Larry Rutledge
Fest Master
Quick Disclaimer: I am avoiding reading other comments before rating each of the films, so I may repeat comments others have said to death.
So far I have only watched about 10 of the films (including SIMILO and We Are Not Alone, which seem to have caused a lot of buzz), but of those this is currently my favorite. I think the overall blend of story, FX, score, acting and cinematography work to make this a great film.
The opening shot in the coffee shop looks really good, and in particular I like the overhead (crane?) shot at the end of the coffee shop sequence. If I had to make a critique about the film it would be the acting during this sequence, it wasn't bad, but felt a little stiff (I think this may be due more to the seriousness of the material contrasted with the laid back location - coffee shop). But it wasn't enough to pull me out of the story.
I really like the effect of the woman lifting the one guy up by the throat, looked very realistic. The other effects were also good, but a little more expected (sci-fi and all, you know
). I liked the guys eyes at the end, great effect.
I liked how the flashback was introduced, it was clear when we went into it and clear when it was over, but never jumped in your face and said "HERE'S A FLASHBACK!!!". It also did a great job of telling us the backstory without being a talking-head, here's what happened, sequence.
My biggest complaint, if you can call it that, was that when the film ended I wanted more, but that's a good thing. I felt that there was a complete story told here, but could see this being a piece from a much larger story.
One of my favorite components of this piece is the score. I think it was as much an actor in this film as the actors were. I was so impressed with it that I watched it once with the sound muted to see the difference and it definitely plays an important role in telling the story. There are many times where the action seems to be going one way, but the score brings it around so when you hit the next shot/scene you are right there with the story.
I also liked the transition wipes, felt very sci-fi to me (I guess I have Lucas to thank for that).
The exterior shot of the truck racing up to the warehouse and the subsequent tension with the gun in the lead's face was great.
Overall the acting was very good, I enjoyed everyone in the film - except that lead, who is that loser?
Just kidding . . . you did a great job Norm, especially considering the pressure of being the filmmaker as well.
Excellent Job!!
Larry
edited to add:

So far I have only watched about 10 of the films (including SIMILO and We Are Not Alone, which seem to have caused a lot of buzz), but of those this is currently my favorite. I think the overall blend of story, FX, score, acting and cinematography work to make this a great film.
The opening shot in the coffee shop looks really good, and in particular I like the overhead (crane?) shot at the end of the coffee shop sequence. If I had to make a critique about the film it would be the acting during this sequence, it wasn't bad, but felt a little stiff (I think this may be due more to the seriousness of the material contrasted with the laid back location - coffee shop). But it wasn't enough to pull me out of the story.
I really like the effect of the woman lifting the one guy up by the throat, looked very realistic. The other effects were also good, but a little more expected (sci-fi and all, you know
I liked how the flashback was introduced, it was clear when we went into it and clear when it was over, but never jumped in your face and said "HERE'S A FLASHBACK!!!". It also did a great job of telling us the backstory without being a talking-head, here's what happened, sequence.
My biggest complaint, if you can call it that, was that when the film ended I wanted more, but that's a good thing. I felt that there was a complete story told here, but could see this being a piece from a much larger story.
One of my favorite components of this piece is the score. I think it was as much an actor in this film as the actors were. I was so impressed with it that I watched it once with the sound muted to see the difference and it definitely plays an important role in telling the story. There are many times where the action seems to be going one way, but the score brings it around so when you hit the next shot/scene you are right there with the story.
I also liked the transition wipes, felt very sci-fi to me (I guess I have Lucas to thank for that).
The exterior shot of the truck racing up to the warehouse and the subsequent tension with the gun in the lead's face was great.
Overall the acting was very good, I enjoyed everyone in the film - except that lead, who is that loser?
Excellent Job!!
Larry
edited to add:
This post might go a long ways to helping everyone understand the inside joke. So I can be a little long winded, is that any reason to rake a guy over the coals?Envision said:Crap, I went long again. At least Larry R can appreciate long posts, can't you Larry!(inside joke)
Last edited: