gh13 and 5d mark 2 IQ and DR comparison

Out of curiosity, why did you use the iExposure on the GH1?
Hm, didn't notice that before. Yeah, if you're going to use iExposure on the GH1, then you should also use the Canon equivalent, I think it's called the Auto Lighting Optimizer. If you don't want to use it on one, you shouldn't use it on the other...
 
This is off the topic of dynamic range, but I also notice a lot of fringing and chromatic aberration on the second GH1 shot (the one with a person in it). The windows on the left and the ceiling pipes on the upper left especially. Does the 20mm pancake usually have that much chromatic aberration?
 
Last edited:
also test with highlight tone priority enabled!!! :)
HTP is another kind of iExposure type of thing. It doesn't actually increase dynamic range, it just gains up the darker sections of the video (adding noise). But it helps you protect your highlights.

None of them (iExposure, HTP, or ALO) actually increase the dynamic range of what the sensor is actually capturing. They just change the way the in-camera processing handles the signal. HTP underexposes everything by a stop, and then puts gain on the darker parts to bring the brightness back up.

I would normally recommend having all those features turned off, so you can test the raw performance of what the camera can actually capture. Or, if you want to see how far it can be stretched in-camera, go ahead and turn them on, but they should be enabled equally for all the cameras in any given test.
 
Thanks for posting the comparisons

There seems to be a decoding error, or error in footage in post #8 of the GH1(3): There is a block artifact over the left wrist.
http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/showpost.php?p=2023481&postcount=8

Can you review the footage and see if this is persistent? and check if it was from decoding (maybe switch decoders), or screenshot capture method

Also can you comment on which patch settings were used

Thanks
 
Thanks for posting the comparisons

There seems to be a decoding error, or error in footage in post #8 of the GH1(3): There is a block artifact over the left wrist.

Nice catch, but not to worry. There are no errors in the footage. I see those during playback when using VLC (i used screen capture to grab screen shots)- there are no errors when I transcode the footage, just VLC making on the fly decoding.
 
Nice catch, but not to worry. There are no errors in the footage. I see those during playback when using VLC (i used screen capture to grab screen shots)- there are no errors when I transcode the footage, just VLC making on the fly decoding.


So this suggests that this is a VLC decoding error?

Is it a repeatable & consistent over the same frame ?

What software are you using to transcode?
 
Hm, didn't notice that before. Yeah, if you're going to use iExposure on the GH1, then you should also use the Canon equivalent, I think it's called the Auto Lighting Optimizer. If you don't want to use it on one, you shouldn't use it on the other...

Good point-I used iexposure because it lowers contrast, with it off the -2 setting just doesnt make the image match the canons larger range of contrast reduction.

I havent seen that feature in the canon before but ill try to find it and do another with HTP on AND auto lighting on. Gotta run a few errands first then ill be back.

For full disclosure, the point of this little test isnt to make the gh1 look better, its just too see how they pair up on my normal shooting settings for both cameras. What I have found is that they are very very close in performance now, not in high iso's im sure but for normal shooting- a hacked gh1 seems like the best bang for your buck.
 
So this suggests that this is a VLC decoding error?

Is it a repeatable & consistent over the same frame ?

What software are you using to transcode?

Yes, it happens on every clip when I playback in vlc, not just with this camera, any mts clip. I use log and transfer. I assure you there are no issues like this with the actual footage, ive pixel peeped for stuff like this.
 
Will second that VLC is probably the culprit. It's terrible for playing back video files.

Even simply throwing up some anime that doesn't have glitches in it, VLC shreds it.

Dunno why. It used to work well.

Thanks for doing the comparison, Hunter. I'm out and out surprised at the way the sky's less blown out on the GH1.

Weird.
 
I'm very interested to see how the GH1 would compare in the zacuto tests, specifically if there would be any change to the lightbulb scene in particular.

Thanks Hunter for the tests! Your sample short the other day finally convinced me that I needed to buy a GH1 for testing this hack. :D
 
HTP is another kind of iExposure type of thing. It doesn't actually increase dynamic range, it just gains up the darker sections of the video (adding noise). But it helps you protect your highlights.

Hi Barry, HTP does indeed get you extra dynamic range in video mode by mapping the mid tone in a lower zone (1stop lower) therefore achieving one extra stop in the highlights while having the same amount in the shadows (but noiser, of course). It seems to be an "infinite" ammount of DR in the shadows, that are recorded in raw, but clipped in video mode.

Shifting the mid grey should in fact not increase DR in the RAW, but we are not shooting raw, but highly compressed RGB/YUV.
Same trick as high end cameras basically.
 
Hunter,

I'm not sure what's going on in the last two test shots, but you look a lot more pensive in the GH1 shot. :D

Nice work and thanks!
 
Thanks Hunter, few comments

Thanks Hunter, few comments

edit: double posted on accident...

Notes,

If you use the 20mm at f2, you would use a 35mm Canon at f3.5, or 20mm at f4 would be about f6.7 say on the Canon 35mm. Interesting about the iso though, which is a bit of folklore but is obviously true.

Good test, note I notice quite a bit of CA on my 20mm.

Good test though, thanks
 
Two things. Both somewhat off-topic:
1) Seeing how the iExposure on the GH1 boosts the shadows to where there's less chroma noise on the white wall, I'm definitely going to experiment with using it. It definitely creates a lower contrast image.

2) If your 20mm and 40mm are both accurate in their f-stops (for the first 2 photos you posted), then the implications are huge, because if 100 ISO on the GH1 is equivalent to 400 ISO on the Canon 5D, then the low-light advantage of the Canons over the GH1 is suspect. Assuming a similar correlation between ISOs, wouldn't 400 ISO on the GH1 equal the 5D's 1600 ISO? I'm not sure that's logical or correct, but a 2-stop difference from 100 ISO to 400 ISO is huge.

I've never shot with a 5D, so I can't comment further on this idea. I've found a close relation between the GH1's meter and my Sekonic meter, so I've always balked at the discrepancy in ISO's between Canon, Nikon, Panasonic, etc. With all this variance, how does anyone use an external light meter with confidence?

Anyway, thanks for all the test shots, Hunter.
 
Back
Top