GH1 firmware research volunteers required

I am still digging in compression things, so I need more tests.

1) VA Bitrate Adjustment - do not touch anything else and lower it initially to 12000000, then to 9000000, and then to 6000000. Shoot short clips in 1080p.
2) VA Bitrate Adjustment 2 - do not touch anything else (including 1) ) and lower it initially to 14000000, then to 9000000, and then to 6000000. Shoot short clips in each mode, including MJPEG 1280p30.

Note. You must shoot something with many details, like grass.
 
Not sure if this was covered in the last 94 pages but might it be possible to increase the frame rate to over 60fps, maybe even up to 120fps?
 
Not sure if this was covered in the last 94 pages but might it be possible to increase the frame rate to over 60fps, maybe even up to 120fps?

May be it is possible by lowering resolution and FOV. But required major firmware rewrite. As many privately developed software products it is not universal, so it have tight connection to available resolutions, fps rates, etc.
So, it is better to just buy compact or specialized camera if you need this.
 
Just thought of this last night;

Would it be possible to tap into the 1920x1080 jpeg "engine" or whatever is allready used for 16:9 small jpegs and send the 24fps image stream to be recorded in a series of jpegs?

Im not talking about using the downscaler (sensor probably cant come close to handling that at 24fps), but just sending the frames over to what already looks like some sort of built in hardware compressor with it being 1920x1080 and all.

With a very fast SD card, you should be able to handle 24frames persecond of 1920x1080 jpegs (at least for a period of time) and the quality would be amazing.
 
MJPEG is actually that, a series of independent jpegs stored in a movie file wrapper. So the best MJPEG bitrate is the best you can get for real-time JPEG video compression.
 
With a very fast SD card, you should be able to handle 24frames per second of 1920x1080 jpegs (at least for a period of time) and the quality would be amazing.

I do not believe that JPEG compressor can do 24 FullHD frames, and 50MBits/s require also much larger buffers . SD controller write speed limit can be about 30-40Mbits/s, we don't know yet.
Firmware is not build like setting resolution and next universal engine obtain RAW frame, process it, move to designated compressor, etc.
It is highly specialized, uses codes for each resolution and fps settings, and this things are used in many many places, so most things are hardcoded to predefinded resolutions.
Sensor setup also seems to be not universal.
 
FullHD 24/25p at 40mbps would be incredible! If you can make it work I'm sure dvxuser.com will build you a statue :)
 
FullHD 24/25p at 40mbps would be incredible! If you can make it work I'm sure dvxuser.com will build you a statue :)

Don't be sure about it. :-)
We can be just few months ahead of GH2 with normal codec implementation.
As that we have in GH1 is problems of implementation, as AVCHD with I and P frames and no CABAC can be worse than MPEG2.
We need normal encoder chip from TM700 and I believe it is main difference in new 4/3" Panasonic camcorder.
And yes, with current encoder we need about 40-50Mbit, as Canon one is similar and show such bitrates.
Problem is that hardware can be not capable of it, or memory mapping can be restriction (buffer sizes can be limited).
 
Don't be sure about it. :-)
We can be just few months ahead of GH2 with normal codec implementation.
As that we have in GH1 is problems of implementation, as AVCHD with I and P frames and no CABAC can be worse than MPEG2.
We need normal encoder chip from TM700 and I believe it is main difference in new 4/3" Panasonic camcorder.
And yes, with current encoder we need about 40-50Mbit, as Canon one is similar and show such bitrates.
Problem is that hardware can be not capable of it, or memory mapping can be restriction (buffer sizes can be limited).

5D records 40-50mbit in H.264 right? GH1 cpu time taken up with wrapping 24p stream in 60i… how did you hack it to record native 24p to the card? I am asking because if this freed up the CPU to certain extent, it may have time to record at higher bit rate. Is it possible to have access to an error log in case of crashes, or monitor CPU occupancy?

Do you know the buffer sizes required for 40-50mbit 1080p stream @24p? Larger cache memory may be reason 5D costs much more
 
Moving to low level stream analizers I see that something is wrong with Panasonic guys.
Really wrong, and they must fix it quick.
It is definitely that encoder settings are wrong (also VBR quality estimators for P frames are wrongly setup).
Bitrate selected is too low.
Wrappers must be removed and player adjusted to play native files (today it can't do it).
I don't talk here about idiotic ZS3/7 (compacts) frame duping in 720p60.

Plus low GOP results (plus bitrate patches) in weird bitrate allocation, see below:
1272908357.jpg


Big surges in some P frames :-)

Please provide me links for GH1 original (with wrapper) files and similar 7D/550D files.
It is interesting to compare at low level.
 
Last edited:
Tester- so you are saying panasonic made a mistake in the settings in their firmware for avc encoding? i.e. That its possible to "fix" it and still shoot 17mbps with out too much mud?
 
I believe that at least 24-28Mbit is possible for this hardware.
So, quality estimators must be changed in next firmware, bitrate settings must be changed also.
Low level adjustment can be made.
Compression artifacts won't be gone completely (as you can see it on normal 24Mbit comcorders streams).
But will be less.
Error can even be in adapting 720p encoder (as chip used was originally indended for ZS3, as I think) to 1080p.
Problem can be as low as motion vector estimation or some related math (as lower fps are much more affected).
They clearly need few men and good systematic tests to adjust it.
Hope someone related to GH1 project read this. :-)
 
Moving to low level stream analizers I see that something is wrong with Panasonic guys.
Really wrong, and they must fix it quick.
It is definitely that encoder settings are wrong (also VBR quality estimators for P frames are wrongly setup).
Bitrate selected is too low.
Wrappers must be removed and player adjusted to play native files (today it can't do it).
I don't talk here about idiotic ZS3/7 (compacts) frame duping in 720p60.

Plus low GOP results (plus bitrate patches) in weird bitrate allocation, see below:
1272908357.jpg


Big surges in some P frames :-)

Please provide me links for GH1 original (with wrapper) files and similar 7D/550D files.
It is interesting to compare at low level.

Found some original MTS files at DPReview. I hope they are useful to you.

http://www.dpreview.com/news/0905/09051503panasonicgh1preview.asp

Good luck.
 
Thanks.

Look at this picture:
1272911954.jpg


As you can see spike in P frame is actually just wasted space.
Useful info (motion vectors+transformation) is still the same.
So, we hit here wall of quality estimators.
 
Just looked frame by frame on DPReview examples (in 720p) and they are not too bad.
So, best way is to try in 1080p for now longer GOP, may be even about 60.
We could see how P frames size is adjusting to available bitrate.
Plus try to up bitrate a little (up to 20-21 must be safe).
At least for now I believe that we have some quality estimaton wall.
First thing Panasonic must do is to up bitrate to about 28-30Mbps and make it almost constant by adjusting VBR estimators and making bitrate setting to be limit, not estimator values.

But without actual testers it is waste of time.
 
Hey there tester13,

I wonder, since they are extremely similar camera's would it be very difficult to modify the GF1 as well? Specifically, manual control over aperture and shutter speed while video recording. If these modifications were made, the GF1 would basically be a cheaper, smaller, GH1. That would be pretty awesome!
 
Tester13 & Car3o,

Have you received your GH1 and adapter yet, if not, when is it scheduled to get to you. I imagine this will speed up your testing/progress quite a bit..
 
The camera, according to Fed-Ex, is skedded to arrive tomorrow. As it's previous delivery I was at work and missed it. The adapter is being sent USPS so I can' t track it. However it was sent 4/30, should be here soon. I'll keep you guys updated. Once the adapter comes I'll mail it all out together.
 
First thing Panasonic must do is to up bitrate to about 28-30Mbps and make it almost constant by adjusting VBR estimators and making bitrate setting to be limit, not estimator values.

I don't believe this will be possible. The AVCHD spec maxes out at "up to 24Mbps VBR". I believe there are only two rated speeds for 1080, "up to 17Mbps" and "up to 24Mbps". Panasonic would have to choose one of those to remain within spec.

-kap
 
The camera, according to Fed-Ex, is skedded to arrive tomorrow. As it's previous delivery I was at work and missed it. The adapter is being sent USPS so I can' t track it. However it was sent 4/30, should be here soon. I'll keep you guys updated. Once the adapter comes I'll mail it all out together.
Please order a fast SD card. Does not have to be big, 4GB should suffice.
 
Back
Top