OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
Hi Dave,

Uncompressed video is actually a direct digital copy of your input and requires far less CPU resources than ProRes. Try playing back a stream of Uncompressed 10-bit 4:2:2 in Final Cut Pro and compare how much CPU resources you'll be using compared to using ProRes.

Kristian Lam
Blackmagic Design

Hi Kristian, nice to see you on here!

In an ideal world, where bandwidth inside a computer and between disk systems and the data bus they are connected to is unlimited and doesn't cost anything extra, yes, uncompressed would be better, perhaps. But in the real world, ProRes needs less storage, and - importantly in this context - less bandwidth (between a sixth and a tenth, depending which version of ProRes you use) and is therefore a much more workable option than working with uncompressed on a typical workstation. I don't think anyone's saying that uncompressed isn't better than compressed, but, again, in the real world, there are advantages in using ProRes over uncompressed, and it's mainly to do with the huge quantities of data involved in HD (and, by the way, I daresay we'll be having the same discussion again when everyone's moved to 2k, 4k 8k etc!).

Put simply, if you're using uncompressed, you're stressing the data-paths in your computer way beyond where they'd be if you were using ProRes. This will limit the number of simultaneous layers you can handle, and may cause other detrimental effects. Try scrubbing a ten-minute ProRes clip from a 2.5 inch drive with FCP over a Firewire 800 link. Then try it with uncompressed from the same drive.

What it all boils down to is practicality vs cost vs quality. There's room for all sorts of products within the graph mapped out by those variables. Pro-res encoders can cost more than uncompressed capture devices but they're worth it because it means that you can use less, and cheaper storage.

Dave Shapton
Atomos
 
Last edited:
Sorry Dave, but I disagree.

I work uncompressed with Black Magic products, since they are on the market.
It was SD back than. As soon as they provided HD cards, we switched to those and work uncompressed HD since that day, in an every day studio environment. When we receive compressed material from customers, the first thing we do, is converting it to uncompressed and work from there. Our own productions are uncompressed till delivery. A 2TB disc comes with the same price tag today as a HDCam SR tape (and that´s only MPEG-4)- so even archiving is a no-brainer and at the same price.

I´m really looking forward to the Hypershuttle, so I don´t have to hulk around my workstation on the set anymore.

I sing the gospel of uncompressed recording and workflow since years. We never had a problem with data rates or storage space in all those years. It even became faster and cheaper.

A lot of folks don´t see any benefit in uncompressed recording and workflow. I can tell you, uncompressed recording looks like you have a new camera.
If you look at it side by side, say AVC and uncompressed 4:2:2 there IS a big difference. Especially if it comes to color grading or multiple VFX and compositing stages. Uncompressed is always compatible with every NLE or application, always keeps pristine quality and is super snappy, responsive, and fluid, even on older computers. Every operation is faster (even encoding for final output) as with any other codec.

I take uncompressed any day over any other codec (especcialy with the outstanding signal quality of BM products), but to each his own.
As you say, there is room for all sorts of products.


my ct2, Frank

P.S an other funny thing: I heard nobody complaining about uncompressed, when it comes to the Gemini, A-Cam (both with more expensive, proprietary media) or professional post production workflows, where DPX files are a industry standard.
 
Last edited:
Sorry Dave, but I disagree.

I'm not going to get drawn in to this. I stand by what I said in my last post.

I certainly don't think it's appropriate for competing companies' representatives to be arguing together on a forum like this: in any case, there's no need to because the facts are there if anyone wants to find them or even measure them. As I said, there's room in this market space for lots of products. Everyone has a different take on the situation. There is no absolute right or wrong: only different positions, as I said before, between price, performance and quality.

Dave Shapton
Atomos
 
Hi Dave.
Is there a sales or demo outlet in Sydney where I can test the xv.ycc output from my camera ? Just making sure that you actually do bring in the 1-254 8-bit range without clipping.
 
Hi Dave.
Is there a sales or demo outlet in Sydney where I can test the xv.ycc output from my camera ? Just making sure that you actually do bring in the 1-254 8-bit range without clipping.

I'm based in Europe and don't cover the Australian sales side of things. I'll put you in touch with the Atomos office in Melbourne. If you could PM me your contact details?

Dave Shapton
Atomos
 
Yes it does, but actually you can also softwarestrip 2 or 3 fast HDDs with raid 0 and your golden.
Windows can do that without additional soft- or hardware. So no biggy.

Frank
 
I mean this in all seriousness, how do you store that much footage? EVERYTHING I shoot I store on a RAID for backup at two locations. So far, having my original files being H.264 based means they take up little space. I do not want to get rid of any footage, even when the projects are done because you never know when you might need them, and we have before, doing alternate cuts, etc for future releases. I'd say I shoot on average of 1TB a year with H.264. That seems like it would be a massive amount of space required to save all that if I left it in uncompressed. Do you transcode for archive?
 
I have different strategies for that.

1. My own projects: After everything is done and outputted to final medium, I consolidate all relevant material, trans code the files to JPEG2000 and store them together with the project files on cheap big (1.5 TB) drives.
One HDD is 60 bucks in the moment - so it´s cheaper than HDCamSR Tape.

I use only bare HDDs and a 40 bucks e-sata docking station - works like big floppy disks.
So I don´t have to buy an external housing every time I need more space.

2. For Client projects: I give them the option to store the material in - whatever form and medium they want - of course they pay for it - no brainer.

I don´t know what ratio you shoot, but for a 30 min. program, I usually have 120-150 minutes of footage.
What I store is seldom more than 60 min.

Let´s do the math: 8 bit @ 1920 x 1080 @ 25fps = 99 MB per/sec, or 348 GB per/hr.
That´s about 15 bucks worth of uncompressed storage space on a 1,5 TB HDD, or less than 5 for JPEG2000 compressed archiving.
Not too shabby I think - even if I want a backup of the backup.

Frank
 
Last edited:
Do you create multiple copies of your projects on different drives? Or just one copy on the backup drives. Hehe, and I have to ask, how many drives do you have!!! :)
 
Project files:
While working on a project, I save the project file with a new number every day or after some major changes - so if something get´s screwed up I loose only one day. At the end of the day I make an additional backup copy on an external drive.

Footage:
It depends. We keep the original footage on external drives, till the project is done and everything is archived.
Than there is a backup of the original footage and there is the footage on my NLEs RAID that I actually work with.

If it is clients footage, they usually ask for a backup that they can keep. That can be anything from BluRay to Tape or HDDs.
Whatever they ask (and pay) for. But surprisingly often they say "Nah, just delete it" - cause in two months it is obsolete anyway.

My own footage is JPEG2000 archived on a gazzilion of HDDs.
I only make a second backup (backup of backup) if the footage is very important or was expensive to shoot.

I have a closet full of HDDs - pretty much the same way, I used to have a closed full of tapes back than.

Frank
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the insight! I've contemplated using BluRay as a secondary backup to drives, but just haven't found a lot of people doing that or much research on the longevity of the disks (yet).
 
Some clients want BluRay, but personally I don´t use it because of the lousy price per MB ratio.

But to each his own.

Frank
 
Coming to the party late.... Just saw this yesterday. What an awesome option for AF100 and Gh2 recording. I think that the Blackmagic products are awesome and such reasonably priced technology.
 
Think this is an excellent green/blue screen recording option - that's what I intend to use it for. Wouldn't, necessarily, want to shoot an entire feature - or corporate video, for that matter with it (given the file sizes) - but I can't see much better out there for recording effects shots on my EX1.
 
Just ordered the Hypershuttle through Markertek. They show it as "in stock" - we'll see. I'll let you all in on what I find out - when/if it arrives.
 
Just ordered the Hypershuttle through Markertek. They show it as "in stock" - we'll see. I'll let you all in on what I find out - when/if it arrives.

Did you get a tracking number? Can you confirm that it has shipped and that they are in fact in stock? I'm tempted to order one myself.
 
No tracking number, yet. As a matter of fact, Markertek changed their online ad, since I ordered. Seems the Hyperdeck will be drop shipped. So - no, it appears they aren't "in stock," as originally stated. They're now saying 7-10 days for delivery. Guess I'll believe that when I see it.
 
Back
Top