Empire - Lawrie Brewster - New Age Film

okay , read some posts, and i really like your comment - challenge - you stated to another poster - articulate your thoughts- and this is why i will say i really like your film - it isn't just that it is different, because somethings that are different will not necessarily motivate or inspire thought, but your film does.
hell with it, here are my thoughts=

i felt cold. the ever going snowstorm kept on blowing and blowing and it never let up and by half way i wished it would so that i could get a better look at what was going on - only that it never did stop snowing! and at first the snow was almost pretty but it got frustrating( it even seemed to garble the dialogue - which i thought you left garbled on purpose ) , and really annoying, and finally the snow left me empty, especially because i knew there was this beautiful world of paint behind the snow, that you left there and then covered up again and again with the snow.... then there is the woman in the house ( maybe the boy's mom - maybe now the boy wasn't even a boy but the leader's personification of his lost innocence as he fights to save what is left of him - he only wants to go home) but he never makes it. the mountain is too high, too cold, they have no food. and there is that monster, and the snow! damn the snow, it marches on and on and on -

like war? like at the beginning of a war all seems clear, motives are defined with political precision ( much like you show with the rows of soldiers ) , there is something to be won.... but after awhile the only thing that is clear is loss. war has and will ravage all, and in every way possible, it will take your soul - like the soldier who'd kill the boy to eat - the soldier who'd do almost anything to be like he was before the war, well fed, and innocent. but... there is the ever blowing snow.

so anyway thats my little thoughts for now!

awesome film.
 
Hi Lawrie,

I loved this... I loved it for many reasons, the artistic VFX look, the haunted scene of waltzing ghosts, the hunger and psychopathic induced vision of the monster, the child subjected to war and the historic relevance. The last point I think people are missing. Whether you get it or not, the foundations of this film is based on historic fact... The French army invaded Russia, taking Moscow and then the winter came and the French were freezing, hungry and hunted, and subsequently were repelled.

I agree that the sound could have been better, and with more time I think you would have done a better job, as no doubt those VFX took long enough. A voice over from a more experienced child actor would improve it also.

Great work though mate.
 
WOW! I really loved the look of your film and it played seemlessly and beautifully! Great job of achieving a great stylized look! The sound was a bit rough in the edits of it (i.e. coming in and out of voices/dialogue) and in the cave, after the officer speaks, there's a voice that comes in that I think was meant to be edited out (not a huge thing, but I noticed it). However, all that is just to say that I really enjoyed this film and your ambition to go for such a hugely stylized piece I think served you very well! Great Job!

Thanks for sharing!
 
Typin' and watchin'

That child has a painted on mustache. I like that.

This is ****ing weird.

The weird/bad sound I feel adds to this piece.

I like the steely blue color grading.

Did I mention this is ****ing weird?

I can't hear half of what the characters are saying, but I don't think I care.

I don't know what's going on, but again, I don't care.

I love the song at the end.

This film is all about feelings to me, not so much story. It's certainly refreshing.

Baby in the snow, ****ing weird.

That's the weirdest DVXuser film I've ever seen. Nice job.

-Joe
 
I used to have this game, The 7th guest for my PC way back in the day, it came with our brand new 233 mhz computer. I was too young to play it and it was about ghosts and death. I do remember the feeling that it gave me tho, as in, it creeped the shi* out of me. One of those, "I really want to play this game cause i'm not supposed to, but I'm too creeped out to."

The point is ... Your film replicates this feeling.
 
Last edited:
Thank you again gentlemen for the exceptional kindness in the time you have taken to provide feedback and discussion for the film's thread.

I'm still writing all my feedback (for all the films) to be performed in the video feedback thread, and i hope you will all appreciate that i will go to the same kind effort you have given me and the folks involved making this film.



Brandon - I hope you appreciate that my post is an attempt to encourage you to engage with subject matter outwith expectation, but with personal impression instead. You may not agree with this philisophy but i do believe that we cannot grow as artists if our work is defined only in comparisons we have of other films - based on our experiences especailly as audience members.

As filmmakers we are not an audience to define films as an audience member, even if that is how we experience a film we watch. As a filmmakers we can only grow if we go beyond that, and it shows first in how we can articulate our thoughts, honestly with other peoples films outwith the superficial concerns.

Ben Sliker - Now that was a brilliant game that i recall (that and Syndicate Wars which taught me a lot about business.) Yep to be honest i toned down this film for the fest to ensure it met the R rating. Probably better for us all right?

Conrad - haha thank you for your candid summary thats quite hilarious and is a great way to provide feedback on films - first impressions thanks !

jai - Thank you for your compliments and suggestions - i take them to account and will look to implement them in the revamped sound edit.

DarkElastic - Thank you for the historical footnote, I had actually toyed with placing a title Moscow circa date etc - with a little text but then this film was never a historical epic, more of a Jacobs Ladder type nightmare which could be applicable to so many conflicts. Agreed about the voice actor also.

Hoz - Excellent impressions you have articulated there, and trust me if you take that approach to any film you will find far greater inspiration for your own works (and not just with film, but literature, art and even life experiences.) Thank you for that very personal and interesting introspection of your experience with Empire.
 
Last edited:
DarkElastic - Thank you for the historical footnote, I had actually toyed with placing a title Moscow circa date etc - with a little text but then this film was never a historical epic, more of a Jacobs Ladder type nightmare which could be applicable to so many conflicts. Agreed about the voice actor also.

The foundations of your story is historic fact... If this was made in a broad way with regards to costume, countries and locations, I would agree. But you have used Russia, you have used the French and you have used Cossacks, etc. So, if you wanted it or not, this is a historic movie, based within an actual failed Invasion.
 
That was quite surreal. You actually caught me lost for words. Weird.:)
I'll have to watch it a few more times I think. Very interesting.
 
Cheers Raptor much appreciated you took the time to watch, yep its a surrealfest - look forward to your thoughts mon amie.
 
hehe. Yeah, I think you have something here that's more than meets the eye and I'd like to spend a few more days with it. It's difficult to explain why. It's a very artistic piece and therefore I want to spend more time with it.

In the meantime, glad everyone else is enjoying it and very well done. Excellent.
 
This one's a keeper!

Fantastic.

i really hope that you include Empire in your erotic video reviews, as if it was made by someone else. :)

To me, it's a very original cinematic journey with many hidden treasures for subsequent viewings. When it's polished, it will be even better.

I liked how you spanned so much time in your story. It's not just '6 minutes of linear events', it's X years of stuff.

I think you should ADR the kid to improve his performance and the audio there.

The scene with the woman was simple, yet very powerful for me. I got chills. It's one of many scenes that make me start to think about symbolism and 'deep' thoughts that usually don't enter my pee-brain.

It exceeded my high expectations, and I can't imagine the amount of work that went into it.
Good going!
 
Thanks Raptor and Tim Joy - yep definately worth considering what you can experiment with in regards to symbolism - i mean in this film is steeped in very 'visual' in your face metaphors such as the crucifiction and the dancing soldiers, and of course the frozen baby too and mother at the end are among my favourites - you note her cot is empty.

Maya Deren as a female director was at the forefrond of what you would call psycho-anayltical symbolism - ie visual psychological references (think sword for penis) nothing new in art, but in avante-guarde film something she helped put into the mainstream (imo.)

Her most famous film in this regard is Meshes of the Afernoon

Oh i forgot to add - remember gents i will be doing all your feedback in the video feedback thread ive done, it will be posted on 10th of August, and will feature short essays of all your work in a nice sexy setting!
 
Her most famous film in this regard is Meshes of the Afernoon

I remember seeing this back in college ... definitely left the screening room with an uneasy feeling. Especially at the time cause I hadn't seen a lot of experimental film.

Although I have to say, it wasn't the weirdest film I saw, we had one that was 15 minutes of black and white flashes with random bits of static for the audio...
 
Yep Ben, thats the interesting thing about avant-guarde film (im terrible at spelling that right.)

You see, we as producers are so preoccupied with entertainment (be it subjective to our chosen genre) ie what is entertaining in the horror genre hardly pertains to the comedy.

In 'art' which is not exclusive to genre whatsoever!!!! Kick the pretentious gimp in the arse if he ever looks down on genre (there are incredible artistic works within it) alongside what we would imagine as arthouse. Which is unfair since arthouse we often typifiy like it is itself a genre.

Words of an idiot - 'oh i dont really like them arty films' - hehe

I watched Tale of Two Sisters recently, Korean Horror film - outstanding and certainly a work of art imo as well. Then you have something with zero artistic ambition like oh i dont know, say any of the Saw sequals. you know?

Anyway back to the point (as i do wander) if we accept the term artistic films, then there objective is not always to entertain. Thus the shock for the typical viewer if confronted with a film that doesnt make them go yey gee what fun. God forbid if it makes them think.

Do all arty films do that? Er no... like anything it is as usual the painful minority that succeed. When films of artistic or intellectual ambition go wrong BOY DO THEY GO WRONG.

Sit through any showcase of senior student short films at a British University and you will be confronted with a gang of would be Voltaire's who harang your eyeballs with the ultimate pretentious mediocrity. (Yes there will be a gem among them) and yes there will also be the stand out among (that establishment of uk style film education) who made a zombie movie - and it will probably suck... but rock on when it doesnt!

It is no surprise that the films with most artistic ambition be them arthouse percieved or genre are among the most outstanding atm.

The Dark Knight proves even blockbuster action entertainment can do it?
Pie on the other scale (Ive not seen it but a worthy indy example.)

Even Romero had something to say in his zombie masterpieces? You Ben had something to say in Desideratum right? Conventional - but with something transcendent above typical tv melodrama.

There are too many here I believe (and i include myself in this assessment) - we all do at times, who create our stories within the confines of correction and expectation - based on very poor understandings of what we think the audience expects, or what they want, rather than what the filmmaker needs to express.

Because there in lies the rawest and most powerful intensity that i think forms the most succesful films of all.
 
Awesome piece of art/film. You would have received high marks on just the technical achievments alone but your follow-through with making it a meaningful, visually arresting, and uniquely stylized take it all the way. If I've gotten the symbolism right, then I think it was very well done. Oh, and I loved the last shot. Very impressive piece Lawrie and I look forward to seeing your work in the future. Great job!
 
Hey there Champloo,

Thanks for the compliments mate, the next film im working on is another short, a modest wee project with a big idea behind it! I'll be posting details of that in the user film section too! Thanks mate again you'll get my feedback in the video review thread!
 
Cripes. Before posting my own thoughts, I made the mistake of looking back a couple of pages, and seeing nothing but rave reviews of the films, with everyone drooling over it & loving what seems to be every aspect of the film ... leaving me to ponder "What, then, is MY problem?".

Which is why I'll probably look like an ass, a jerk, or at least an uneducated, uncultured, Hollywood-spoon-fed-simplton in my feedback.

You state this is your first festival entry for DVXuser, but not that this is your first film ever.

The only thought going through my head as this ended was "What the hell??" ... this was nearly the same thought I had in the beginning, and middle as well. Once I was able to take myself away from this repetitious chant, I realized quickly that this was going to be more of an art film, where really it seems there are no boundaries, rules, or production values that need to be met. Being an art film, I won't comment on the greenscreen/compositing, dialogue/audio recording, computer animation, etc.

So it just leaves me with the story. I didn't get it. Other than there was a child they were trying to protect, a rag tag small group that escaped death from the battle they were in, and one by one lose their minds. Reading your logline AFTER seeing the film, it makes a little more sense ... but the logline (in my opinion) shouldn't fill in any blanks, which in this case it does.

I guess I'm just a bad judge of art films, and really don't know how or what I should be commenting on, because I don't know what the creator intended or set out for the film to be, with regards to story, production value, etc.
 
I guess I'm just a bad judge of art films

I delight in the difference of opinion that leads to an interesting and intellectual discussion that results in shared insight, be that a difference of opinion on the quality of a film- even my own.

But when a chap shrugs and goes... art film... lol, i feel a duty to help.

A bad judge of art films, is no different to a bad judge of genre films, that is he is a judge seemingly incapable of a subjective or even relative response. The need to articulate that with some populist humility ala hollywood spoonfeeding makes the critique all the more staid.

To refuse your own right to personal analysis based on a shrug and a broad categorisation of this film as an art film (a compliment it does not deserve.) says more for you than the film.

If you dig deeper, i think you may find that your own personal perception of this film being artistically pretentious caused for your aversion to it :P I can only imagine that this must be the case based on your hollywood voila line, as your response seems more a critique on the 'type' of film you percieve it to be than the film itself.

So I challenge you good sir hehe, you say yourself you probably look like an uneducated, uncultured, hollywood spoon fed simpleton, well... why not prove otherwise ;)
 
Back
Top