OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
I'm not sure I understand your question. I think the BlackMagic box might work for some that have limited shots per day and limited camera angles in post. But for
me and the types of long running shots that we do, this box would not work for us. I think it's cool .. and perhaps the storage cost and I/O will catch up to uncompressed
video .. but for now, I would not consider this box.

jeff

Agree - not for everybody, we have sometimes 150 hrs Video. But some for shorter takes it is ok.
 
The Ninja and Samurai don't come with SSD's correct? So you pay $1000-1500 just for the unit, plus a SSD to boot. So figure a 128GB SSD costing you like $250 or so, that puts you at $1300 already (if you consider the Ninja). With the BM Shuttle you spend $350 on the unit, and you have another $1000 you can spend on SSD's before you'd even hit the cost of the Ninja with 128GB drive. For $1000 you can get TWO 256GB Drives giving you the exact same recording time as the Ninja's ProresHQ on the 128GB drive. Does it cost you more money? NO. Does it cost you more time? Perhaps. Depends on what you want and why.

You could transcode the files right off the SSD to your laptop and not lose that much time at all depending on your system. Also no display on the BM Shuttle, but I plan on using the display mode the product seems to have to playback and show clips on my External LCD anyways. I understand not everyone has that or plans to use that, so as others have said it's not for everyone. :)
 
I'll take the ProRes of the Samurai with it's built in monitor, or the FFV recorder.

Actually, the Sound Devices recorder is the one I am really looking at.
 
When someone creates a SSD SATA to Thunderbolt cable, you will be editing uncompressed HD on a MacBook laptop or any laptop with Thunderbolt ports.

Sweet.
 
It's hard to see how it's an alternative to the Ninja, which works with commodity-priced hard-drives and has a built-in monitor. The vast majority of users don't need to record uncompressed when there are visually-lossless alternatives like ProRes. You need to look at the Total Cost of Ownership with these devices. - Dave Shapton (Atomos)

Hi Dave: Point well taken. The Ninja & Samuri are different enough from products such as BlackMagic's that I think there's room for all. I think your products are well-positioned for success.

Here's a funny thing: I've been researching buying a harddrive-based, near-to-mid-term backup & archive solution for my work, and I'm considering your Ninja Docking Station & Master Caddy products -- even before I consider buying the Ninja itself. With the price of 1TB bare HDD drives being so low, it seems to be a cost-effective approach. Especially since the drives are so easy & safe to handle once mounted in caddies. Very importantly, because the data is on fast hard drives, data can be accessed infinitely faster than with tape backup systems. Longer term, it will also be easy & fast to transfer date among drives via a computer to keep data safe on relatively new drives -- or to transfer it to some future low-cost backup system.

The fact that the Atomos Master Caddies also fit the Ninja & Samurai field recorders (and work with both HDD & SSD) is a huge plus if I decide later to get one of those, too.

A product suggestion: If the Ninja & Samurai don't already have this feature, please consider adding it, especially if it would only require a firmware update: A magnify mode for the video monitor, accessed via an always-available button, so that at any time one can zoom in & out to aid focusing. It's OK with me that the Ninja's built-in monitor is relatively low-res as long as it has a very good, easy to access magnify mode. I looked thru the user manual but didn't see such a feature mentioned, but if I missed it, my apologies.

Cheers.
 
It's hard to see how it's an alternative to the Ninja, which works with commodity-priced hard-drives and has a built-in monitor. The vast majority of users don't need to record uncompressed when there are visually-lossless alternatives like ProRes. You need to look at the Total Cost of Ownership with these devices.

Dave Shapton
Atomos

I think the price point automatically begs comparison . . .

If (and maybe Ninja does this already), your device recorded in a codec I could just drop into Edius Broadcast or PP CS5 you'd be (IMHO) the clear winner for most users.
 
Is there a reason why you could not just drop it in a time line?

i think generally, the ones that are most concerned about the pro res encoding are wary about the fast raids they'll need to buy, and extra storage requirements. It's a nominal cost, and drives are very cheap these days along with esata raid enclosures. but there are still users who are still constantly trying to keep things in a certain budget at all times, and the extra drives do break those budgets. So the great thing is, this is pretty much the year for external recorders. there's literally 6-8 that's gonna be out by the end of this year for people to choose from, for any workflow and budget.
 
ProRes drops into Edius or Premier fine. As long as you install quicktime.


I think the price point automatically begs comparison . . .

If (and maybe Ninja does this already), your device recorded in a codec I could just drop into Edius Broadcast or PP CS5 you'd be (IMHO) the clear winner for most users.
 
I think it's like anything else in acquisition or post. An option. Everyone will have different needs. Personally, I plan to get one just so I can take the full resolution of the the SDI enabled camcorders we have in-house or if I'm renting. And it's small enough to take on the road with HDMI enabled laptops or small monitors. Fewer codec mis-match issues when I'm sending things to different people on different systems? Heck, I'll take two.
 
Well according to Mikko's NAB updates, the battery only lasts an hour, so longterm use in the field is out without a good powering source which takes $$$ since the voltage on the product is 12V. The other options are a lot more appealing now since they have battery docks (like the Atmos products) and the Nano can be ran off a Swit battery in the AF100 or something similar, at under 7V.

I'm still stuck trying to figure out a good battery pack to buy for my setup so I can also power my TVLogic which is 12V. Since I plan on using the TVLogic I might as well look into investing in a battery pack that can run everything anyways, so this product is still a possibility for me.
 
Last edited:
It looks great.

I find the workflow a bit odd and cubersome. They make it clear you have to remove the ssd and plug it into a hd dock to copy the
files to a computer. The usb is just for firmware update. Look at the workflow diagram.

That strikes me as silly, why can't I just attach it by usb to a computer as an external drive?

There is an enormous difference in ssd preformance, so I would venture to guess they will have an approved list
containing only the most expensive ssds. The internal ssd interface is sata 3.0, which is also a little odd with sata 6gbs
coming everywhere.

Most ssds never come close to saturating interface bandwidths, they just aren't fast enough writing and retreiving data.
But I would think uncompressed hd video streaming in would have a pretty good chance!

It's not like write speeds are consistent,
they peak and valley. 1080p 24p 10 bit is what, 250mb/s? That's banging on the door. sata 6 would have given some breathing room.

SSDs wear out and preformance degrades severly, especially when you write a whole of data all the time. They will have an okay lifetime depending on load,
but they will die in time. unlike what most people think, if they are being written to heavily, their lifetime can well be less than a non-defective hdd. They do better if they mostly
are reading, that's not what will happen here.

Best bang for big with sata 3 ssd right now is odz vertex pro2 120gb, which can be found close to $200 and is near the top performance-wise. That will change as vertexpro3 and the rest of sata 6gbs come.
It will be a while before sata3 ssd come down much in price.

It would be great if this thing worked well.
 
I find the workflow a bit odd and cubersome. They make it clear you have to remove the ssd and plug it into a hd dock to copy the
files to a computer. The usb is just for firmware update. Look at the workflow diagram.

That strikes me as silly, why can't I just attach it by usb to a computer as an external drive?

Simple, and it sounds like you probably know this, connecting via USB, even USB3, will net you a fraction of the SSD's speed... like driving a F1 car down on old, narrow, cobblestone street.
 
I'm still stuck trying to figure out a good battery pack to buy for my setup so I can also power my TVLogic which is 12V. Since I plan on using the TVLogic I might as well look into investing in a battery pack that can run everything anyways, so this product is still a possibility for me.


I have a few of those, powers my TVLogc almost for a whole day.
http://cgi.ebay.de/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=220716426587&ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT

Does it respond to Camera Start/Stop command ?
Probably does, atleast on SDI - but it makes no sense, cause the signal is there without pushing the rec button on camera. To record the signal out of the HDMI/SDI you dint have to push that button.

Frank
 
Last edited:
I have a few of those, powers my TVLogc almost for a whole day.
http://cgi.ebay.de/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=220716426587&ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT


Probably does, atleast on SDI - but it makes no sense, cause the signal is there without pushing the rec button on camera. To record the signal out of the HDMI/SDI you dint have to push that button.

Frank

I was looking for that. I believe you had posted it before and I was just trying to find where I bookmarked it. You are Johnny on the Spot! Thanks Frank.
 
Sometimes I forget how Microcosmic DVXuser really is.

Honestly, this didn't ever, doesn't seem, the product for the average user. It's something slated toward larger productions that can afford to go uncompressed, and it still seems to me that this is a position BlackMagic's taking to begin phasing out tape stock and media for good.

It'll take a while, it's not an instantaneous process, but this does represent a nice shift in the post flow toward delivering a secure, high quality copy to various houses and/or territories.

The Ninja is much more suited for the average user, but it also has its own drawbacks. I've had my chance to use one and it's a great little module, but there are lots of things that need to be addressed to put it into a serious production environment, and post environment.

Let each product be its own, and hopefully be great at what it professes to deliver.
 
Back
Top