OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
Thanks for the insight! I've contemplated using BluRay as a secondary backup to drives, but just haven't found a lot of people doing that or much research on the longevity of the disks (yet).

XDCAM discs are very similar to bluray. You might want to look at those as a zero point for your benchmarks.
 
Decided to bail out on my order. Way too many questions about compatible media and powering options - at this point. Thinking I'll wait a little longer 'til all these products shake out a bit.
 
Sata 2/3

Sata 2/3

Let's talk costs then.

At present price levels, what would 90 minutes of continuous uncompressed 10-bit 1080p30 422 cost with a solid SATA II or SATA III SSD drive run?

and any indication that the BM device could power that long of a continuous shoot?

This device is SATA 2. SATA 3 SSD's won't perform any faster on it but will cost more.
 
This device is SATA 2. SATA 3 SSD's won't perform any faster on it but will cost more.

That's not true. The reason being, some characteristics of the SATA3 drives are faster yet still slower than SATA2 bus speeds. Therefore, for those characteristics, like write speeds, you can get faster drives that are SATA3 to give you better performance on SATA2 buses. Mainly because they have newer tech and in some cases smaller gate sizes on the NAND technology.

You just have to check the stats and make sure what you are getting improved.
 
Just got a reply from BlackMagic and the HyperShuttle is NOT made for shooting in the field.

CONS:
- Battery lasts for 1 hour
- No mounting ability to camera

However he did mention that some third parties may make some kind of mounting device. But the battery situation really licks.
 
Making a metal basket or a threaded mount for 1/4" screw should be easy. The external battery isn't too hard to over come either.

I'm wondering if a 2.4" notebook drive would work in there. It should work and much cheaper IF, and ONLY IF you didn't jar it to hard.
 
Indeed just Google 12v lithium ion battery and tons of products pop up. So although it may not be good at all for run and gun it should definitely be good enough for controlled outdoor shoots like filmmaking.

I definitely foresee my workflow, if I pick this little baby up (after you all act as guinea pigs, ahahaha), as being:

1 BMD Shuttle
3 hard drives (Intel 320 Series 300 GB SATA 3.0 Gb-s)

Record to SxS and BMD deck simultaneously.
Hand hard drive to assistant to transcode on eSATA dock to laptop to Cineform . As well as the SxS card for backup.
Cineform copy to another hard drive as backup.
Format SSD drive with uncompressed footage.
While this is going on the other drives are happily shooting.

I haven't worked with Cineform yet but the name always comes up. And reading this from another board:

"1080 24p CineForm will run about 14-15MB/s compared to 10bit uncompressed at 132MB/s". Yeah, I'll take 1/10 the size at about the same quality, thanks!
 
Indeed just Google 12v lithium ion battery and tons of products pop up. So although it may not be good at all for run and gun it should definitely be good enough for controlled outdoor shoots like filmmaking.

I definitely foresee my workflow, if I pick this little baby up (after you all act as guinea pigs, ahahaha), as being:

1 BMD Shuttle
3 hard drives (Intel 320 Series 300 GB SATA 3.0 Gb-s)

Record to SxS and BMD deck simultaneously.
Hand hard drive to assistant to transcode on eSATA dock to laptop to Cineform . As well as the SxS card for backup.
Cineform copy to another hard drive as backup.
Format SSD drive with uncompressed footage.
While this is going on the other drives are happily shooting.

I haven't worked with Cineform yet but the name always comes up. And reading this from another board:

"1080 24p CineForm will run about 14-15MB/s compared to 10bit uncompressed at 132MB/s". Yeah, I'll take 1/10 the size at about the same quality, thanks!

I'm not making a political point here; just wondering whether you wouldn't be better capturing in the first place to a lossless compressed format? Then you wouldn't have to transcode to a lossless compressed format.

1080 24p CineForm will run about 14-15MB/s compared to 10bit uncompressed at 132MB/s". Yeah, I'll take 1/10 the size at about the same quality, thanks!
You're actually making the case for not using uncompressed yourself. Or have I missed something here?

Dave Shapton
Atomos
 
Last edited:
the data rates would be WAYY too high for mechanical notebook drives, sadly :violin:

I didn't check on the 2.5" drives, but on 3.5" drives the 7,200 rpm drives go up to 6Gbps, which is what I thought was required for uncompressed.

But on further investigation is appears the SATA drives at 6Gbps are not yet available in 2.5" form factor.
 
Last edited:
I'm not making a political point here; just wondering whether you wouldn't be better capturing in the first place to a lossless compressed format? Then you wouldn't have to transcode to a lossless compressed format.

You're actually making the case for not using uncompressed yourself. Or have I missed something here?

Dave Shapton
Atomos


Well I'm definitely still undecided. Mainly because I'm not quite sure the more affordable off-the-shelf SSD drives can sustain write spreads throughout their entire disc. It comes down to price, quality and compatibility.

Capturing the uncompressed gives me the option of compression codec. For my projects I'll use Cineform but maybe an editor or client prefers ProRes. Well, it can be done. But going ProRes to Cineform...we're losing some data there. Like going from a 320kbps mp3 to 256kbps. Recompressing compressed files, but on a more subtle basis.

From the looks of it I may not be purchasing any of these external recorders until Autumn at the earliest. That all depends on whether and when I start shooting this TV pilot I have in mind. Cards need to fall into place but I have 3 big projects lined up this year that would benefit from these recorders. Your product does have a lot of Pros I'm weighing, including:

Battery life (this can't be understated)
Portability
Video Preview/Touch Screen
Longer recording times per drive
Off-the-shelf drives with company recommendations (BMD is being too quiet about this, if I have to pay $1,000+ for a drive with 10 minutes of recording time it's a deal breaker)

I haven't counted Atomos out yet, Dave. Not by a long shot. I'm just weighing my options.
 
Well I'm definitely still undecided. Mainly because I'm not quite sure the more affordable off-the-shelf SSD drives can sustain write spreads throughout their entire disc. It comes down to price, quality and compatibility.

Capturing the uncompressed gives me the option of compression codec. For my projects I'll use Cineform but maybe an editor or client prefers ProRes. Well, it can be done. But going ProRes to Cineform...we're losing some data there. Like going from a 320kbps mp3 to 256kbps. Recompressing compressed files, but on a more subtle basis.

From the looks of it I may not be purchasing any of these external recorders until Autumn at the earliest. That all depends on whether and when I start shooting this TV pilot I have in mind. Cards need to fall into place but I have 3 big projects lined up this year that would benefit from these recorders. Your product does have a lot of Pros I'm weighing, including:

Battery life (this can't be understated)
Portability
Video Preview/Touch Screen
Longer recording times per drive
Off-the-shelf drives with company recommendations (BMD is being too quiet about this, if I have to pay $1,000+ for a drive with 10 minutes of recording time it's a deal breaker)

I haven't counted Atomos out yet, Dave. Not by a long shot. I'm just weighing my options.


That's good to know, but I wasn't just plugging my product - just wondered what your reasoning was regarding codecs - which I now understand.

BTW - I've had quite a bit of experience with multiple generations and with transcoding between good quality codecs. Yes, there's always some loss, but at this level (ie high bit-rate I-Frame only (ie intra-frame) codecs), I think you'd be hard pushed to see any loss going from, say, Cineform to ProRes. Even the old DigiBeta codec was capable of many, generations before there was any significant (ie visible) loss. I have to say though that all of this is based on my less-than-perfect eyesight, and not on scientific tests!

Good luck with whatever you choose to go with!

Dave Shapton
Atomos
 
That's good to know, but I wasn't just plugging my product - just wondered what your reasoning was regarding codecs - which I now understand.

BTW - I've had quite a bit of experience with multiple generations and with transcoding between good quality codecs. Yes, there's always some loss, but at this level (ie high bit-rate I-Frame only (ie intra-frame) codecs), I think you'd be hard pushed to see any loss going from, say, Cineform to ProRes. Even the old DigiBeta codec was capable of many, generations before there was any significant (ie visible) loss. I have to say though that all of this is based on my less-than-perfect eyesight, and not on scientific tests!

Good luck with whatever you choose to go with!

Dave Shapton
Atomos

No problem. I just need something that will meet broadcast spec, go through a bit of color correction (medium grading, not heavy) and not look like garbage over satelite.
 
Some quick questions about the HyperDeck Shuttle;

- When feeding it a HDSDI signal, is it possible for it to get a cue through the HDSDI to start and stop recording? On the Sony F3 for example, my thinking is that you could be recording both to the SxS cards and to the Shuttle at the same time, by only hitting the record button on the camera.

- Does this device support TOD timecode? and is it possible to customize the naming convention of the clips to match the clip names on the SxS cards?

- Is there any plan in the future to support any additional codecs?

Any info would be great.

Thanks
Colin
 
Wondering if this can be also be used with Canon XH-A1?

Wondering if this can be also be used with Canon XH-A1?

I am not familiar with the Canon Xh-A1 component output signal...
Wondering if this could be a solution ...
Canon XHA1 - component output -> Blackmagic Intensity Shuttle (for convering Component signal 4:2:2 to HDMI) -> use HDMI output to record to Blackmagic HyperDeck Shuttle.

$199 ( Intensity Shuttle) + $345( HyperDeck Shuttle) + Cable costs

Not sure if Intensity Shuttle needs a power source? Can't figure that out...

If this is a possible workflow - I will be able to still use by Canon Xh-A1 as a great filmmaking Camera.
Would love your inputs...
 
the intensity shuttle doesnt need a external powersource..its powered by the USB connection. I just got one( Intensity shuttle) and and will be playing/figuring out today.
 
So I presume it cannot be used for Field Work , if the goal is to use HDMI output to a HDMI input recording source (As all the current Recorders like Ki-Pro mini, ATomos Ninja and Hyperdeck Shuttle have no USB 3.0) - Do not know any new Pro Camcorders using USB 3.0...
I am planning on using KanexPro (Component to HDMI) $65.00 with a 5v Battery pack. Does anyone have any experience with this product?

KanexPro (Component to HDMI) http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/770114-REG/KanexPro_RGBRLHD_Component_to_HDMI_Audio_Video.html
 
Last edited:
Back
Top