OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
If DSLRs continue to be the only cheap way to shoot with a large sensor, the take-up of the external recorders might be tied in to how clean the HDMI-out will be on the up and coming stills cameras. Be interesting to see how this pans out: with responsibility of recording the video taken off the camera, maybe Nikon will make up ground more quickly? If Canon HDMI output is clean later this year, maybe they'll field a recorder module themselves if they go down that route, so as not to overburden the camera body for stills-only purists? Though by-passing a camera's compression scheme still leaves the problem of making the downscaled big sensor video output worth recording -- can DIGIC 5 do that? The new 7D and 5D Canon's won't be replaced for the next two years, so to avoid obsolescence does that mean 4k? There seems to be a lot in the mix here...Interesting times.
 
...Interesting times.

Agreed. Understatement of the year. :-)

I hope this happens ASAP. Canon may be one of the 1st to release a DSLR w. live 10-bit 4:2:2 1080p HDMI as a standard feature.

It would OK with me if _any_ manufacturer would sell a larger than 2/3" sensor, interchangeable-lens HD camera with live 10-bit 1080p HDMI/HD-SDI I/O for far, far less than $5K US. For that matter, I bet such tech can now be included in a cam selling for less than $3K US.

Atomos & BlackMagic Design have now proven that 10-bit 1080p HDMI/HD-SDI I/O -- plus a heap of additional features -- can be included in devices selling for only a few hundred $ US.

Current tech now allows both new relatively small companies as well as established manufactures to design such a camera.

Modularity is the trend. In-camera recording is dead, dead, dead (just as videotape is dead, dead, dead). Atomos, BMD, SoundDevices, AJA & others are leading the way. Question is, will cam manufacturers step up to the plate?

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Just a quick comment about all of this.

When you weight up the pros and cons of any of these devices, look at the cost of storage, and look at what you're getting in the package. And remember, uncompressed isn't always a blessing. You've got massively increased storage costs, and compared to a visually-lossless codec like ProRes, it's harder to edit with as well. Visually lossless means just that: it's as good as uncompressed, but cheaper to store and nicer to work with. The Ninja is low power, is 10-bit/4:2:2, has a monitor and a touchscreen, works with commodity storage (ie $50 for 2.5 hours of record time with ProRes HQ 220mbps), and is available now. And it has everything included (batteries, charger, docking station, carrying case etc...).

Just make sure you're comparing like-with-like.

We had an awesome NAB, by the way!

Dave Shapton
President
Atomos EMEA
 
Last edited:
Hi David S.: Thanks very much for your input.

What Atomos, BMD, AJA & SoundDevices are doing is industry-shaking. Different users will have different requirements from project to project, so there is plenty of room in the market for all of these new solutions. In fact, the new crop of portable HD recorders are so affordable many users will rent/own more than one!

See my related comments here:
http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/showthrea...eo-recorders&p=2312182&viewfull=1#post2312182

Now we just need the cam manufacturers to get with the program -- the affordable modular cam program. Stat!

And David: Please let me know when you have a Docking Station & Master Caddy 5-pack ready to ship. I'm ready to buy. ;-)

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Agreed. Understatement of the year. :-)

Modularity is the trend. In-camera recording is dead, dead, dead (just as videotape is dead, dead, dead). Atomos, BMD, SoundDevices, AJA & others are leading the way. Question is, will cam manufacturers step up to the plate?

Cheers.

I beg to differ, in-camera recording is ideal, at least for me, one less box on the camera. I have to say that I am tired of things hanging off my camera. My hope was that Scarlett would solve this with a compact high quality package, but not for a while yet it appears. A lot of my work is run and gun and requires me to work solo most of the time. For two years I travelled North America with a DVX100b that had a Zylight on a noga arm ,Sennheiser shotgun,Firestore,rails, mattebox, grips Tekkeon battery, Senheiser wireless receiver and sometimes a monitor. Moved to an HMC150 and just finished 2 years on the road in the Caribbean and USA with a similar setup less the Firestore but had to have an HD monitor so... These cameras are just not ergonomic with all that stuff and it gets more clumsy with a DSLR, I have a GH1 kit as well.
My needs and I think I am like many on here don't call for 4.2.2. uncompressed. In the meantime the Ninja, depending on the quality of its monitor, may be my next purchase along with an HPX 370 and a P2 setup.Back to the shoulder with my next camera. Unless Scarlett comes through in the next couple months.
 
Posted by Peter J. DeCrescenzo: Modularity is the trend. In-camera recording is dead, dead, dead (just as videotape is dead, dead, dead). Atomos, BMD, SoundDevices, AJA & others are leading the way. Question is, will cam manufacturers step up to the plate?
I beg to differ, in-camera recording is ideal, at least for me, one less box on the camera. I have to say that I am tired of things hanging off my camera. My hope was that Scarlett would solve this with a compact high quality package, but not for a while yet it appears. A lot of my work is run and gun and requires me to work solo most of the time. For two years I travelled North America with a DVX100b that had a Zylight on a noga arm ,Sennheiser shotgun,Firestore,rails, mattebox, grips Tekkeon battery, Senheiser wireless receiver and sometimes a monitor. Moved to an HMC150 and just finished 2 years on the road in the Caribbean and USA with a similar setup less the Firestore but had to have an HD monitor so... These cameras are just not ergonomic with all that stuff and it gets more clumsy with a DSLR, I have a GH1 kit as well.
My needs and I think I am like many on here don't call for 4.2.2. uncompressed. In the meantime the Ninja, depending on the quality of its monitor, may be my next purchase along with an HPX 370 and a P2 setup.Back to the shoulder with my next camera. Unless Scarlett comes through in the next couple months.

Hi Brian: Thank you very much for your detailed reply. I really appreciate it when shooters supply "reports from the front", as it were. Great stuff!

I should amend my "in-cam recording is dead, dead, dead" comment: In-cam recording is far from dead, and in the general scheme of things will probably never leave us. For the simple reason that it's obviously very useful.

What I meant to say is, that in _addition_ to in-cam recording, more & more shooters will use portable external video recorders attached to their cams to get additional capability. Primarily higher-quality video & sound, but other features, too (see Sound Devices PIX).

The availability of these devices is exploding, and I've perhaps gotten swept-up in the excitement. The trend-line has taken a turn towards straight up.

I totally agree with you about the ergonomic & practical challenges of working with modular gear. But solutions & sensible rigs are emerging. I also I totally agree with you about the joys of using a shoulder-mount camera. Heaven. But as we know, every cam configuration (DSLR, palmcorder, handycam, lipstick, shoulder-mount, cine-rig, etc.) has it's advantages & disadvantages, depending on budget & application.

I'm hopeful the Ninja & the other new external HD recorders live up to the hype. Meanwhile, it's helpful for all of us to discuss this stuff so we can so sort out the hype from the reality.

Thanks again for your input, and let us know how you get on with your Ninja once you've had a chance to work with it.
 
Last edited:
Modularity comes and goes though. Back in '97 you could buy a Sony camera head with a DVCAM or a BetaSP docking deck. Sony makes the SRW-1 docking recorder. Years and years ago you bought camera heads separate from the recorders and connected them via cables.

External recorders are hot property right now because they offer substantial benefits over most in-camera recordings. But I can't for the life of me figure out why I'd want to use an external recorder instead of AVC-I on P2, for example... half the data rate, 10-bit, and equal or better quality than what other external recorders would deliver at 2x to 3x the bitrate. So when everyone has an internal recorder that's AVC-I or better, the market for external recorders will likely go through the same cyclical process as it always has. When P2 got big enough, the FireStore FS-100 disappeared. When XDCAM-EX improved enough over HDV, and AVCHD made solid-state recording cheap enough and affordable enough for the masses, the use of firestores for HDV disappeared.

The pendulum swings back and forth. Right now the pendulum is swinging towards the external recorder. I'm really intrigued by something like the SD PIX 240, because the prospect of having a 10-bit master-quality video recorder, and a monitor, and a high-quality audio recorder, all in one little battery-powered box, is really very compelling. But the funny thing is -- isn't that the opposite of a "truly" modular design? Shouldn't I be looking for a video recorder module, and a monitor module, and an audio recorder module? Why would I want all those devices in one?

And here's the answer -- as much as "modularity" gets the press, people don't really want that, overall. They want one device to do everything. Hence the massive success of the iPhone. It's a camera, a web surfer, an email tool, a flashlight, a GPS, a skype device, a text messaging device, a voice communication tool, a video camera, a personal digital assistant, a music player, a video game platform, etc... ALL IN ONE. And it's enormously popular. How many people carry a separate flashlight, own a separate GPS, have a separate telephone, keep a video camera on them, and have a separate stills camera? Some, yes, but far and away the majority are now relying on their phone to do all those tasks. That's really what people want, I think. More convenience, less hassle. And I think AVC-I points the way - having a master quality recorder in-camera means I don't have to bother with separate modules. The AF100 points the way -- having high-quality audio recording and ND filters and good-enough video and a big-enough sensor and all, all in one body, means I don't have to bother with rigging and frankensteining a whole bunch of modules together. Probably why the iMac and iPad are Apple's best-selling computers -- no need for modules, it just works and does everything and comes all in one box...

There's certainly an argument that can be made for modularity, which is why that pendulum keeps swinging back and forth, but I know that I certainly prefer having an integrated solution in as few modules as necessary. And I think the mass consumer market has spoken pretty clearly about that too (not that the pro video and mass consumer markets are the same, of course!)

It seems like nothing in this industry ever truly "dies", it will continue to go in cycles. Zooms eliminated primes for decades, but now primes are back in vogue. Onboard recording eliminated external for years and years, but now external is back. One-piece or single-source kits eliminated modularity for a long time, but now modularity is in fashion. The cycles will unquestionably continue.
 
Well I for one hope that when recording to tape dies, that it never comes back :) By the way, how do I rewind an SDHC card? :P
 
Modularity comes and goes though. Back in '97 you could buy a Sony camera head with a DVCAM or a BetaSP docking deck. ... ... Onboard recording eliminated external for years and years, but now external is back. One-piece or single-source kits eliminated modularity for a long time, but now modularity is in fashion. The cycles will unquestionably continue.

Completely agree with everything you said.

I have fond memories of Sony's Portapac 3/4" UMATIC "portable"* cassette camera head & deck. Um, not. :-)

Now get off my lawn! :-)

* Back then, "portable" meant "not bolted to the studio floor".


Question for Barry:

I'm confused by your statement, "But I can't for the life of me figure out why I'd want to use an external recorder instead of AVC-I on P2, for example... half the data rate, 10-bit, and equal or better quality than what other external recorders would deliver at 2x to 3x the bitrate."

Are you saying AVI-I on P2 is higher quality than what the new ProRes external recorders can do when they operate at their higher data-rate settings? Just looking for clarification on this point. Thanks again.
 
Are you saying AVC-I on P2 is higher quality than what the new ProRes external recorders can do when they operate at their higher data-rate settings? Just looking for clarification on this point. Thanks again.
I'm saying that it's certainly better than what you'll get out of a Nano at 220 or 280mbps, because while they're both "master quality", the AVC-I is a full 10-bit system and therefore, when used with a 10-bit camera, it's going to outperform what the Nano does at 2x to 3x the bitrate. And I would be pretty confident in asserting that it will hold up as well as a ProRes recorder, even though it takes up half the bitrate.
 
I'm saying that it's certainly better than what you'll get out of a Nano at 220 or 280mbps, because while they're both "master quality", the AVC-I is a full 10-bit system and therefore, when used with a 10-bit camera, it's going to outperform what the Nano does at 2x to 3x the bitrate. And I would be pretty confident in asserting that it will hold up as well as a ProRes recorder, even though it takes up half the bitrate.

I remember reading a few articles that AVC I proved to be much more efficient than pro res. In fact talking to a lot of software and hardware engineers, apparently pro res, along with DNxHD are both horribly inefficient codecs. Meaning all that bandwidth because the codec can't figure out a lot of the detail so needs the extra headroom to get it right.

At one point, AVC I was proven to be a better codec than in the early days of R3D. a DIT friend of mine saw the results done at Deluxe comparing r3d grading and avc I. Nowadays it's different but it just goes to show Panasonic got it right, off the bat.

But to play on the reverse side Barry, the major draws of pro res recording directly is

1. cheap off the shelf media recording, price per GB compared to a SSD or spinning drive compared to P2 is vast.

2. pro res is a widely accepted codec has high quality. Mis-information and lack of cheap access to AVC I at the moment, makes it so that the general public doesn't know how good it is. Just like Cineform, a codec that rivals HDCAM SR. But until now, AVC I only existed in high end varicams. Indie film making community simple haven't seen much of it or used it first hand. That goes from starting producers, to some tech savvy clients, to the shooters themselves. And I'm not saying people are stupid, I'm saying people don't know, what they don't personally use. Pro res is a staple thing that people practically live and breathe these days in post.

3. and lastly, the fact that the cheapest pro res recorder at the moment is a thousand dollars. and price always matters. unless we start seeing avc i recorders in the 1500 dollar range, I don't think more external avc i recorders are gonna fly.
 
Barry talks a lot of sense as usual, but I don't think any in-camera system can compete with visually-lossless ProRes combined with incredibly low cost storage: $50 for 2.5 hours! (BTW - If you're recording that amount of time uncompressed onto solid state, you could pay several times the price of a Nina just for the storage!)

In-camera systems will grow in capability, as will external recorders.

Dave Shapton
Atomos
 
Thanks Barry for ticking a few more boxes in my "Get an HPX 370" list. Every time I look at the 370 with optional wireless, viewfinder where I always used to find it and dual P2 ...yep. And Peter I too remember the "dog and pony show" light weight portable news gathering gear. I date way back...RCA TK76. Can't say which was more fun... the acquisition or the joy of three minutes of edited footage with only a half dozen dropouts.
The Ninja's multi purpose monitor and recorder would be very handy as backup and obviously monitoring and reviewing material at production meetings or whereever..maybe even during the obligatory nightly beer.
Brian
 
Back
Top