gh13 and 5d mark 2 IQ and DR comparison

I can't decide which mode to shoot in, Nostalgic or SMooth. I just go with Nostalgic and everything dialed down, but it would be nice to be able to dial down further. Maybe turn Noise Reduction OFF and make sure that it's off.

Reduce in camera sharpening to non-existent, those sorts of parameters.
 
Yet the #34

Yet the #34

In that first set of pictures something strikes me as odd. But the plant and room in general looks out of focus on the 5Dll compared to the GH-1....and I know you said they were focussed the same. But when you look at the background (mountains, buildings etc. outside the window) everything on the 5Dll looks sharper than in the GH-1 pictures. Am I crazy?
No, you are not. Once Hunter said the focus is on the plant, as same as you, I wonder myself why...?
That's why I asked about the aperture on the GH1.

Or maybe the fake detail aka aliasing may have some use after all. LOL
Aside the fact the 4/3" Pancake is in its full aperture as mere academic hypothesis, we would have 1-1 1/4 stop (4/5.6 for full frame Canon) for such DOF difference (?)
 
Last edited:
Notes,

If you use the 20mm at f2, you would use a 35mm Canon at f3.5, or 20mm at f4 would be about f6.7 say on the Canon 35mm.
BTW, it would be interesting to have full information on the lens used. 35mm? Canon FD?

There is obvious CA with the Canon what clearly means the difference of glass quality comparing with the superior Pancake. Apples to oranges IMHO. Here's a link about the use of different glass in camera comparison tests:

http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/showthread.php?t=213806


Curious discussion in any way.
 
Dial in AdobeRGB in colour space too in GH13;-)

Dial in AdobeRGB in colour space too in GH13;-)

You find this in the camera icons, pag4, colour space, once dialed in from a std PASM setting, carries over to all video settings in CMM, but only uncover the option in still icon? you will see lot less "garish" colour much "flatter", try it.
 
No, you are not. Once Hunter said the focus is on the plant, as same as you, I wonder myself why...?
That's why I asked about the aperture on the GH1.

Or maybe the fake detail aka aliasing may have some use after all. LOL

On that one I just matched histograms the best I could (didnt have time make a full scene reading), the gh1 was at about ~2.2 as I was trying to somewhat match dof. It could be because I used a 35mm (instead of a 40mm) that there may have been more dof than I anticipated OR its also possible that your seeing perceived "focus" because I turned the sharpness on the 5d to 4 to try and match the GH1 sharpening (which was at -2).
 
You find this in the camera icons, pag4, colour space, once dialed in from a std PASM setting, carries over to all video settings in CMM, but only uncover the option in still icon? you will see lot less "garish" colour much "flatter", try it.

It is in that color space.
 
BTW, it would be interesting to have full information on the lens used. 35mm? Canon FD?

There is obvious CA with the Canon what clearly means the difference of glass quality comparing with the superior Pancake.

That is definatly part of it, the 20mm pancake is extremely high contrast, the only 35mm I have is a pretty old vivitar, but it is quite stopped down and out resolves the HD video modes if you compared it with a still- definatly lower contrast though which makes it seem less sharp I think.f I shot a still with the canon of the same scene with the same lens, it would definatly win. I can call a few friends and try to borrow a zeiss ZF 35mm and do a reshoot.

The main thing I noticed though is that the 5d looks out of focus with any lens compared to the gh1- the nikkor 50mm 1.4 ais is sharp as hell stopped down (first shot) but it still looks soft in HD video mode.

Edit: Here is a still taken with this same vivitar I have so you can see that it is sharp enough to out resolve 1080 (found on flickr):
http://www.flickr.com/photos/34326258@N03/3838290527/sizes/o/
 
Last edited:
On the scene settings, for what it's worth, I shot smooth at -2 everything for months based on early forum recommendations, but switched to Nostalgic a couple of months ago and haven't looked back.
 
That is definatly part of it, the 20mm pancake is extremely high contrast, the only 35mm I have is a pretty old vivitar, but it is quite stopped down and out resolves the HD video modes if you compared it with a still- definatly lower contrast though which makes it seem less sharp I think.f I shot a still with the canon of the same scene with the same lens, it would definatly win. I can call a few friends and try to borrow a zeiss ZF 35mm and do a reshoot.

The main thing I noticed though is that the 5d looks out of focus with any lens compared to the gh1- the nikkor 50mm 1.4 ais is sharp as hell stopped down (first shot) but it still looks soft in HD video mode.
Thanks for your input. Yes, it seems the GH1 sharpness is out of question. So, there's no doubt there should be any reason for those #34 samples and outcome. Unfortunately, the Zeiss ZF (AFAIK Zeiss branded, manufactured by Cosina) is not the best as far as CA/color fringing concerns. And we'd be testing with different glass anyways.

The best should be to have the same zoom lens, used in its different focal lengths with one and another. A 16-35mm L, if available, would actually be great.
 
i'm satisfied with this as a sharpness comparison, even with such different lenses.

all we need now is an ISO/noise comparison for lowlight footage! hint hint :)
 
I can't decide which mode to shoot in, Nostalgic or SMooth. I just go with Nostalgic and everything dialed down, but it would be nice to be able to dial down further. Maybe turn Noise Reduction OFF and make sure that it's off.

Reduce in camera sharpening to non-existent, those sorts of parameters.

I've been shooting Standard and will keep on shooting it in most situations at least until the blue shift issue is resolved (which it may soon be, the thought is that's what the update from Panasonic is.) Usually contrast -2, sat 0, sharpness +1 (you heard me), and NR -2.
 
i'm satisfied with this as a sharpness comparison, even with such different lenses.

all we need now is an ISO/noise comparison for lowlight footage! hint hint :)

It's Kholi's turn. :kiss:

It has to be DOF matched too otherwise it's kinda floored IMO. Whatever ISO on the GH13 vs 1250 ISO on the 5D would be cool. Something like a 50mm @ f/2 vs a 105mm @ f/4-5.6 under street lights.
 
If you can get your hands on the 45mmPL?

If you can get your hands on the 45mmPL?

It's Kholi's turn. :kiss:

It has to be DOF matched too otherwise it's kinda floored IMO. Whatever ISO on the GH13 vs 1250 ISO on the 5D would be cool. Something like a 50mm @ f/2 vs a 105mm @ f/4-5.6 under street lights.

The PanasonicLeica 45mmf2.8 macro is a really nice lens, that against a Canon in the 80mm area f4.5/f5 will give you close equivalents. As you say though set the Canon at iso1250 for exposure and see what you need to do to match with the GH1, would be very interesting.:undecided
 
It's Kholi's turn. :kiss:

It has to be DOF matched too otherwise it's kinda floored IMO. Whatever ISO on the GH13 vs 1250 ISO on the 5D would be cool. Something like a 50mm @ f/2 vs a 105mm @ f/4-5.6 under street lights.

We'll have to see. I'm burned in on PL glass and I need to be able to test it with some T1.3 goodness @ wide ends.
 
Edit: Here is a still taken with this same vivitar I have so you can see that it is sharp enough to out resolve 1080 (found on flickr):
http://www.flickr.com/photos/34326258@N03/3838290527/sizes/o/
Sure, it can handle 1080... It is a 35mm lens after all. LOL :)

The point is what we add when we're comparing capture devices with distinct glass. We cannot accurately compare the sharpness of two cameras when there are different levels of sharpness between both lenses placed there. The difference of quality is quite noticeable, the amount of CA speaks by itself.

Thanks for your effort anyway.
 
In a perfect world, both would have matched lenses with matched fov, but it just wasnt possible for me. This was the best way I could match FOV (mainly to access realworld DR for the scene) and I hope it gives somewhat of a glipse at the difference between these two cameras; which is; they are more simlar than what we first imagined.
 
No problem. You did with what you had at your disposal. Much much better than nothing. We could discuss and learn with your test. That's what counts in the end. Without your contribution, this forum would be poorer. If you'll have any chance to add a different approach with another piece of glass suitable for both capture devices in behalf of an add-on to your test, it would be a sweet spot indeed. Thanks again for your entry.
 
Back
Top