OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
Do I need this or will this work in my workflow? Probably not. With the current costs of SSD drives, does it makes sense for me? No... I shoot a few weddings, some web videos, and MLS soccer. I don't need uncompressed out of my HMC150. But that doesn't keep me from appreciating this for what it is... if paired with an AF100, an FS100, an F3, or the new Ikegami m4/3 camera, it's $345 of visual awesomeness that in some workflows and budgets is a Godsend. It may not be for everyone, but for what it is it's pretty stinkin' sweet.
 
I've been trying to decide between nanoFlash, Ki Pro Mini, Samurai, etc., but wanted to wait until after NAB for any new announcements or price drops. WOW! This looks amazing! Now I just have to wait to find out the specs on size, weight, battery stats, etc. In one of the pics it looks fairly big, like too big to mount on the camera, but I don't know if it was to scale. I'm watchin' this one closely.
 
How would you go about getting the footage off the SSD? What kind of reader would you need? The unit only has USB 2.0 on it, so I don't see offloading footage via that. Maybe a SATA PCI card and a SSD with SATA port? But how would power the drive then?
 
Last edited:
Uncompressed is an unworkable workflow for me. a 1080p SSD 800gb drive is $2.5 k .. so that's one hour at 1080p30 ..
and, you wouldn't have time to copy on-set to another drive ( 5 hours on FW800) ... so you'd have to have at least 3 to cycle swap. And you
copy maybe copy one drive. Maybe Thunderbolt will make this more practical . but there's still the write time of the disk to consider.

And then, there's editing uncompressed video .. you're limited in the number of video tracks / angles you can stream simultaneously.

Sounds cool .. but I don't think this would work for me without a codec option.

jeff
 
Also, the gemini comes with the docking station... I haven't heard talk of a docking station with this thing which, again, adds yet another nominal cost...

Yeah, an eSATA docking station is like 35 bucks - big deal.

Is there an official price for the Gemini special SSDs now?

Frank
 
Come on David, a 600GB SSD for 950 Euros lasts about one hour (24p 1080 10bit) - more than you usually shoot at one day.
If you buy two and download one while shooting with the other one, you can go on for ever. and they are - contrary to film - reusable. So for 2000 bucks you get 2 hrs of "reusable stock"- how much did we get with P2 for the same money?

Frank
Yeah, but this uncompressed footage has to be stored/archived, and backed up somewhere. While you can reuse the camera media over and over, the uncompressed footage is going to take more storage than a lot of use are currently used to using. Of course this will not cost anywhere near what shooting film does, but does require similar considerations when planing a project. That being said, I am very excited about this. Way to go BM.
 
HDDs are cheaper than SR tape today. Never heard someone complaining, that he can´t archive his SR tapes because they are to expensive.
Same goes for film - as you said.


Some folks say compressed material is good enough for them, and it´s more important to store 5 hrs of material on a laptop or a cheap external USB drive - so the can buy the Ninja, which is still a steal. I´m working uncompressed SD and HD with BM products since they are on the market (I think 2002 or so) - I never looked back to compression. To each his own - buy what works best for you.

Frank
 
Is a really nice alternative to the Atomos Ninja, both SDI and HDMI in/out, uncompressed Quicktime, i love the design too!
So the new UltraStudio 3D for Thunderbolt connection.

I´m sold!

It's hard to see how it's an alternative to the Ninja, which works with commodity-priced hard-drives and has a built-in monitor. The vast majority of users don't need to record uncompressed when there are visually-lossless alternatives like ProRes. You need to look at the Total Cost of Ownership with these devices.

Dave Shapton
Atomos
 
Uncompressed is an unworkable workflow for me. a 1080p SSD 800gb drive is $2.5 k .. so that's one hour at 1080p30 ..
and, you wouldn't have time to copy on-set to another drive ( 5 hours on FW800) ... so you'd have to have at least 3 to cycle swap. And you
copy maybe copy one drive. Maybe Thunderbolt will make this more practical . but there's still the write time of the disk to consider.

And then, there's editing uncompressed video .. you're limited in the number of video tracks / angles you can stream simultaneously.

Sounds cool .. but I don't think this would work for me without a codec option.

jeff

Come on are they crazy uncompressed unrealistic product this way, should have the option for 1 GB HD or ProRes with SSD 2500$ für 800 GB *"?!
 
So .. with a 600 or 800 GB SSD drive, how long would it take you to copy it to an HDD on set? Further, how many uncompressed camera
angles does your NLE rig support?

HDDs are cheaper than SR tape today. Never heard someone complaining, that he can´t archive his SR tapes because they are to expensive.
Same goes for film - as you said.


Some folks say compressed material is good enough for them, and it´s more important to store 5 hrs of material on a laptop or a cheap external USB drive - so the can buy the Ninja, which is still a steal. I´m working uncompressed SD and HD with BM products since they are on the market (I think 2002 or so) - I never looked back to compression. To each his own - buy what works best for you.

Frank
 
Last edited:
Very interesting, indeed. My initial excitation has settled somehow when I realized how much storage I'd need. Would have to transcode to ProPres prior to editing anyway - considering this fact I'd rather get KiPro or maybe Ninja and encode on-the-fly.
I don't think there's gonna be codec option. Main reason why it's so inexpensive is that there's hardly any DSP inside and no codec fees.
Still - very cool little product. Not for me, but definitely will find its users. Or... maybe I'll get one, just in case? The price is so tempting :)
 
Come on are they crazy uncompressed unrealistic product this way, should have the option for 1 GB HD or ProRes with SSD 2500$ für 800 GB *"?!

I'm not sure I understand your question. I think the BlackMagic box might work for some that have limited shots per day and limited camera angles in post. But for
me and the types of long running shots that we do, this box would not work for us. I think it's cool .. and perhaps the storage cost and I/O will catch up to uncompressed
video .. but for now, I would not consider this box.

jeff
 
Very interesting, indeed. My initial excitation has settled somehow when I realized how much storage I'd need. Would have to transcode to ProPres prior to editing anyway

Why on earth would you waste time and transcode to a lossy slow codec like ProRes, if you have uncompressed?
It is so much smoother and snappier in the timeline and super easy on the processor. There is no reason, not to edit uncompressed.
A simple software raid with 2 or 4 dirt cheap 2 TB HDD drives will do the trick. I work like this for years, and it´s getting cheaper every day.

Some folks insist to work on laptops these days. But with eSata or Thunderbolt even this isn't a problem anymore.

Frank
 
You don't keep the uncompressed! You transcode it to proreshq from the ssd to your external drive on the fly...... u can if you want to, but you dony have to. That's the beauty of uncompressed...... it let's you make the footage into anything you want!
 
Agreed Timur. For those without a RAID or who do not wish to archive the uncompressed footage - it can always be transcoded later to a more efficient codec like Cineform. I plan to do this during the computers downtime. Hang you can even get a cheap laptop to do the transcoding even on set if you have two cards to swap between them. Uncompressed 10 bit 4:2:2 is close to as good as it gets in most people's indie budget - of course RAW is amazing but this would be outsanding for projects that need it. Now I just need to get a full 10 bit front end.
 
For the price of the this and a small ssd, it is worth it to have for the times when you need the best, greenscreen, effects plates etc. No one says you have to take every shot that way. It is an option to use at your own discretion. For me the low band internal codecs are fine for 95% of what I do or more, this appears to be what is needed to take up the slack on the rest.
 
For the price of the this and a small ssd, it is worth it to have for the times when you need the best, greenscreen, effects plates etc. No one says you have to take every shot that way. It is an option to use at your own discretion. For me the low band internal codecs are fine for 95% of what I do or more, this appears to be what is needed to take up the slack on the rest.

This is a really good point and I agree with you completely. It think this how everyone should look at it. At this price I will get one for exactly that reason.
 
Back
Top