gh13 and 5d mark 2 IQ and DR comparison

On the scene settings, for what it's worth, I shot smooth at -2 everything for months based on early forum recommendations, but switched to Nostalgic a couple of months ago and haven't looked back.
I do love the amount of shadow detail Nostalgic at -2 keeps, but I fell in love with how the Smooth mode handles highlights. Nostalgic's highlight handling looks too "digital" in comparison to me. In most situations, I prefer the smooth highlight rolloff and throw a little more light on the shadows when I can. Different strokes.

Oh, and thanks for this test Hunter! Much appreciated!
 
Soooo... any more tests of GH13 vs 5D2? I'm not gonna lie and try to justify any reasoning and look for excuses, but it really looks like the GH13 is messing up my beloved 5D2 in the video department ..the framegrabs tell me much more than all the excuses and posts I've been reading.
 
It isn't a surprise at all. Since a year ago, GH1 beats the 5D Mark II in the sharpness or aliasing departments, for example. For some reason, this camera has been preferred to be used rather than the Canons for certain shots. Now, when there is a new codec or a higher bitrate as add-on, would it be helpful to see any comparison tests with the same glass? Yes, indeed.
 
Hmm... you think it's possible for Tester13 to make a similar hack for the Canon 5D2? Maybe even a feature that only uses the 1.6 crop or 4/3 part of the FF sensor for less aliasing/moire & no line skipping?

...maybe with a lot of donations from all of us??? :) :) :)
 
Doubtful. The way the 5D firmware works is probably vastly different from that of the GH1.

Remember, all the GH1 hack is doing is changing the codec settings. Trying to get the camera to do something that wasn't in the original firmware is rather wishful thinking, esp. as there's only one guy on the job. It's not as if you can just tell it to crop the image without writing/seriously modifying the code. :)

Besides, no amount of firmware modding will help remove the moire on the 5D, the hardware isn't capable.

With the GH1, the hardware was capable of more. The Canons are pretty maxed out already and there's not much room for improvement.
 
Would it be a dumb move to replace/trade/sell my 5d2 & ZE glass for a GH13 set up and new glass? The GH13 is really impressing me more and more I research into it.
 
Well, the best way to go might be to just add a GH13 to your setup; buy the body-only for $600 or whatever. Problem is, the ZE lenses don't have aperture rings on 'em, and right now while you can easily mount Canon-mount lenses on an m4/3 body like the GH1, there's not any easy way to adjust the aperture on them. I do expect that some enterprising entrepreneur will solve that issue soon, but no idea how soon.
 
I can't decide which mode to shoot in, Nostalgic or SMooth. I just go with Nostalgic and everything dialed down, but it would be nice to be able to dial down further. Maybe turn Noise Reduction OFF and make sure that it's off.

Reduce in camera sharpening to non-existent, those sorts of parameters.

Kholi,

That's way I shoot with it too. Nostalgic -2 on everything- And I also use iExposure mode on high. Very similar to circuits in high end video cameras, with a different name of course.

Hunter; this was a great test you did, and very insightful..

Pappas
 
Today I shot Smooth with everything dialed down to -2, no iExposure (although I think I could've used it and just forgot to throw it on) and it looked pretty good.

I still need to actually do my own comparisons. Doh.
 
I've heard good things from reputable people about those gamma curves that are for sale. On the other hand, buying curves does seem silly, especially having used Canons Picture Style Editor. After building a few custom curves with it, I quickly realized that any curve made in that program likely to have issues and to be mostly guesswork as the software's curve editor implementation is one of the worst I've ever seen, and the HSL adjustment is nearly as bad. The limitations of the software would significantly hinder anyone's ability to make a worthwhile curve. That combined with the lack of information about the curves on lightillusion's website makes me very skeptical of buying them. The sample images have no skin tones, no high contrast areas, etc. So not much can be judged about these curves without buying them first.
 
I was always wondering why those Zacuto guys had 9 stops for GH1 against 11 for Canons in their latitude test?

Barry calculated 8 and 1/3 stops in his test.
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canoneos5dmarkii/page25.asp

Dpreview had 8.4 for 5D mark II with the same Stouffer Step Wedge as Barry's.
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canoneos5dmarkii/page25.asp

Hunter's test demonstrates pretty much equal dynamic range. How could it turn out then that Zacuto had different figures?

I guess the clue is that Barry's and dpreview's paper tests as well as Hunter's real world one are REFLECTED light test while Zacuto did theirs with DIRECT light coming though some semitransparent bar thing.

And as we know GH1 has a peculiarity of overexposing the direct light sources such as light bulbs or sun in some halo-ish manner. THAT is what happened to Zacuto guys. The halo around the direct light had eaten a part of dynamic range - the next bar to the brightest one or few of them.

Does this mean that GH1 has shallower dynamic range than Canons? It depends on the situation. If there are direct light sources in the scene it will be technically shallower because of the overexposed areas around the direct lights. But for the scenes like Hunter's there shouldn't be any difference at all.

BTW I also tried to play with contrast and gamma settings of his pics and I have to admit that they're highly tweakable. You can get them as milky as Canon's and even more - there are plenty of details in the shadows. there's only that thing that Pana's pictures have contrastier gamma by default, they're more "baked in". But that's correctable. Which is good.
 
Here is a Japanese Gh1 vs 550D test that demonstrates exactly what I'm trying to say.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0EGOZEWNzM4

Look at the first few sunset scenes. There's very little difference in cloud details or in shadows around the houses. But then in the take 4 comes the sun! Ta-da! Look at the halo around it and how washed out and flat the cloudy sky becomes. While Canon still maintains the richness of crimson gradients.
 
BTW I also tried to play with contrast and gamma settings of his pics and I have to admit that they're highly tweakable. You can get them as milky as Canon's and even more - there are plenty of details in the shadows. there's only that thing that Pana's pictures have contrastier gamma by default, they're more "baked in". But that's correctable. Which is good.

I’ve noticed this as well with my new GH-1. I can basically get the same type of “milky” picture with my GH-1 as I did with my previous 7D…but better detail. This was my main concern because that’s what I liked about the Canons and was used to seeing a much more contrast(y) (baked in) image in GH-1 footage from others. Also Nostalgic mode with sharpness turned down gives that smooth look I’m used to from Canon (with no artificial looking edge enhancements).
 
Shooting with a hood improves the contrast and limits the "milky" look some what, at least that's what i've found using old FD canon lenses. I don't have the kit lens to compare but the newer coatings probably help with this.

R
 
Nice test.

I just received my GH1 few days ago and probably missed some nice comparative tests in this forum or other places.

Anyone care to share the best ones?!

Thanks.
 
great grabs and testing, will take me a good few reads to full understand it all.

what a beautiful location/studio space!
 
Back
Top