hyphygreek
Well-known member
http://vimeo.com/25071757
Done for our Senior Thesis Project +2 Armor. Comparing a rental kit to the kit I own. AF100 with standard primes (rental kit) and GH2 with Canon FD primes (own kit).
Last edited:
AF100 vs GH2 Resolution/Gamma test
- Thread starter hyphygreek
- Start date
http://vimeo.com/25071757
Done for our Senior Thesis Project +2 Armor. Comparing a rental kit to the kit I own. AF100 with standard primes (rental kit) and GH2 with Canon FD primes (own kit).
hyphygreek
Well-known member
We were comparing the rental kit with the kit I own. Plus we didn't have much time.
David W. Jones
Veteran
Exactly... Should have used the same lens with the same f-stop.
hyphygreek
Well-known member
My point wasn't to see which camera/sensor is better. My point and mission was to compare the AF100/Zeiss rental kit to my own GH2/canon FD kit.
Ed Kishel
Veteran
good effort, but without the same lens on both cameras you can't make definitive conclusions about the sensor. It's like if you were testing two different brands of tires on which one handles better- and you put "brand A" on a Kia and "brand B" was put on a Audi. Which car do you think is going to handle better? The Audi. But do you really think it was the tire? Without using the Kia for both brands, you can't really say.
hyphygreek
Well-known member
Ive done the test with same lenses a different time. And now, I did the other test I needed to do. I don't understand what the fus is about.
PaPa
Major Contributor
The fus is just about people's expectations of what a test like this should be showing. There isn't anything here that the boards and users can learn from your test. Your title indicates "AF100 vs GH2 Resolution/Gamma test" Anyone reading that would expect to see somethign interesting and this test fell short of it's own name. That's all.
hyphygreek
Well-known member
I'm done.
Last edited:
Ed Kishel
Veteran
he's done...
We're (or at least I'm) not digging on you for doing the test. It has merit in that it gives some insight into different lens/camera combos. We just can't infer about the sensor because there is no common denominator. Thanks for posting the footage though- at least you are testing the cams out yourself to learn more and share with others.
We're (or at least I'm) not digging on you for doing the test. It has merit in that it gives some insight into different lens/camera combos. We just can't infer about the sensor because there is no common denominator. Thanks for posting the footage though- at least you are testing the cams out yourself to learn more and share with others.
PaPa
Major Contributor
Why are you done man? We're simply explaining what the "fus" was about? Lol, no one's beating you up but I get the sense that you're reading too much into it and taking it, perhaps, too emotionally? It's difficult to read posts without putting a voice behind the text.
Tests are great. People do tests all the time and then they post the tests. People watch the tests and give feedback, it's not a reason to throw your hands up in the air.
This test is definitely something I've been wanting to see. You have heard the boards, we are interested. And if you have time, do the test again but change the parameters so we can compare apples to apples. Would be very worthwhile.