GH1 firmware research volunteers required

Will recording at a higher bit rate risk damaging the sensor?

The sensor delivers the same amount of frames, the encoding is handled by another chip, so the sensor isn't doing any more work.

Same with 1080p mjpeg?

Same deal, the sensor is delivering the same amount of data as in the AVCHD 1080p modes.

Why do the canon's overheat and the gh1 doesn't?

I guess different sensor design and/or better internal cooling arrangements.
 
Guys here is my summary:

1. As for camera - it is better just to buy new one and have full warranty, Car3o will keep original box and warranty papers, so I could send camera back in case of serious trouble.
Panasonic don't have worldwide guarantee, right?

2. As for AVCHD, we need systemetic testing.
As I said, from low bitrates, up to high ones.
And find tool that can show P/I ratio and P,I frames maximum and average sizes.
As we have some conflicting reports.

3. New 720p 23,97 and 60i wrapper patches still not tested.

4. MJPEG patch will be tuned. If necessary, I'll temporarty split it on more parts to test where we have problems.
 
Last edited:
MJPEG update: camera freezes only when recording more than 4 o 5 seconds, 3
second videos are OK, fluid 24p and 24mbps.

It's more than likely some firmware glitches, but just to be sure -- are you positive that you're using a SD card that can handle 24 mbps write?
 
It's more than likely some firmware glitches, but just to be sure -- are you positive that you're using a SD card that can handle 24 mbps write?

I believe we really have a glitch, we'll look if improved patch can fix that.
It'll be interesting to really push upper limit of MJPEG bitrate.

Added research parameters, I belive allow you to play with encoding settings. And we'll see that could be made out of it.
 
most SD cards can easily support 24mbs. that's only 3MB a sec. so there's plenty of head room. going to order Gh1 from cameraland tomorrow. the reason i'm going that route is ONLY to go with a fresh warranty and new camera that way it's straight out of the box for testing purposes. but the response for people to get their camera's out there for tester was awesome, thanks. i'll keep everyone up to date with camera delivery and will notify tester and the boards when i receive and ship out.
 
Testing 3.06

MJPEG mode working well:

Video
ID : 1
Format : M-JPEG
Codec ID : jpeg
Duration : 59s 500ms
Bit rate mode : Variable
Bit rate : 12.2 Mbps
Width : 1 280 pixels
Height : 720 pixels
Display aspect ratio : 16:9
Frame rate mode : Constant
Frame rate : 24.000 fps
Bits/(Pixel*Frame) : 0.551
Stream size : 86.4 MiB (96%)
Language : English
Encoded date : UTC 2010-04-27 10:40:43
Tagged date : UTC 2010-04-27 10:40:43
 
Last edited:
And:

VA bitrate adjustment (X) - 19000000 <- This value can't be more - 200000000 can't work
VA bitrate adjustment 2 (X) - 21000000


This value don't work: (freeze camera when I want to push rec button)

VA param 1 - 6
VA param 2 - 600
VA param 3 - 42768
VA param 4 - 493216
VA param 5 - 6


Next test:

VA param 3 - 65536 (don't change anything)

FHD

Bit rate : 13.0 Mbps
Maximum bit rate : 16.6 Mbps

SHD (this mode changing visual, when shot video, don't see 50p, it like 24p, but recording in 50p)

Bit rate : 12.4 Mbps
Maximum bit rate : 16.6 Mbps

AU Audio encoding bps - 320000 (changing well)

Audio
ID : 4352 (0x1100)
Menu ID : 1 (0x1)
Format : AC-3
Format/Info : Audio Coding 3
Format_Settings_ModeExtension : CM (complete main)
Duration : 1mn 32s
Bit rate mode : Constant
Bit rate : 320 Kbps
Channel(s) : 2 channels
Channel positions : Front: L R
Sampling rate : 48.0 KHz
Stream size : 3.51 MiB (2%)

And one moment: This modify file camera can't play ;) it can show only PC.
 
Last edited:
Any news on backing out the firmware to 1.21 original? Or is the current plan to alter the version bits in an where every patch its minor_version++? tester13, "Version Up" routines don't support it due to lens firmware conjoined?

We have plenty of room, up to 0xFFFF :-)
Reverting thing need time and patience, as we must be absolutely sure that all things are clear, otherwise this upgrade will be you last one :-)
 
NURBS


Thanks for testing, but be more sistematic.
Change one thing at a time.
a) Set
VA param 1 = 6
VA param 5 = 7

Do not touch anything else (except Version, of course).
Look at produced file.
You need I and P frames information.

b) Next, set Bitrates as follows
Top Limit - checked
Bitrate 1 - around 10
Bitrate 2 - around 8

P.S. Look at private messages for some present :-)
 
Last edited:
Great work, everyone, especially Tester13.

I'd help but I know nuts about programming :-(

One request: sometime, when the video codecs are done, would appreciate a look at trying to switch off the AGC that's causing everyone all that audio grief.

Thanks again to everyone involved.
 
One request: sometime, when the video codecs are done, would appreciate a look at trying to switch off the AGC that's causing everyone all that audio grief.

I am working on AGC, but it is not near.
We'll try to approach it from high level and from low level.
For starters we must know used CODEC chip, so if anyone have anough courage and want to remove outer shell and look at audio PCB, it could help.
Next, I'll add few research audio parameters to experiment in next versions.
Some of them can set level and/or AGC.
 
I'm sorry for the ignorance, guys. I've been working with photography and kind of left the video world for sometime now...but these new DSLRs that can film in Hd REALLY interest me. So my question is, in practical visual terms what is the benefit of a 24Mbps bitrate as opposed to 17Mbps? I mean what I've seen a lot of GH1 footage shot with a 17Mbps bitrate. VISUALLY what improvements can I expect from a 7Mbps bitrate increase?
 
I'm sorry for the ignorance, guys. I've been working with photography and kind of left the video world for sometime now...but these new DSLRs that can film in Hd REALLY interest me. So my question is, in practical visual terms what is the benefit of a 24Mbps bitrate as opposed to 17Mbps? I mean what I've seen a lot of GH1 footage shot with a 17Mbps bitrate. VISUALLY what improvements can I expect from a 7Mbps bitrate increase?

Try to comress JPEG to 50% quality and then to 75%. Check it out.
Problem is that upping bitrate (and we still do not have stable version) is not enought, we must play with I,P frames and their maximum sizes.
 
Try to comress JPEG to 50% quality and then to 75%. Check it out.

I believe - but not 100% sure - that this is not really correct. The increase of the max. bitrate gives more room for fast pans, objects and so on. (or in other words: its vbr not cbr)
You have to raise the average bitrate as well to increase overall video bitrate/quality. Maybe the average bitrate will automaticly raised with higher max. bitrate but i don't believe that (see most video render software).

Nevertheless it's a great project and a lot of people - me too - are very excited. :Drogar-Happy(DBG):
 
Back
Top