Barry_Green
Moderator
I'll post a clip. No doubt in my mind that it's keyframe pulsing.What sample where you looking at ? Perhaps you are desribing something else, not keyframe pulsing ?
Totally disagree. Of course a P-frame can be much higher quality than the I-frame. The P-frame is not targeted to match the I-frame, it's targeted to match the raw uncompressed frame that's fed to the coder. A P-frame looks at the changes between the previous frame, and the target frame. If the target frame is incredibly complex, and the previous frame is mushy, the P-frame will use its bandwidth to encode the changes between the mushy frame and the detailed reference frame.because in theory a P-frame cannot be higher quality than the I-frame it's using as reference.
Each frame in the GoP does not care what the prior frame looks like, it instead cares what the target frame (the uncompressed image) looks like, and makes its best effort to look like that target frame. So yes, cyclic codec pulsing is very possible if the I-frame does a poor job on the first frame in the GoP.
In the clip I will post, you can watch it happen. The keyframe (I-frame) looks horrible because it's got nowhere near enough bandwidth to represent the image properly. Then the P-frames bring it successively up to snuff, adding more and more detail, until - smack, 15 frames later, the cycle starts all over again with a lousy I-frame.
Whereas if the I-frame was a good-quality image in the first place, then the P-frames would have very little work to do to maintain that quality image throughout the GoP.