shot sums up this film well: it's a picture book come to life. Every aspect of it screams that out.

Thanks for the visuals. Drug fueled or not. :beer:
 
Absolutely loved the scope and imagery of this film. It had a unique visual style that kept me engaged. Awesome awesome work.

On one hand, I did feel disconnected from the story, but on the other, I appreciated that you didn't spoon feed us what we needed to know. I definitely think this is one of those pieces that I think are great, but aren't necessarily among my favorites.

But honestly, job well done. I'm sure it took countless hours of hard work.
 
As promised...my first review of my first fest.

Coming from the Greenhorn of the fest, I assume you will take this review with a grain of salt, but as I am also a movie buff and a juryman of all things gnarly, I hope you accept it with the weight of a thousand worlds.

I will agree with Puck in that the sound was a bit pressed. Not so much the foley or the music, but just the dialogue. Were you to add some grain and little quote cards, ala silent film, it would add a lot to this film, equal to or greater than what the sound took away. The sound only pulled me out a bit, as this was a very visual story and the dialogue was almost an aside from the scope and depth of the story you were telling.

Being that this was an independent short, I would have the nerve to comment on the grade of some of the acting or CGI. So no worries there...except maybe a little less snow. :)

Some Greenhorn notes:

I noticed that in the beginning, it was almost like you cut and paste the shot of the boy saying, "I found it." Not sure if it was a C/P or if the delivery was the same.

The kid is waking up...why can't babies wake up laughing...bah!

On the whole, I think you rocked the road you took, with the best that you could do. For that, I salute you. Good job.

I may write more later after a second viewing, when the kids are comatose and not sleeping like feathers.
 
Hey Lawrie – just adding to this thread and the opinions of your peers some musings of a person belonging to the lay audience...
Let me begin by saying that I remember seeing Van Gogh exhibition this winter. Days after returning back home the memories of paintings still lingered around. Something similar happened when I watched this short film: I watched it once, twice, three times... watched some other short films that are on the list... came back again to your film and watched it again... And every time I saw it I liked more and more the pace and rhythm of the story, the way how the sound is used to contribute to the nightmarish feel of the return journey, the grey-bluish colour palette, the beautiful song from the second part of the film...
Above all, what truly fascinated me was how film seemed as if the work of Hieronymus Bosch was transposed into the world of the moving pictures (this goes especially for the scene of crucifixion and macabre dance as well as the final scene). And although the story is structured as linear narrative I also like to think of its singular scenes as panels within polyptych that can be read independently but which ultimately lead viewer’s eyes to the utmost atrocity of war as represented in the finale. I also like to think of War itself as the main allegorical character of the film and thus see the use of symbolism and subconscious as principles, again close to the work of H. Bosch.
So the bottom line is that (in my opinion) this is a very unique short film. Thus it deserves praise for its originality and non-conformity.
 
Thank you dear, that is the most thought provoking feedback ive probably seen on this forum for a long time! It's a real pleasure to read such feedback thank you very much :)
 
nice music... interesting visuals...

I don't get it.... experimental films generally don't work for me... but they do for others :)
 
Wow... what an vfx undertaking. I bet you guys had a fun time filming this piece. I think the sound levels definitely need some adjustments as it was hard to hear some of the dialog from the sound FX.

way to go out on a limb with this one.

thanks for sharing.
/j
 
Back
Top