Why did we jump from HD to 4K?

We're supposedly now in the big kickoff year of 4K, and it has me wondering... considering all the minuscule leaps the camera makers give us in bitrates/codecs, why have they not make more incremental steps towards 4k?

The answer is probably simple: to cross promote with all the 4k tvs coming out.

but still, 2.5K 2.7K, 3K, all are significant jumps from HD, and yet the only cameras to make the increment are the bmc and gopro black.

what think you?
 
It is just math.

The 4k standard is actually 4 1080p screens.

It scales perfectly.

2.5K 2.7K, 3K is not a standard.
 
Yeah, I have been thinking about that, and have made some mention on the 4K threads. Ain't gonna happen, I guess. You think someone would have wanted to go to school on the Alexa with 2K prores and 2K raw, which seemed to do pretty well! I would buy a dedicated 2K camera. I think that the workflow would be somewhat less bulky. I also think that it may just be enough resolution, and is certainly enough for what I'm doing.

The hybrid solution from Sony seems to have stumbled some on the OLPF. Anyway, got my vote.
 
Good topic -
And at a certain price point, it'd be nice to just get some REAL 1080 cameras before going to 4K. I suppose 4k down to 1080 will make for a better HD, but things like nice codecs, better DR and proper scaling sensors would also make for better 1080. Those things don't have the buzz sound manufacturers want though....4k MUST be better because it's 4K!
 
That's a good point. Wouldn't a dedicated 2K sensor allow for larger pixel sites and thus be more sensitive than a 4K sensor? Are there any benefits besides like DR, better codecs, or at least less strained codes? I bet you'd have pretty good HD down rezzing from 2880 X 1620.

Maybe I'm missing something. I admit that I don't know why engineers have skipped 2K. Maybe it's just math, as Matt says, or that in scaling a 2K camera for production doesn't provide enough benefit not to just go to 4K, but for the user, I think 2K would be a boon, for higher res, maybe better DR and sensitivity, and lighter workflow.

I don't know. I just keep thinking of all those feature films shot on 2K Alexas that look pretty dandy on CineAlta 4K projectors and say, yeah, that'd do it for me.
 
Maybe I'm missing something. I admit that I don't know why engineers have skipped 2K. Maybe it's just math...

It is just math, but it's certainly not the engineers' fault. The engineers will tell you now what they've said in the past -- that 1080p is "good enough". That consumers won't see much improvement from 4k below like a 100 inch screen size. And then only if they are sitting close enough.

The 4k thing is marketing math. It's "the revenge of 3D" if you will. 3D didn't work out very well for the manaufacturers. So... 4K. Anything to keep the consumers consuming. You've had that 1080p TV for three years! Time to move up!

What? You thought it was about image quality? Really?
 
Yeah... I kinda did.

I did too, for a while. I wanted to believe. I really did. Then I saw some movies shot on an Arri Alexa at 2k. In a theater, sitting toward the front, I couldn't tell even when I was looking for it. Final blow was Skyfall, Roger Deakins' work on Arris. A textbook in lighting for Arri. For me the results were considerably better than film, yet way less than 4k.

If I can't see it in the theater, what are the odds I can see it at home? (I can distinguish 720p from 1080i, but only when I'm trying to see just that, and my Panny plasma can show me just about everything there is to see in the signal it's given.) Even Blu-rays are quite compressed. If I can't see it at home, and can't see it in the theater, is it useful? Is it needed? If not, what's its purpose?

I can accept the argument that 4k is good capture technique, and then delivery is downsampled to 1080p. But that sorta kills the argument for the entire 4k delivery chain, from UHDTVs, HDMI 2.0, 4kBlu-ray, etc.

Which brings us full circle to the OPs question "Why did we jump from HD to 4K?" There doesn't seem to be a technical reason. And that leaves marketing. That's what I'm sayin'.
 
We're supposedly now in the big kickoff year of 4K, and it has me wondering... considering all the minuscule leaps the camera makers give us in bitrates/codecs, why have they not make more incremental steps towards 4k?

The answer is probably simple: to cross promote with all the 4k tvs coming out.

but still, 2.5K 2.7K, 3K, all are significant jumps from HD, and yet the only cameras to make the increment are the bmc and gopro black.

what think you?
That's what happens when consumer mentality takes over professional industry. Rat race for milions of pixels with very little relevance to the perceived IQ. Sad.. but there is hope- Alexa- incredibly popular 4K camera...wait, WHAT? it's HD only?!!! It must be crap then- never mind....Fu&k "Hugo" and its Oscar ;)
 
I did too, for a while. I wanted to believe. I really did. Then I saw some movies shot on an Arri Alexa at 2k. In a theater, sitting toward the front, I couldn't tell even when I was looking for it. Final blow was Skyfall, Roger Deakins' work on Arris. A textbook in lighting for Arri. For me the results were considerably better than film, yet way less than 4k.

If I can't see it in the theater, what are the odds I can see it at home? (I can distinguish 720p from 1080i, but only when I'm trying to see just that, and my Panny plasma can show me just about

That's my exact thought on my first post on this thread, that the features shot on Alexa at 2K are plenty for me.
 
I did too, for a while. I wanted to believe. I really did. Then I saw some movies shot on an Arri Alexa at 2k. In a theater, sitting toward the front, I couldn't tell even when I was looking for it. Final blow was Skyfall, Roger Deakins' work on Arris. A textbook in lighting for Arri. For me the results were considerably better than film, yet way less than 4k.

If I can't see it in the theater, what are the odds I can see it at home? (I can distinguish 720p from 1080i, but only when I'm trying to see just that, and my Panny plasma can show me just about everything there is to see in the signal it's given.) Even Blu-rays are quite compressed. If I can't see it at home, and can't see it in the theater, is it useful? Is it needed? If not, what's its purpose?

I can accept the argument that 4k is good capture technique, and then delivery is downsampled to 1080p. But that sorta kills the argument for the entire 4k delivery chain, from UHDTVs, HDMI 2.0, 4kBlu-ray, etc.

Which brings us full circle to the OPs question "Why did we jump from HD to 4K?" There doesn't seem to be a technical reason. And that leaves marketing. That's what I'm sayin'.
skyfall and pretty much every big budget film shooting ALEXA, shot on the codex box i.e. 2.8k RAW. Not 2k.
 
It is just math.

The 4k standard is actually 4 1080p screens.

It scales perfectly.

2.5K 2.7K, 3K is not a standard.

standards no, but do you really believe that scaling power is the crux? are people with BMC cameras having issues with their 2.5K cameras because of scaling?

4k computer monitors still aren't on the floors, but you know what is? 2560x1440 monitors. sounds like a good stone to step on to me

even if we're set on 2k and 4k as 'the' standards, having a camera that shoots in between just means you're either choosing to master by downscaling or upscaling. and again, i don't see scaling power or architecture as an issue of a higher but not 4k aquasition
 
This is all marketing. The camera manufacturers could care less. They have just spent the last three years getting us to give up SD and DV to go to HD and SD. Now they want us to move to th newest standard because they can't optimize the current one. My clients are all still SD, or only on "the web". To output to Blu Ray is radical. I predict collapse as the manufacturers race ahead into 4k long before the market is ready. Last year was 3D. This year 4K. To be clear, I remember distinctly being shown the first HD screen at Microsoft in 1996. It was touted as the next wave, but obviously it was not that for the midlevel video production industry until almost 10 years later! I tell this as a warning that no one ought to feel obliged to run into this new standard. It could be 3 to 5 years before it becomes embedded. The first HD cameras with SD or CF cards arrived, what, 5 years ago? 5Dmkii, AF100s, HMC150s, etc. The optimized versions of this, meaning the C500, etc. for mainstream videographers, has only recently arrived. If you are feeling like you have the money to invest to show off your sklls at the new format, be my guest. I'm still thrilled with the output my C100 is giving me No client of mine even understands 4k, let alone asks for it. Look at all the great work being done with existing formats. I think we need better storytellers, rather than another round of upgrades. Color me retro. I wish the manufacturers would invest the same amounts in scriptwriters rather than nextgen gear. Maybe even every other year?
 
Last edited:
The answer is pretty simpel: it's possible. Storage is getting bigger, compression has improved, internet is becoming faster. The digital infrastructure is already in place. All it takes is increasing the pixel count a bit.

Expect 8k in a year or 2.
 
Which is way short of 4k. Which is my point.
Sky fall was also up scaled to 4k and mastered in 4k for theater distribution, which is my point. Technology is moving fast. 4k has been talked about in the industry for years and years. Pretty much every film that gets scanned for digital copy is scanned at 4k and now 6k. So the content is there. It won't be long till more homes have 4k TVs. Even my parents bought a 4k tv (Sony 65" with 4k player), this year and can tell the difference at 4k compared to 1080.
 
This is all marketing. The camera manufacturers could care less. They have just spent the last three years getting us to give up SD and DV to go to HD and SD. Now they want us to move to th newest standard because they can't optimize the current one. My clients are all still SD, or only on "the web". To output to Blu Ray is radical. I predict collapse as the manufacturers race ahead into 4k long before the market is ready. Last year was 3D. This year 4K. To be clear, I remember distinctly being shown the first HD screen at Microsoft in 1996. It was touted as the next wave, but obviously it was not that for the midlevel video production industry until almost 10 years later! I tell this as a warning that no one ought to feel obliged to run into this new standard. It could be 3 to 5 years before it becomes embedded. The first HD cameras with SD or CF cards arrived, what, 5 years ago? 5Dmkii, AF100s, HMC150s, etc. The optimized versions of this, meaning the C500, etc. for mainstream videographers, has only recently arrived. If you are feeling like you have the money to invest to show off your sklls at the new format, be my guest. I'm still thrilled with the output my C100 is giving me No client of mine even understands 4k, let alone asks for it. Look at all the great work being done with existing formats. I think we need better storytellers, rather than another round of upgrades. Color me retro. I wish the manufacturers would invest the same amounts in scriptwriters rather than nextgen gear. Maybe even every other year?

Huge difference between the industry in '96 and today though. Content creation and content distribution are computer-centric from cradle to grave now and are advancing with the pace of Moore's Law. BetaSP ruled the roost for a couple of decades because it was expensive to create and roll out successful, propriety tape-based workflows. Now almost everything is file based so rolling out a new codec can be as simple as a software update or upgrading the processor on the next round of cameras. On the distribution side of things YouTube, for example, went from 240p to 1080p in about 5 years and it was pretty much invisible to the end user. Unlike the analog to digital switch in broadcast which was a much delayed, and confusing, pain in the butt. 4k also doesn't have all the downfalls of 3D (requires extra hardware, causes headaches & nausea in some users, etc.,.)

I think it'll be 4-7 years before 4k is mainstream. I don't get why people think the transition has to be instant to be successful. DVDs didn't hit their stride until about 4 years after the format's first release and I remember back in 2002-ish when the HDnet channel launched and only had 8 or 12 hours of HD content running on a loop.

As an aside, considering the ubiquity of HD screens (and greater than HD screens) that can view web content I would've stopped considering SD 'good enough' for the web years ago. The days of pixilated, postage stamp sized web videos are gone (at least in industrialized nations). It's easy to get web video on big HDTVs now not to mention that computer monitors are HD (if not higher) and even iPad screens are contain 1/3 more pixels than 1080p HD.


-Andrew
 
As usual, only upgrade if you have the work or can pay it off in a decent amount of time. "Future proofing" is a sales tactic more than a working reality. A lot of discussions here about 4k need a disclaimer attached that your clients are "very high end". Because anybody else will not need 4k. I am waiting for the low-baller customer calling to ask for a 4k internet video shoot for $400.

As far as better 1080 cameras, I totally agree. The C300 is pretty much that design and it creates amazing images with great light sensitivity. I would like to see this approach at the 1/3" chip level as I care more about professional functionality than gained-up and noised reduced 4k because the photosites are tiny. I already have 4k fatigue...:)
 
- TV sales are in the dumps. The big electronics firms need something new to push. It's mostly marketing to sell more gear.

- 4k is more than 2k so it must be better! There are legitimate reason for going 4k, but there are also a lot of 'amateurs' screaming for 4k and unfortunately they are a very loud voice that the manufacturers listen to.

- If you talk to almost anyone at the ASC / BSC etc they are perfectly happy with 2.8k out of the Alexa. They are mostly interested in more dynamic range and greater bit depth (16bit). Two factors which have far more impact on visible IQ than going from 2.8k to 4k. Not everyone is shooting a Lawrence of Arabia style epic, with actors the size of dots on a distant horizon. All DoP are paid to make the actors look good and almost anyone over the age of 16 can't stand the scrutiny of 4k and modern glass. There have even been cases where a major star has vetoed 4k, because it made them look like hell.

- There recently was a test done in LA (?). 4k native vs 2k to 4k, 2.8k to 4k, 4k to 2k, native 2k. From what I have heard the Alexa blown up to 4k was everyones favorite.

So, what's going to happen is that we are going to have 4k shoved down our throat and it will be diffused down to 2k via filters or in post. So, we'll end up pushing around 4 times the data with no gain and the DoP will lose dynamic range on set, because the receptors on the sensor are much smaller. But 4k, because bigger is always better.


I was looking the trailer for the movie about the painter Turner shot on the F65. Amazing color, but it was so sharp that everything looked fake. Everyone looked like a bunch of actors dressed in costume.
 
Last edited:
That's a good point. Wouldn't a dedicated 2K sensor allow for larger pixel sites and thus be more sensitive than a 4K sensor? Are there any benefits besides like DR, better codecs, or at least less strained codes? I bet you'd have pretty good HD down rezzing from 2880 X 1620.

Maybe I'm missing something. I admit that I don't know why engineers have skipped 2K. Maybe it's just math, as Matt says, or that in scaling a 2K camera for production doesn't provide enough benefit not to just go to 4K, but for the user, I think 2K would be a boon, for higher res, maybe better DR and sensitivity, and lighter workflow.

I don't know. I just keep thinking of all those feature films shot on 2K Alexas that look pretty dandy on CineAlta 4K projectors and say, yeah, that'd do it for me.

In terms of common release formats, there is no difference in spatial resolution between 2k DCI and HD video, just wider aspect ratio, A 2k DCI video projector is 2048 x 1080p 1.89:1 aspect ratio vs 1920x1080p 1.78:1 HD ratio. Some cameras, like the Reds and the Digital Bolex shoot a 2k 16:9 format, 2048x1152, but there is not enough difference in practical resolution to be worth scaling it to HD since scaling can introduce artifacts.

The Alexa is closer to 3k than 2k and is 1.5x HD resolution, so scales pretty cleanly.
 
Back
Top