OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
The S35 Scarlet got a name change (and specs, and price), and is now the EPIC-S. Which won't likely be available for order until all EPIC orders are filled. For all intents and purposes, Scarlet is now limited to 2/3rds.
 
Their last guesstimate was $12k, but they didn't indicate it was final. With RED, things always change...

If true, seems F3 will continue to be the least-cost big-sensor, interchangeable-lens cam w. 10-bit live out, at least until something less expensive comes along (possibly including Scarlet s35 / EPIC-S).
 
Last edited:
I kinda feel bad for atamos right now...

But yea, where do I put in my pre-order for this to get in line (as I am sure there will be one)? I will make my deposit right now if it will ship before July!
 
I kinda feel bad for atamos right now ...

Don't feel sorry for Atomos. They'll sell as many Ninjas at $995 for their complete kit (but w/o drive) as they can make. It's a bargain.

All the new external, file-based HD recorders have features valuable to different users. Just because you like the Hyperdeck Shuttle's features & price (I like it too!) doesn't mean another device is wrong for someone else or for a different project.

Choice is good!
 
I beleive the Scarlet S35 was initially closer to $7k, not $3,500, which was I beleive for the 2/3rds, or 2/3rds fixed lens zoom.

But the $12k figure comes from Jannard himself: http://reduser.net/forum/showthread.php?53580-EPIC-S-%28old-Scarlet-S35%29-update...

Thanks for the link & info.

It's probably a good bet the RED "EPIC-S / Scarlet s35" will be built like a tank compared to the Sony F3, too, but we'll have to see what ships, when it ships.

Is it likely the RED "EPIC-S / Scarlet s35" will ship w/o in-camera recording capability, meaning you buy a separate module to capture RED RAW on the media of your choice? I wonder if the basic cam head unit will have HDMI or HD-SDI output w/o buying a RED RAW recording module? Will be interesting to see what happens ...
 
To answer my own questions:

The Sony F3 body-only @ list price of $16K US is currently "... the least expensive interchangeable lens camera available "soonish" which has a sensor larger than 2/3" and live _10_ bit HDMI (or HD-SDI) out ..."

(The AF100, FS100 and all the DSLRs have 8-bit HDMI/HD-SDI out, not 10-bit.)

I believe the above is correct. If not, please post.

And: Scarlet will most likely have a 2/3" sensor, although I haven't seen official confirmation on RED's website that specifically states this. Again, if I'm mistaken please post.

Cheers.

FS100 is 10bit and...4:4:4 according to Sony themselves:

http://vimeo.com/22275448

Or this guy just might be a bit NABered

/V
 
Just a heads up. There are 3 variants of colorspace used thus far.

8-bit
8-bit extended xv.ycc
10-bit

8-bit extended i.e. xv.ycc is not supported on Blackmagic products.

Regarding 10-bit, only the Sony EX1/EX3 actually output 10-bit uncompressed on HDMI. Every other camera under 10K gives out 8-bit over HDMI.

It would be a simple feature to allow us to choose between 8-bit or 10-bit recording. As simple as writing out 8-bits from the embedded processor instead of 10-bit.
This could be configured via USB.

The lack of support for xv.ycc causes problems when recording from certain Panasonic and Sony cameras. One camera I do know of is the Panasonic HDC-SD9 that outputs the extended colorspace. I am trying to get Blackmagic to
a. Allow us to choose 8-bit vs 10-bit uncompressed
AND
b. Allow for recording support of xv.ycc (and avoid clipping of colorspace in the 16-240 regions).

For those who are at NAB please do bring this issue up with Blackmagic.
 
Some more info about colorspace.
A response from Blackmagic...
>>>
Intensity will probably capture the xvYCC colorspace but it will strip the
video to the YUV colorspace. This does the same thing if you take a RGB
colorspace signal and capture it with Intensity. Instead of the RGB 0-255,
it will capture and strip it to YUV 16-235.

The same should apply with our DeckLink cards even when capturing at 10 bit.
>>>

My response..
>>>
Even the ITU.BT-709 standard clearly says that video data is all the range from 1-254. So why are they clipped ?

BM provides products for the professional industry, so its actually a major drawback to reduce colorspace in this range.
HDMI 1.3 allows for xvYCC, and both AVCHD and H.264 include this support in their specs.

The specs for all BM cards include HDMI 1.3 so its strange that this clipping is happening.
>>>

I am posting this hoping that if some of you also raised these issues, BM will consider fixing (IMHO) a major and easily fixed bug.
 
He is NABered.
From the BH page on the fs100.

Uncompressed 4:2:2 Output with Embedded Timecode
When shooting, the NEX-FS100 can output uncompressed 4:2:2 footage via HDMI (with an embedded SMPTE Timecode) that can be recorded onto external media, such as HDD.


FS100 is 10bit and...4:4:4 according to Sony themselves:

http://vimeo.com/22275448

Or this guy just might be a bit NABered

/V
 
FS100 is 10bit and...4:4:4 according to Sony themselves:

http://vimeo.com/22275448

Or this guy just might be a bit NABered

/V

Well, according to Bill Drummond, Sony's product manager (who should know!), the FS100's live HD out is 8-bit, not 10-bit. See:
http://www.hdwarrior.co.uk/2011/03/...ive-interview-with-bill-drummond-coming-soon/

"... Let’s not beat about the bush, HDMI is becoming more professional every day and more and more professionals are using it for monitoring and other things but, you know, ultimately it does allow use of products like the Ki Pro mini and the Atmos Ninja which meet the requirements of our target customers. The [FS100] HDMI outputs 4:2:2 8bit. ... "

Don't get me wrong, I'd _love_ it if the FS100 featured live 10-bit HDMI, but that doesn't seem to be the case, unless Sony has recently changed its specs.
 
Don't feel sorry for Atomos. They'll sell as many Ninjas at $995 for their complete kit (but w/o drive) as they can make. It's a bargain.

All the new external, file-based HD recorders have features valuable to different users. Just because you like the Hyperdeck Shuttle's features & price (I like it too!) doesn't mean another device is wrong for someone else or for a different project.

Choice is good!

Right. I've been trying to get on board with the BM device because of its low price but we're talking about 10 gigs a minute here 1080/24p. It also has a limiting onboard 1 hour battery time. If you're in a controlled environment I can see its use but out on the street the BM seems impractical and the work arounds to make it practical ( dtap batterries if possible, multiple ssd's, dumping station) its low cost suddenly disappears..

I hope atomos rethinks their samurai design and gives both HDMI and SDi on that unit, because with its double battery system and selectable prores codecs it would definitely have more user interest.
 
... I hope atomos rethinks their samurai design and gives both HDMI and SDi on that unit, because with its double battery system and selectable prores codecs it would definitely have more user interest.

I'm hoping the Ninja/Samurai have a magnify toggle mode to aid focusing on the relatively low-res monitor. If it doesn't have it now in first rev, might be easily added via Atomos firmware update if internal hardware can support it.
 
Regarding 10-bit, only the Sony EX1/EX3 actually output 10-bit uncompressed on HDMI. Every other camera under 10K gives out 8-bit over HDMI.


quick correction, did you mean sdi? as the ex1/ex3 only have sdi output, no hdmi. But the sdi output on them is indeed full 10-bit. the hdmi out on the ex1r however is 8-bit, with its sdi output being 10-bit.
 
Back
Top