OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
I have a few of those, powers my TVLogc almost for a whole day.
http://cgi.ebay.de/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=220716426587&ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT


Probably does, atleast on SDI - but it makes no sense, cause the signal is there without pushing the rec button on camera. To record the signal out of the HDMI/SDI you dint have to push that button.

Frank

makes sense if you are recording the internal camera codec for your editorial, bypassing editing with uncompressed or transcoding later, and then onlining to the uncompressed later. lots of scenerios that this workflow makes the most sense, especially when log workflows are involved. if possible, you record 709 or log with lut to internal codec, just log to uncompressed.
 
Remember seeing an interview with some BMD people at a show, and they said, that, not only did people tell them, they couldn't sell at those prices(When they first started), but that they literally got some death threats.
 
Remember seeing an interview with some BMD people at a show, and they said, that, not only did people tell them, they couldn't sell at those prices(When they first started), but that they literally got some death threats.

seriously?

I can believe it. Sooo much of film gear is overpriced because they are more or less the only game in town.
 
Ok, to clarify. What would be the consensus on at what level of post production, effects handling, color grading, mastering and exhibition/distribution would uncompressed acquisition be noticeably superior?


(This ought to be interesting!).
 
Ok, to clarify. What would be the consensus on at what level of post production, effects handling, color grading, mastering and exhibition/distribution would uncompressed acquisition be noticeably superior?

I think it's less about its effect on the end result (which is why so many will transcode anyways) and more on its strength of being a format not tied to any system or codec. The fact that it can be turned into anything without data loss from the source is worth it for some. Noticeable in the end product people watch...different story. There's a ton of stuff that goes on BTS in workflows that doesn't affect the end result, just the speed or ease of getting to the end result for the provider. Just because Uncompressed won't necessarily in most respects change what the end viewer sees doesn't make it a useless commodity. (not that you were implying that...just stating it).
 
Ok, to clarify. What would be the consensus on at what level of post production, effects handling, color grading, mastering and exhibition/distribution would uncompressed acquisition be noticeably superior?


(This ought to be interesting!).

The nice thing is that it allows you to make the choice based on what compromises *you* want to make.

You can transcode to whichever codec is best for you, or just keep it uncompressed. For 1080 work you can't get much better for price and performance. If you have to have a drive that can walk in ProRes, get the KI Pro Mini, FFV recorder, or the Ninja.

The bigger question with all of these tapeless workflows is that you need redundant backups and a robust workflow. So just double at least each of your harddrives. :)
 
Most ssds never come close to saturating interface bandwidths, they just aren't fast enough writing and retreiving data.
But I would think uncompressed hd video streaming in would have a pretty good chance!

It's not like write speeds are consistent,
they peak and valley. 1080p 24p 10 bit is what, 250mb/s? That's banging on the door. sata 6 would have given some breathing room.

10-bit 1080p24 Y'CbCr 4:2:2 uncompressed (aka v210) is about 125 MegaBytes/s

Writes for recording should be sequential, and consistent when dealing with uncompressed video
 
Sometimes I forget how Microcosmic DVXuser really is.

Honestly, this didn't ever, doesn't seem, the product for the average user. It's something slated toward larger productions that can afford to go uncompressed, and it still seems to me that this is a position BlackMagic's taking to begin phasing out tape stock and media for good.

It'll take a while, it's not an instantaneous process, but this does represent a nice shift in the post flow toward delivering a secure, high quality copy to various houses and/or territories.

The Ninja is much more suited for the average user, but it also has its own drawbacks. I've had my chance to use one and it's a great little module, but there are lots of things that need to be addressed to put it into a serious production environment, and post environment.

Let each product be its own, and hopefully be great at what it professes to deliver.

Tnx for sharing you Ninja using. Maybe wrong tread? But what should be improved on the Ninja?
Is the analog level monitoring level overlayed with the Video Monitoring picture?
 
Blackmagic already has a whole portfolio of their own codecs, both lossless and lossy. I'm surprised they're not including them in this product. Could somebody at the show ask them about this? It would be great if they did.
 
Blackmagic already has a whole portfolio of their own codecs, both lossless and lossy. I'm surprised they're not including them in this product. Could somebody at the show ask them about this? It would be great if they did.
+1
It's always frustrating too see great products skip out of my list because of stuff like this. Sure, it would fit a great deal of customers. But I think the addition of a codec compression would make this much more versatile. I need recordings of live event shows (can be loong). So BM, pleace concider this, even motion jpeg would be a great. Otherwise, I like it a lot.
 
+1
It's always frustrating too see great products skip out of my list because of stuff like this. Sure, it would fit a great deal of customers. But I think the addition of a codec compression would make this much more versatile. I need recordings of live event shows (can be loong). So BM, pleace concider this, even motion jpeg would be a great. Otherwise, I like it a lot.

-1 because for $345 you aren't going to have the processing power to handle that kind of throughput. If they added that sort of capability into the unit, it will start being the cost of the other offerings. It's not just about codec licensing fees, it's about electronics. There is a reason it is so inexpensive in comparison. Having a system that can take that amount of raw data AND compress it REAL TIME costs money. I'm actually amazed at what Atmos has done at the price point they have. That is some significant processing.
 
I'm sure the additional hardware, circuitry, coding, and licensing fees or any compressed codec would make this product in the same price range as the Ninja or Samurai and it doesn't have a monitor. Even if they saved a little by implementing a blackmagic codec it would probably raise the price enough to loose potential customers since it's not ProRes. I think they cornered a market for inexpensive, yet high quality external recording solutions and made a good choice. I will get one, and I'm sure many others will as well.
 
Exactly. I see this as a GREAT option for people who only need an external recorder minimally for extremely challenging scenes, and therefore, do not need HUGE drive. I'll probably still get the Atmos for our productions, because I think the extra features make it more worth it to me, however, I've already passed this device info on to MANY people who do things like green screening and stuff. For people doing short commercial work, or music videos, etc, for around $500 with a small drive, they'll be able to get MUCH easier to key footage. That's pretty cool.
 
Apologies if this has already been asked, but this seems like a relevant thread:

Currently, pending further NAB announcements, what's the least expensive interchangeable lens camera available "soonish" which has a sensor larger than 2/3" and live _10_ bit HDMI (or HD-SDI) out?

And a follow-up: Has RED officially announced if Scarlet will have a 2/3" or S35 sensor, or will both be offered?

Just trying to figure out which big-sensor cam can make best use of the new 10-bit external recorders, for the least cost. Thanks.

To answer my own questions:

The Sony F3 body-only @ list price of $16K US is currently "... the least expensive interchangeable lens camera available "soonish" which has a sensor larger than 2/3" and live _10_ bit HDMI (or HD-SDI) out ..."

(The AF100, FS100 and all the DSLRs have 8-bit HDMI/HD-SDI out, not 10-bit.)

I believe the above is correct. If not, please post.

And: Scarlet will most likely have a 2/3" sensor, although I haven't seen official confirmation on RED's website that specifically states this. Again, if I'm mistaken please post.

Cheers.
 
Back
Top