GH1 firmware research volunteers required

No news on HDMI out and any video output.
And I do not expect them to appear soon.
This is crucial parts, and we know only few things about video things.
And clearly know nothing about low level things.

Plus turning AGC off requires interface, this is also very big work.
Unfortunately audio related strings that we have in GF1 firmware are not referenced from code, so they are useless.
We'll try to find sensor related parts and audio related parts, but it is not easy.

What about just allowing people to turn the AGC off permenantly (via the firmware) and maybe set a recording level? That way we could plug in mixers or something and get things sort of figured out with some trial and error.
 
BTW, gop 3 on 1080p24 failed, it does not have any effect the gop is still 15.

100% grass crop:
There is a really obvious reason this failed, and that is because the 1080p24 setting is for NTSC cameras, and not for PAL cameras. You should change the GOP size of the 1080p25 setting, that will have effect. A GOP of 3 is however way too low for 1080p on my camera to write with decent speed.
Also, since you got such high bitrates, which settings did you change? JUST the GOP size, or did you change any of the other parameters?

And as said, this should help with dynamic mud. However, I'm wondering, shouldn't the increased bitrate help with the static mud too?

Looks amazing Chibs, close to flawless! (minus the stutter). This is only a matter of card speed and/or maybe figuring out the encoding settings more. Tester is going to nail this thing!

BTW how are you adjusting the exposure on the clip? Manual aperature adjustment on the lens?

Yes, the lens used is a Xenon 50/2, with an aperture that doesn't 'click' at known values. Makes it really easy to adjust exposure smoothly.
 
There is a really obvious reason this failed, and that is because the 1080p24 setting is for NTSC cameras, and not for PAL cameras. You should change the GOP size of the 1080p25 setting, that will have effect. A GOP of 3 is however way too low for 1080p on my camera to write with decent speed.
Also, since you got such high bitrates, which settings did you change? JUST the GOP size, or did you change any of the other parameters?

And as said, this should help with dynamic mud. However, I'm wondering, shouldn't the increased bitrate help with the static mud too?

I have NTSC model , anyway I'm testing more 720p mode, at 24p there is lot of room for bitrate increment.


there's a lot parameters to change and test, may be tester13 is willing to release the work done in firmware source, or if its illegal, I think the IDA data can be shared and contributed by many people. Lots of people searching the code would be much better.
 
Last edited:
It seems that more and more people are willing to involve in testing.
Do you think it will be good to form wiki pages or something similar for more systematic approach.
Information for testers and testing results, what has been done, files etc.
Probably people are willing to help, but lacks knowledge. There can be parameters which works/do not works, so no one will have to repeat same tests.
 
I have NTSC model , anyway I'm testing more 720p mode, at 24p there is lot of room for bitrate increment.
Okay, seems I misunderstood.
Something could be set wrong somewhere with the GOP 1080/24, as GOP 3 on 1080/25 has a huge effect for me.
 
I'm too testing new NTSC setting mode:

All videos in AVCHD mode is NTSC standartd :) but camera can't write more 5 sec.

VA 59,94fps > 23,97fps mode: change fps to - 47.952 fps :-) it's on 720p mode.

Guys don't forget GH1 have AVCHD Format profile ( High@L4.0 ) it have a max 20Mbps bit rate..

Regards
NURBS
 
Last edited:
PTool 3.11 released
720p50->23,97 patch added
1080p24 GOP patch fixed

Guys - if you use NTSC patch always use 30min removal patch also.
 
It seems that more and more people are willing to involve in testing.
Do you think it will be good to form wiki pages or something similar for more systematic approach.
Information for testers and testing results, what has been done, files etc.
Probably people are willing to help, but lacks knowledge. There can be parameters which works/do not works, so no one will have to repeat same tests.

I looked at Wiki engines, so from techincal point I see no hurdles.
But from legal one we have many.
Plus we don't have any expirienced reversers in sign.
So, until I'll see real need for this I don't want to talk about it.
 
Today we have very unsystematic testing.
And such approach wastes my time, testers time, etc.

So, please try to report as follows:

1) Applied patches, and all values if applicable.
2) You exact actions.
3) Detailed and clear to understand technical result.
 
might I suggest devising a template report template that testers could use to report data in a useful manner, that way only the data that is necessary for tester13 is preserved and what he doesn't need, need not be reported.
 
might I suggest devising a template report template that testers could use to report data in a useful manner, that way only the data that is necessary for tester13 is preserved and what he doesn't need, need not be reported.

IF anyone want to make such template, you are welcome.
Text file will be fine.
XLS also ok.
 
NTSC to PAL switch

NTSC to PAL switch

Test NTSC to PAL

1) Applied just PAL patch.
2) tested 1080 and 720p.
3)1080 sims to work fine, the file is 25fps. 720p is 50 fps but camera stop recording after few seconds. it say SD memory to slow.
but the memory is just class2.

note
after switch between NTSC/PAL must be format card for use it.
 
Test NTSC to PAL

1) Applied just PAL patch.
2) tested 1080 and 720p.
3)1080 sims to work fine, the file is 25fps. 720p is 50 fps but camera stop recording after few seconds. it say SD memory to slow.
but the memory is just class2.

note
after switch between NTSC/PAL must be format card for use it.

I tiried to adress this issues in new patch. See below.
 
Last edited:
Even though this might be the most ingenious and elaborate Russian hoax to get a free GH1 and class 10 SDHCs, I love this thread! It is the only thread I check lately.

<sarcasm mode>please change this to european hoax, i'm not from russia but i'm a little bit involved. wait wait wait! i even donated to that hoax :eek:
</sarcasm mode>
hmmm, i bet some money in advance in the hope to see an custom FW with some minor tweaks & after very short time i'm able to get that 30min limit disabled. that feature alone makes an difference of 75€ additional customs tax saved for every customer in the EU.
@Simon Höfer or any other user with the EU PAL version & an post count of >1000: could any of you please try the patch just to disable the 30min restriction & confirm it here? that would stop any other clowns following.

So am I sending Chibs money for a card? I don't know what's going on right now. Camera ordered and still gotta order a mount

+1 vote to send Chibs the money for a card & add such an card to the package for tester13 BUT we must decide first which card(s) to test/use


I am still interested why on Panasonic products related forum you can't write it's producer name - Matsushi*a :-)
Censorship at it's worse. :-)

as ingenious as you're as an hacker, your missed some business lessons ;)
there is of course no interest to promote the producer, all they care about is the brand. why dilute the effort to push both brand & producer when only the first matters. they've even gone so far as to rename european subsidiaries from Matsushi*a electric works to panasonic electric works, guess it was easier to get employees that way :D

FWIW, In my day job, I'm shooting on Class 10 Patriot SDHC cards with a pair of NTSC GH1s. I'll have time to try the latest MJPEG firmware mods out on one of them as early as tonight. Results will follow.

did you had the opportunity to test?

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=MMC6FFRI Here's the clip for GOP analysis.

that's interesting. you get some very wild GOPs. 18 I frames, 7 P frames, 15 I frames, 10 P frames and so on...
@DrBlaz: what tool do you use? elecard streameye? or some other tool? please check his clip also, i guess streameye is misinterpreting frames

one short test i did with only the following settings: 30min / 720p50 GOP 1 / 1080p25 GOP 25 (no bitrate adjustment or any other setting)
results:
- with 720p regardless of quality selected (tried all: L/H/SH) the recording does not even start, only empty files (0kb) are created & the message about card speed apears. after the third try to start the recording, the GH1 freezes (had to remove the battery) => i doubt its the card speed cause in that case it would at least get some data in buffer & write at least the first frames?!?
- with 1080p the resulting clip has lower than average frames (compared to default settings), both I/P frames are smaller in comparision to the default GOP. increasing GOP alone does not result in better quality (as could have been expected...) see attachment for stats
downside: DrBlaz has an transcend class 6 HD, mine is without the HD suffix, seems like transcend cards are not up to the task...

@tester13: the results so far are hard to interpret. how would you try to find out the maximum throughput to card? at the moment i would sugest reducing the GOP as far as possible + increasing bitrate. we need to identify which cards to test (you & Chibs) in the future when tweaking with other settings.

does anybody have other class 6 brands (not transcend) or even class 10 cards & willing to do some card performance tests?

some interesting review regarding the panasonic class 10 cards: http://www.amazon.com/review/RQNCQEGNPETMG/ref=cm_cr_dp_cmt?ie=UTF8&ASIN=B002I7IJME&nodeID=172282 with the panasonic AG-HMC150 it looks like it needs an FW upgrade to work with class 10 cards (https://eww.pavc.panasonic.co.jp/pro-av/support/cs/csregistp2m/ep2main/soft/hmc150/hmc150.htm), so its not always said get the equipment + accessories from panasonic & you have no trouble. incompatibilities (card controller + internal controller in GH1) are bound to throw us back & we need to find some compatible cards for the GH1...
 

Attachments

PTool 3.11 updated (without version change), redownload if you have it already.

Only NTSC/PAL patches changed.
We moved to one level higher, from video only related to system functions.
Thus formally "Crucial" status added to patches.
I don't see much risk here as only simplest code modifications are done, but formally it must be done.
 
@Simon Höfer or any other user with the EU PAL version & an post count of >1000: could any of you please try the patch just to disable the 30min restriction & confirm it here? that would stop any other clowns following.

I'm sorry, I've got the Hong Kong PAL version. No time limit.
 
- with 720p regardless of quality selected (tried all: L/H/SH) the recording does not even start, only empty files (0kb) are created & the message about card speed apears. after the third try to start the recording, the GH1 freezes (had to remove the battery) => i doubt its the card speed cause in that case it would at least get some data in buffer & write at least the first frames?!?
- with 1080p the resulting clip has lower than average frames (compared to default settings), both I/P frames are smaller in comparision to the default GOP. increasing GOP alone does not result in better quality (as could have been expected...) see attachment for stats

Here is my opinion:

1) We have multiple buffer overruns if reducing GOP. And checking procedures just show default message as normally this occures only because of SD.
2) Large GOP is good, but we have some VBR related quality estimator and with increasing GOP it decreases bitrate (I,P frame sizes). Quality estimator is just function. Making CBR could be better, I think.
 
Hello ;-)

720p50->23,97 test result:

Frame rate : 25.000 fps
Original frame rate : 47.952 fps

25p for PAL user it's more important :-)

Regards
NURBS
 
Hello ;-)
720p50->23,97 test result:

Frame rate : 25.000 fps
Original frame rate : 47.952 fps

25p for PAL user it's more important :-)

Again.
Such reports are not enough. Not useful.
I need to know actual FPS, if it is native or wrapped, all this small details.

Try to test new NTSC patch.
 
I test only 720p50->23,97:

720p50 mode (PAL system)
Mediainfo said that:

Video
ID : 4113 (0x1011)
Menu ID : 1 (0x1)
Format : AVC
Format/Info : Advanced Video Codec
Format profile : High@L4.0
Format settings, CABAC : No
Format settings, ReFrames : 1 frame
Duration : 2mn 0s
Bit rate mode : Variable
Bit rate : 11.3 Mbps
Maximum bit rate : 16.6 Mbps
Width : 1 280 pixels
Height : 720 pixels
Display aspect ratio : 16:9
Frame rate : 25.000 fps
Original frame rate : 47.952 fps
Standard : NTSC
Resolution : 8 bits
Colorimetry : 4:2:0
Scan type : Progressive
Bits/(Pixel*Frame) : 0.489
Stream size : 161 MiB (94%)

For more info I must have more software. If you know what software will give me more info please say that.

Now testing NTSC patch. ;-)
 
Back
Top