GH1 firmware research volunteers required

4:2:2 for AVCHD too?

4:2:2 for AVCHD too?

Hi tester13,

great work, on the 4:2:2

Do you think it will be possible, to implement the 4:2:2 also for AVCHD sometimes?
 
Tester, what frame rate should we use to give you results for MJPEG? I currently have some settings loaded, but need to know what frame-rate you want us to use, or does it matter?

Thanks
IB

Also testing 5 FPS mjpeg with no other settings changed for mjpeg (so standard mjpeg except for FPSX set to 5) the camera appeared to be recording 5fps, but then after I stopped recording, camera froze, and then when I tried to bring the footage off the SDHC card onto my computer, the card shows a file, but the file has 0 bytes, I guess the camera didn't actually send anything to the SD card, even though it appeared to be recording.

I will update my firmware to test MJPEG with higher bit-rate and 30p and report on the jpeg-snoop app. (hopefully)
 
Last edited:
How to guide for developers?

How to guide for developers?

Tester13 thanks for your dedication to this project. I was wondering if a how to guide is in the works to aid programmers get up to speed on this. I have access to Visual Studio and a G1 at this time. Let me know if I can contribute, thanks
 
I haven't patched the GH1 yet, so here are some results on stock version. GH1 doesn't report anything while in TV Output mode, so info is limited by what TV is showing, which in this case we will call Pana Brevia as only line resolution is reported, not refresh rates.
Regular HDMI playback mode.
1) Pictures, all aspects - 720p.
2) AVCHD FHD - 1080i.
3) AVCHD SHD - 720p

Viera-link on -- everything shows as 720p.

I can run patched tests on a Sony TV later, which does show both resolution and refresh rates.
Patched using 1) version increment, 2) native playback 3) simplified AVHCD bitrate patches. When pressing record button (shutter priority mode at 1/50th) cam switches to record mode, but red Rec icon is not showing up, also unable to stop or cancel recording. On off button doesn't work either, have to pull the battery.

When using non-simplified patches (settings as detailed here http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/showpost.php?p=2016738&postcount=373) footage gets recorded at avg bitrate around 24 Mbit. Confirmed native 24p in StreamEye. When played back on GH1 it actually goes out to TV as 1080i, same as original 24p-in-60i-wrapper.

Hope this helps. Let me know if any additional tests are necessary. Thanks!
 
Last edited:
Tester13 thanks for your dedication to this project. I was wondering if a how to guide is in the works to aid programmers get up to speed on this. I have access to Visual Studio and a G1 at this time. Let me know if I can contribute, thanks

First page, second post.
Plus search this thread by name for my posts concerning development.
 
PTool 3.36 updated without version change.

Added 420->422 Sampling patches for both GH1 and GF1.

Remember that we still do not have 1920 MJPEG mode testing results for GF1, and it looks (from sensor setup) that resolution can be more than GH1.
 
Last edited:
Btw, the notations for the MJPEG width & height patches seemed to have been overwritten with a duplication of the color sampling patch's notation.

tester13: Fixed already, thanks.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
gf1 1920 x 1080

gf1 1920 x 1080

PTool 3.36 updated without version change.

Added 420->422 Sampling patches for both GH1 and GF1.

Remember that we still do not have 1920 MJPEG mode testing results for GF1, and it looks (from sensor setup) that resolution can be more than GH1.

patched my GF1 with mjpeg patch:
h: 1920
w:1080
422...

(screenshot deleted by tester13)

unfortunately it didn´t record the file my class 6 cards are to slow :-(
but it gave a an image:

P1030629.JPG



the analisis with the jpeg tool is here:

https://sites.google.com/site/pruebabbbb/temp/P1030629.txt?revision=1

Today I donßt have much time but at night can do more testing with other settings, perhaps without 422? or smaller size. didn´t touch the compression for mjpeg tho any suggestions are welcome.
 
Last edited:
I don't see any image.
I suggest you to up your quality settings significantly, overwise going from 1280 with 420 to 1920 with 422 will hit image quality, your quantization tables show it.
And look at Pappas settings at his thread.
I tested his 1440x1080 with 422 sampling and reduced quality settings.
But high detailed footage is still untested.
 
Last edited:
very good job TESTER13 !! congratulation !

I'm French and i have a little blog, talking a lot about DSLR, Canon EOS, Panasonic but also about RED and other Next Gen D-Cinema Tools.

www.pampuri.net


I did a post today, talking about your work.
Do you think it will be possible to manage the different options in the future directly on the GH1 interface menu ?

Thanks a lot for what you did !
 
GF1 tests report

camera with sandisk extreme class10 16g sd card

mjpeg quality settings 384 320 256 200
mjpeg table 24 24 24 24

1280->1920

4:2:0->4:2:2

camera stopped recording after 1-2 seconds, a 500ms mjpeg has been recorded,and bitrate is about 96Mbps.

tried servel times and got same results.
 
GF1 tests report
camera with sandisk extreme class10 16g sd card
mjpeg quality settings 384 320 256 200
mjpeg table 24 24 24 24
1280->1920
4:2:0->4:2:2
camera stopped recording after 1-2 seconds, a 500ms mjpeg has been recorded,and bitrate is about 96Mbps.
tried servel times and got same results.

You can't use same quality settings for 422.
Bitrate will be much higher.
Size1=X+X/4+X/4=3/2 X
Size2=X+X/2+X/2= 2 X
It is not precise, but you get the idea.
30% bitrate increase at least.
On high detailed scenes it can be even worse.
Normally you don't need 422, use it only for green screen work.
 
GF1 try again

same mjpeg quality settings

no 1920 patch, just 1280 and 4:2:2

works well, no problem. the bitrate is about 64Mbps.
 
Back
Top