Tired of the unnecessary AF100 vs. DSLR polemic.

yoclay

Veteran
There is so much talk about how the AF100 spells the death of DSLR and FF is not the way of the future elsewhere on this site that I begin to wonder how much wish fulfillment is going on here.
The question that begs to be asked is why do the two have to be mutually exclusive? Why do so many users feel so threatened on either side of the equation?

I think we are all tired of "the death of" and "this vs. that" threads. I know I am.

It is eminently clear to me that DSLR is not going away anytime soon. The cat is out of the bag and it's not going back in. There are millions upon millions of these cameras that will continue to be sold in FF and they will continue to have the video component. It is a parallel market. That's it. Does anyone honestly think that the quality of the video they produce will not continue to improve?

What everyone seems to ignore here is that multicam has become more accessible. Having a 2nd and 3rd camera is suddenly much more financially feasible.
Many people will use them (DSLR's) if only at the very least to augment their primary camera, because they are less expensive and are justifiable in terms of their polyvalence.
Not only in terms of camera bodies, but just as importantly in terms of lenses. Which lenses? Not video ones. Photography ones. Grillions upon billions of inexpensive ones making it easy to have lens "packages" for every camera you own. There are almost no interviews that I do today for instance which are not shot with multiple angles and that is something most clients dearly appreciate.

I have seen the future, and it is MULITICAM.

Would I consider buying 3 AF100's? No way.

Would I consider purchasing a single AF100. Definitely.

But only to augment my two technically far superior Canon 5D Mark II's.

:-)
 
Last edited:
There is so much talk about how the AF100 spells the death of DSLR and FF is not the way of the future elsewhere...

Definitely the introduction of the Honda four cylinder 750 ccm in the early 70's did spell the death for Harley, BMW and Moto Guzzi.... not exactly. But it was the most convenient and affordable way of having a rather big bike for a rather reasonable price.... and it introduced a new principal and did not out-troduce the others. It occupied a new and rather broad slot.

I have seen the future, and it is MULITICAM.

On Monday we will be talking to a DoP about the possibility that we are going so shoot our next project with an ALEXA as principal camera plus his Canon and my - then hopefully arrived - Panasonic AG-AF 101. We will be shooting additional material for this project with the Pana before and after principal shooting... and we may bring a GH13 into some probably very perilous situations too..... this will be fun. The project before the last we shot with two ARRI 416 and in some really itchy situations with a Canon and a GH13. For the last we had a RED MX and a GH13. Meaning: We give a rodent's behind about what "thingie" we use for taking pictures - als long as it full fills the special needs that a project has and helps us cope and balance both the creative and budgetary demands.

Having said this: The AG-AF seems to have the ability to develop real work-horse qualities. Why? Because it covers a lot of ground. Maybe it will be the missing link between what has helped to bring a revolution to "picture taking" and the "old school" of film making - not to the least because with the apropriate adapters we can stay in the same family of cine-lenses if we want and we have a camera really set up and designed for moving picture production with a load of things already implemented we need dearly to a price, well: demanding but reasonable (not for people in Euroland though, as we get charged a tiny bit more by our well-meaning Japanese friends - thanx, btw). The discussion if anything will "kill" any other thing is a bit silly. And a camera is not a monstrance but a tool.

In my biker club then we had one guy who rode the smallest toy - allowed only sneeringly in a club of big bikes: A 125 ccm east German MZ. Everybody made jokes about this "sissy piece of socialist junk ". Yet, they guy could drive like a Tasmanian devil and would outpace some 850 Norton Commander at times.... a tool is what it is. A tool.
 
I agree -- the future is multi-cam -- sooo much easier for cast and crew. Did it for years in SD, can only now afford it in HD. Some may disagree on which is the best way to go, but the fact that we can all do it is awesome....
 
You don't find it a hindrance to shoot multicam interviews with a 12 minute record max on the DSLRs?
 
Undoubtedly a convergence of stills and video is upon us, in that stills photographers will be called upon to do motion and video shooters will provide stills. It's already happening; all my stills buddies are shooting video and our Red furnishes stills for my clients.

However, I'm not so sure about the certainty of a practical convergence of the equipment! Just as the Army rifle designed to fit everyone really fits no one well, I don't believe a convergent camera can be made to do both jobs, still and video ideally. A similar, but quite distinguishably different set of controls and their placement is required for each task. I'm not one to bet against the inexorable march of technology, but I don't believe one camera can do everything as well as purpose-built designs.

Both Red One and the Canon 5DMkII approach convergence and they are used for both tasks, but few would proclaim the Canon to better the Red at video or the Red to best the Canon for stills.

My Leatherman multitool is far better than no tool at all, but I'd much rather have the real thing.

The bottom line is this: how much compromise are we willing to accept?

Good shooting and best regards,

Leo
 
But only to augment my two technically far superior Canon 5D Mark II's.
And there is your answer, right there. You ask why there's the combativeness, and then you make a statement implying that a still camera is technically superior to a product you haven't used or seen, even when the 5D has demonstrably got serious issues that the new product doesn't.

If you want to stop the war, you'll have to stop lobbing grenades. :)
 
However, I'm not so sure about the certainty of a practical convergence of the equipment! Just as the Army rifle designed to fit everyone really fits no one well, I don't believe a convergent camera can be made to do both jobs, still and video ideally. A similar, but quite distinguishably different set of controls and their placement is required for each task. I'm not one to bet against the inexorable march of technology, but I don't believe one camera can do everything as well as purpose-built designs.
Absolutely agreed. I can surf the web and take photos with my phone, but I don't.

My Leatherman multitool is far better than no tool at all, but I'd much rather have the real thing.
This is exactly my feeling.
 
Well, i just didn't get a job because i dont have a 5D.

I'm a HMC150 owner, and since i heard about the A100 (in april i think) i decided not to buy a DSLR.

Two months ago i bought the GH1, to adapt myself to the AF100 workflow. And i tried to do that job with the GH1 (unhacked), but it didn't successful. Some clients here are "blind" about the wonders of 5D.

Sometime ago i was talking to a friend, informing him about the AF100 and he said to me: "BUT THATS A VIDEO CAMERA!", like i was telling him a a crazy idea.

Well my point is: we have to deal with the ignorance of people. I have nightmares to think about the assumption of the market (ignorant people) prefer the 5D over AF100. So all that makes me ask:

How you think would be the best way to prove, to ignorant people, the superiority of the AF100 over DSLR?

Thanks.
 
I'm so tired of the 5D craze.

I've worked on big commercials in which a RED one could've been easily rented and people still went with 5Ds.

It's like a collective hysteria.
 
The DSLR's will not be held in such high regard 5 years from not IMO. They are or will be dead in terms of being used for semi and pro video. There were the start of a revolution! But I highly doubt that a camera can be both a great still cam and a great video cam at the same time. Forget the form factor, what makes the AF100 (and all the soon to come large sensor vid cams to come) so great is the low bypass filter! Aliasing is gone! It's a video camera and not a still cam. Once the AF100 gets out there people will choose it for video over the 5d in droves IMO. Aliasing sucks and ruins so many shots!

The only way DLSR's are going to be used for anything other than ENG or family vacation vids is if they improve the technology and eliminate aliasing. They can't put a low bypass filter on it because that would cripple it as a still camera.

I think anyway. Someone correct me if I'm wrong.
 
Well my point is: we have to deal with the ignorance of people. I have nightmares to think about the assumption of the market (ignorant people) prefer the 5D over AF100.

How you think would be the best way to prove, to ignorant people, the superiority of the AF100 over DSLR?

Might want to start with yourself.
 
I'm so tired of the 5D craze.

I've worked on big commercials in which a RED one could've been easily rented and people still went with 5Ds.

It's like a collective hysteria.

The 5DMkII has something that a superior camera cannot overcome; small ad agency people regard it as cool. Shaking your head in disbelief? Don't. Cool cannot be overcome with logic, or even unassailable demonstration.

The 5D is cool now and it will remain cool for quite a while, even after the AF100 is in common use.

I lost a job to a 5D, not on price, not on quality, but simply because the agency wanted the 5D. Period. End of discussion. Never again. If the client demands the 5D, I'm ready to leave the Red in the case.

Another production company I know was awarded a job based on the 5D and when they offered the Red instead at no extra cost, they were almost fired. Seriously.

The 5D is cool. And that's all that matters.

Good shooting and best regards,

Leo
 
Hmm... I've never visited the AF100 forum until now... and you guys sound just like the RED camp when the 5D first came on the market.

Relax -- I think the AF100 will (on average) out perform the 5D on video - unless it somehow misses the mark on low light perofrmance (I'm not an expert on the camera). But sometimes that bigger sensor will make a difference, whether it's low light or a need for extremely shallow DOF.

Leo -- what kind of group of 'professionals' are you talking about that seem so blindly attached to the 5D? Most of the industry is still dead set against the 5D, and is just barely easing up about the post-production nightmare of the RED. The AF100 will no doubt be accepted among professional circles with much more ease due to form factor and a familiar brand. Let's be friends, k ;) ?

PS: I own, and have shot dozens of films with my 5D. But I'm a photographer first and foremost. I shrug.
 
I agree. But what's cool can change quickly and my bet is that the 5D's cool days are numbered.

Of course if the 5d III comes out and solves the aliasing then all bets are off.
 
Leo speaks the truth. And it will continue that way until some agency gets burned with unusable footage. And when that happens, the word will spread that the 5D isn't cool anymore, and it will disappear.

Until then, if the customer asks for the 5D, you give them the 5D. If the customer doesn't ask or doesn't care, you give them the product that will deliver the best image to your standards. But if they insist on using a particular product, you give it to them.
 
When comparing two products, I think that human nature, and especially on internet forums, reverts to tribalism. You can see this absolutely everywhere you look.

Coke vs. Pepsi
Republicans vs. Democrats
Ford vs. Chevy
Gibson vs. Fender
Linux vs. Windows
vi vs. emacs (a 20 year rivalry over competing UNIX text editing programs)
Rock vs. Rap vs. Country

In every case, you have a lot of moderate reasonable people, and some that really champion their one favorite choice to the exclusion of all others.

It is not enough to have something useful or beneficial that you like to use. What is most important is that you can prove everyone else wrong so that everyone comes to the same conclusion, even if their circumstances, needs, wants, desires, or frame of reference are different.

Once people pick a tribe, they will circle the wagons to defend their choice and point out the flaws in the other tribes.

Really, all the cameras being discussed here are good. Think of where we were just a few years ago, and how far we have come. I started using expensive NTSC ENG cameras in the 90's, and I would have absolutely killed for any of the cameras discussed on this forum.
 
Leo speaks the truth. And it will continue that way until some agency gets burned with unusable footage. And when that happens, the word will spread that the 5D isn't cool anymore, and it will disappear.

If this hasn't happened by now , I don't know when it will happen. I think every one has been burned with bad DSLR footie by this time.
 
When comparing two products, I think that human nature, and especially on internet forums, reverts to tribalism. .

How do I write this in English: Heee-heee-heee....?! Bikers and camera-people are alike in that at times.

My take is: If it fit's my needs I friggin use it. If not, not.

I have ordered an AG-AF 101. My problem, okay? If anybody else shoots a better film on an iphone, a 5 D or an old Pathé, I'd say: Well done.
 
Back
Top