gh13 and 5d mark 2 IQ and DR comparison

dvbrother- Thanks, I used my sekonic L758 and I found it to be more in line with the GH1 than the 5d as well. It was less of a difference with the canon in "superflat" mode, but I would say the gh1 is faster by at least a stop for the same iso. Dxomark.com has some great sensor tests and shows the gh1's listed iso's are about 1/2stop faster where the canons are almost 1/2stop slower than the listed iso, it also says (in RAW) that the Gh1 has 11.3 stops DR while the Canon has 11.6, I didnt beleive they were that close but after today- im a beliver. ; )
 
Thanks for doing this! I think I'm doing to mess around with the iexposure settings more.
 
Thanks Hunter, great tests.

The 5D appears to have a slight edge over the GH13 with the superflat profile. There's a lot more detail in the clouds, I like fluffy clouds. You're right about bang for buck though, they're damn close.
 
«I like fluffy clouds...» LOL Anthony... We practically posted at the same time even if in different sections of this forum. I was answering to another post of yours to a previous comment of mine about these cameras. Horses for courses anyway.

I like to have both tools in my bag, though.
 
Who requested Superflat, anyway? That's the worst profile you can throw on the 5D/7D. Looks like crap in any real situation.

Neutral dialed down is more plausible.

Regardless, though, great comparisons Big Richards!
 
I threw out the superflat suggestion, just so we could get to the bottom of the "it adds three stops of DR" question once and for all.
 
In that first set of pictures something strikes me as odd. But the plant and room in general looks out of focus on the 5Dll compared to the GH-1....and I know you said they were focussed the same. But when you look at the background (mountains, buildings etc. outside the window) everything on the 5Dll looks sharper than in the GH-1 pictures. Am I crazy? PLus the GH-1's images have halos around the plants edge etc. Is sharpening all the way down?

Thanks for doing all of this by the way.
 
One little note: If you smoothly roll of the highlights, you get a similar highlight response as the 5D. The way the Gh1 naturally rolls off highlights is extremly ugly in my opinion.


Uploaded with ImageShack.us
 
^ Gotta agree with that. You do need to really tame the highlights. NDs and Pola in front of the lens help this a lot.
 
plasmasp, are you rolling the highlights off there by tweaking the luma curve or some other technique?
 
In that first set of pictures something strikes me as odd. But the plant and room in general looks out of focus on the 5Dll compared to the GH-1....and I know you said they were focussed the same. But when you look at the background (mountains, buildings etc. outside the window) everything on the 5Dll looks sharper than in the GH-1 pictures. Am I crazy?
No, you are not. Once Hunter said the focus is on the plant, as same as you, I wonder myself why...?
That's why I asked about the aperture on the GH1.

Or maybe the fake detail aka aliasing may have some use after all. LOL
 
This time I used "standard" mode on the gh1 with the same settings above applied. Interesting how the standard mode effected the image on the GH1, makes the canon almost look over exposed.

So what is the conclusion on whether to use Standard or Nostalgic Mode on the GH1 from the images posted here?

Randy
 
In "smooth" mode or "nostalgic" the highlight rolloff is better than "standard" mode, I would like to see how the sky looks with the GH1 in "smooth" mode because in all pictures but the first it looks unnaturally oversaturated/cyan compared to the 5D.
 
Back
Top