OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
Apologies if this has already been asked, but this seems like a relevant thread:

Currently, pending further NAB announcements, what's the least expensive interchangeable lens camera available "soonish" which has a sensor larger than 2/3" and live _10_ bit HDMI (or HD-SDI) out?

And a follow-up: Has RED officially announced if Scarlet will have a 2/3" or S35 sensor, or will both be offered?

Just trying to figure out which big-sensor cam can make best use of the new 10-bit external recorders, for the least cost. Thanks.
 
Are they wrong to ask questions?

There has definitely been some complaining here, with people asking stupid questions and wishing this thing was something it was never designed to be. The cost for some could definitely be a lot more expensive, but you do NOT need to spend more than $1800 to have over an hour of recording with this thing, less if you can get away with 30min record time in-between dumps.

Nobody said it was for everyone, but for those that see the cost benefits where they are...it's awesome. It seems every-time there's a new thread about a new product, there's a ton of people who flood in who the product was NOT designed for, and they whine about what it doesn't have to fit their particular work flow or budget. It gets under my skin a little. :)
 
One thing i don't understand ..

BM site says HDMI input is version 1.3 ..
for 10 bit ¿?
Is not only the v. 1.4 of hdmi the ones that supports 10bit ??? (cause i think that hdmi 1.3 is for 8bit only)
Correct me if i'm wrong (i wish)
 
One thing i don't understand ..

BM site says HDMI input is version 1.3 ..
for 10 bit ¿?
Is not only the v. 1.4 of hdmi the ones that supports 10bit ??? (cause i think that hdmi 1.3 is for 8bit only)
Correct me if i'm wrong (i wish)

"HDMI 1.3 supports 10-bit, 12-bit and 16-bit (RGB or YCbCr) color depths, up from the 8-bit depths in previous versions of the HDMI specification."

From HDMI.com
 
Fantastic .. hope sony makes the ps-100 10bit ..
Any official word about ?

Anyway, if ps100's only outputs 4:2:2 8BIT will be great also to have this BM recorder ! cause i think will be no problem recording 8bit output to this BM pocket (correct me if i'm wrong)
 
I on the hand am thankful for all the good questions people have been asking. It helps the rest of us just peeking in on the conversation understand better what this device is for and what it isn't for. A little frustration with the peons would make this a friendlier place.
 
+1 ...can't believe how ridiculous these threads can get.

Prores is NOT what this device was designed to do, so please get off the complain train. Go buy something else...

I don't see any one complaining. What I see is people looking at options that are consistent with their workflow.

For many, or most I would venture, 10 bit uncompressed is a substantial overkill for intended delivery, and at the top end, substantially increases acquisition costs, and long term archival.

Remember, this is the substantial reverse of moving from a compressed acquisition codec to an editing and delivery codec, and prospective purchasers have a prerogative to assess workflows.
 
There has definitely been some complaining here, with people asking stupid questions and wishing this thing was something it was never designed to be. The cost for some could definitely be a lot more expensive, but you do NOT need to spend more than $1800 to have over an hour of recording with this thing, less if you can get away with 30min record time in-between dumps.

Nobody said it was for everyone, but for those that see the cost benefits where they are...it's awesome. It seems every-time there's a new thread about a new product, there's a ton of people who flood in who the product was NOT designed for, and they whine about what it doesn't have to fit their particular work flow or budget. It gets under my skin a little. :)

This device isn't even released yet.

Asking questions about workflow, and alternative codecs makes sense.

Let's eliminate "stupid" and "whine" from the conversation and keep the front end collaborative, please.
 
Understood, but as stated earlier in the thread most people wouldn't even be buying this to use the Uncompressed files to edit with. For those who want something other than Prores, this is actually the greatest choice because anybody who currently uses other methods has to change it to something else anyways.

The issue isn't the overkill, I think that's canceled out by the fast copy times and such. Just trans-code to Prores as you dump the SSD and use that as your master. Who gives a care about the uncompressed 10-bit? I don't. It can matter for some but what I see this as is just a better way to get a Prores file off my AF100 without spending a huge amount. It's all about getting that HD-SDI or HDMI signal off that camera and onto my computer in an editable codec. With me currently dumping the on-board from the camera itself to Prores, I'm spending the same amount of time I'll spend doing the same from 10-bit 422 Unc to Prores with this thing.

I guess I just don't see the difference. Who cares if it's 10-bit Uncompressed or not, you don't have to keep that file. End up with the same master as you would with the KiPro or something else and just dump the SSD, but you'll get it cheaper with this (in my opinion) and faster (again, my opinion based on transcoding to Prores from the Unc as opposed to the transfer speeds of CF cards).
 
I think it's specifically designed to record 10-bit only...there's no indicator it can do anything other than that.


Of course it will be able to record 8-bit as well, it will just pad the signal with two extra bits, as every other piece of 10-bit equipment does when fed an 8-bit signal.

Regarding, the fs-100, all reports indicate it is indeed 8-bit out via hdmi, not 10.
 
I am buying one unless somebody else comes up with just another such NAB shocker for even less and available NOW. Has anybody actually seen one in real life? How long will it take till they hit the shops?
For the rest I agree with Frank, its a no brainer so far.
 
I think it's specifically designed to record 10-bit only...there's no indicator it can do anything other than that.

Any other can confirm that ??
I thik making a recorder for only 10bit hdmi output cameras when actually there is no cameras that outputs 10bit hdmi makes no sense.

Can any confirm if that BM uncomrpessed 350$ recorder can record from sony ps-100 ? panny af100? panny GH2 (gh2 + this bm will be a woow) ? and f3 ?
 
Understood, but as stated earlier in the thread most people wouldn't even be buying this to use the Uncompressed files to edit with. For those who want something other than Prores, this is actually the greatest choice because anybody who currently uses other methods has to change it to something else anyways.

The issue isn't the overkill, I think that's canceled out by the fast copy times and such. Just trans-code to Prores as you dump the SSD and use that as your master. Who gives a care about the uncompressed 10-bit? I don't. It can matter for some but what I see this as is just a better way to get a Prores file off my AF100 without spending a huge amount. It's all about getting that HD-SDI or HDMI signal off that camera and onto my computer in an editable codec. With me currently dumping the on-board from the camera itself to Prores, I'm spending the same amount of time I'll spend doing the same from 10-bit 422 Unc to Prores with this thing.

I guess I just don't see the difference. Who cares if it's 10-bit Uncompressed or not, you don't have to keep that file. End up with the same master as you would with the KiPro or something else and just dump the SSD, but you'll get it cheaper with this (in my opinion) and faster (again, my opinion based on transcoding to Prores from the Unc as opposed to the transfer speeds of CF cards).

Good post, but let's keep the discourse civil.
 
It might be taking an 8-bit signal and recording it as 10-bit, but there's nothing on their site that says it will record anything but 10-bit to the SSD itself. I won't record your output to 8-bit 422 Uncompressed onto the SSD, not according to their site and specs listed. Hopefully I'm wrong though, that would save some space. :)
 
It might be taking an 8-bit signal and recording it as 10-bit, but there's nothing on their site that says it will record anything but 10-bit to the SSD itself. I won't record your output to 8-bit 422 Uncompressed onto the SSD, not according to their site and specs listed. Hopefully I'm wrong though, that would save some space. :)

This is why i ask, i hope it can record good from 8 bit as Fohdeesha said
 
Back
Top