GH1 firmware research volunteers required

Hi Vitaly
How likely is the breakthrough of video out whilst recording ? You said that it is complicated, but since then some time has passed and youve made some significant progress...

I am not magician.
This thing requires amazing amount of work and we are not here yet to start experiments.
So, do not count on this feature.
It'll be good if we could archieve this, but it can be that we'll fail.
 
PTool 3.40d updated

Added "PAL<->NTSC Menu" patch for GF1 and GH1.
In short - it allows you to change video standard on the fly.
"Video Out" menu is used. It'll simultaneously set you TV output standard and also camera shooting standard.
As a side effect, this patch enables Video Out menu for regions where it was disabled.

Both other PAL and NTSC patches removed.
 
PTool 3.40d updated

Added "PAL<->NTSC Menu" patch for GF1 and GH1.
In short - it allows you to change video standard on the fly.
"Video Out" menu is used. It'll simultaneously set you TV output standard and also camera shooting standard.
As a side effect, this patch enables Video Out menu for regions where it was disabled.

Both other PAL and NTSC patches removed.

It appears that the proper sequence for switching the GF1 from NTSC to PAL with a single SD card and the new firmware patch is as follows:

1. Record footage in NTSC
2. Transfer footage to computer
3. Switch to PAL mode
4. Format card
5. Turn camera off and on
6. Format card again
7. Record PAL footage

It appears that if you don’t format, turn the camera off and on again, and then format one more time you will get a message stating “No other selections can be made”.
 
I am not magician.
This thing requires amazing amount of work and we are not here yet to start experiments.
So, do not count on this feature.
It'll be good if we could archieve this, but it can be that we'll fail.

We have faith in you. However, I am pretty darn satisfied with what you have given us so far. I bought the camera when it just had low bit rate 4:2:0 720p MJPEG and AVC-HD, it didn’t have any manual controls for video, I couldn’t use my third party batteries, it wouldn’t allow me to switch languages, and I couldn’t switch to PAL.

You have already given us all of those things. I doubt Panasonic will do the same for me in the GH2.
 
It appears that the proper sequence for switching the GF1 from NTSC to PAL with a single SD card and the new firmware patch is as follows:

1. Record footage in NTSC
2. Transfer footage to computer
3. Switch to PAL mode
4. Format card
5. Turn camera off and on
6. Format card again
7. Record PAL footage

I see much better ways.
1. Use two cards, one for PAL and other for NTSC footage.
2. During transfer simply delete (or move with files) PRIVATE folder. You won't be required to do any reformat in this case.
 
I see much better ways.
1. Use two cards, one for PAL and other for NTSC footage.
2. During transfer simply delete (or move with files) PRIVATE folder. You won't be required to do any reformat in this case.

You are correct. That is a better way. However, some people only have one SD card and I was trying to head off all of the inevitable posts like "You broke my camera it keeps saying "No other selections can be made".

It took me awhile to get it to switch from one format to the other. And until I did it correctly it prevented me from recording anything. I just wanted to make sure others didn't run into the same issue.
 
Hello Vitaly. Ever thought about the maximum exposure lock of 1/160 if a flash is attached again? Dunno if you're looking into things like this, couse it's still photography. But I remember that you've mentioned it before.
 
PTool 3.40d updated

Added "PAL<->NTSC Menu" patch for GF1 and GH1.
In short - it allows you to change video standard on the fly.
"Video Out" menu is used. It'll simultaneously set you TV output standard and also camera shooting standard.
As a side effect, this patch enables Video Out menu for regions where it was disabled.

Both other PAL and NTSC patches removed.

I tried the 1080p AVC-HD setting on the GF1 and it appears to record in NTSC perfectly for shutter speeds between 30-60. For PAL it records for shutter speeds faster than about 1/300 sec.

It was weird because the band of light area across the top seemed to be dependent on shutter speed. As I made the shutter go faster it would make the band bigger or smaller depending on if I was in PAL or NTSC mode.

Here is a PAL sample of the 1080p video from the GF1. It is not as good as the 720p MJPEG though. Hopefully, you guys can figure this one out.
http://vimeo.com/13597744
 
Small update.

AGC
I can use Volume value now (available from menu). It is quite good option having 7 steps from 0 to 6. So, no more basic interface problems.
Main problem is that we still did not know AGC routines and how they work.
WindCut settings looks like our most probable chance.
Unfortunately we have another layers between our position and actual low level stuff.
Overall GH1 internally looks like cabbage :-)

As for HDMI and TV out thing.
We know how all related parameters as set from menus, how they are adjusted according to each other (like HDMI mode if you select other standard) and many other things.
 
I tried the 1080p AVC-HD setting on the GF1 and it appears to record in NTSC perfectly for shutter speeds between 30-60. For PAL it records for shutter speeds faster than about 1/300 sec.

It was weird because the band of light area across the top seemed to be dependent on shutter speed. As I made the shutter go faster it would make the band bigger or smaller depending on if I was in PAL or NTSC mode.

Here is a PAL sample of the 1080p video from the GF1. It is not as good as the 720p MJPEG though. Hopefully, you guys can figure this one out.
http://vimeo.com/13597744

I just had to try that, of course. I haven't managed yet to get such a clean picture as mpgxsvcd did. But I found something that I hope might help cracking that nut how to give the GF1 1080p: my shots look like the AVCHD codec seems to break or produce extreme amounts of mud while filming with the 1080p on the GF1. Curiously the mud gets considerably less while panning and takes over the whole picture when holding the camera still.

I did two sample shots of the same scene, one with panning and one with still camera. All was shot with a firmware with
_only_ the patches for
FHD-mode and
manual-movie-mode
checked
(and 3rd-party battery and language, but that shouldn't matter)
- no change of the AVCHD-codec etc.

Both where shot with
PAL, ISO400, 1/400, f1.4(Nikkor 50mm/f1.4).

Please tell me what kind of systematic tests might help collecting info to solve that GF1-1080p-AVCHD-puzzle. I would really like to help there and in two days time have some spare time to test.

Here are the original MTS-files. Please download them only, if you are going to do development work on this or really want help testing, as they are limited-downloads. Thanks.

Shot A - lots of panning, less (but still loads of) "mud" or borken codec:
http://rapidshare.com/files/409211814/20100726_173720.00004.MTS
Shot B - holding camera still, "mud" or broken codec all over the picture:
http://rapidshare.com/files/409208222/20100726_174014.00005.MTS
 
It is not necessary to test FHD patch at this stage, as it have " for fun" state :-)

Try to test two othe video related patches instead (they are in testers section).
I don't see any reports on them.
I mean "Remove encoder limits" and "Overall Bitrate 2".
First one could be useful for static high bitrate shots using native (as we have problems in encoder here).
 
Try to test two othe video related patches instead (they are in testers section).
I don't see any reports on them.
I mean "Remove encoder limits" and "Overall Bitrate 2".
First one could be useful for static high bitrate shots using native (as we have problems in encoder here).

Okay, understood and will do.
I have some questions regarding those patches though:

1.) In the description of "Overall bitrate2" it says "you must use all three patches to have any effect": does that mean that I should check "overall bitrate2", "remove encoder limits" and also either "preset bitrate" or "preset bitrate2" or does it mean that I should also check both "preset bitrate(2)" patches? ...or is it worth testing/trying all possibilities for those patch combination?

2.) The format of the value of "preset bitrate" is still a bit confusing to me (default 234 for 23,4Mbps). The description says "try to set it according to video bitrate" - does that mean that if I am using a value of 50.000.000 for "Video Bitrate" (under -> patches for end users -> avchd compression) that I should put "500" (from 50.0Mbps) under "preset bitrate"?

Hope I am not asking too much to be spoon-fed :-)

Thanks for all your work btw. ... manual movie mode for GF1 was such a fantastic treat!
 
I would just like to say thank you to Vitaliy and everyone else who worked on getting manual video controls for the GF1. I took some videos of my son at the beach this weekend if very difficult light and the manual controls made all the difference in the world.

Now if only there was a firmware hack to add a view finder to my GF1. That would be some magic that I would like to see.
 
Okay, understood and will do.
I have some questions regarding those patches though:

1.) In the description of "Overall bitrate2" it says "you must use all three patches to have any effect": does that mean that I should check "overall bitrate2", "remove encoder limits" and also either "preset bitrate" or "preset bitrate2" or does it mean that I should also check both "preset bitrate(2)" patches? ...or is it worth testing/trying all possibilities for those patch combination?

Do not look at this hint. It is copy fron Overall bitrate patch hint.
We also need to test original Overall Bitrate (leaving it at defaul value or making it even lower).

2.) The format of the value of "preset bitrate" is still a bit confusing to me (default 234 for 23,4Mbps). The description says "try to set it according to video bitrate" - does that mean that if I am using a value of 50.000.000 for "Video Bitrate" (under -> patches for end users -> avchd compression) that I should put "500" (from 50.0Mbps) under "preset bitrate"?

Generally, yes.
But do not use this patches during testing.
They had been introduced to better understand compression.
 
Looking at Bracketing part.
As always Panasonic team style is amazing.
Simple design flaw lead to many many extra routines, like multiple code conversions, spagetti code, etc.
How to get number of frames you must shoot,? Ouch, we don't want easy ways, we convert selection to special code, than convert this code to other code, and then use other conversion to get frames number. Company pays for this, anyways.
 
Looking at Bracketing part.
As always Panasonic team style is amazing.
Simple design flaw lead to many many extra routines, like multiple code conversions, spagetti code, etc.
How to get number of frames you must shoot,? Ouch, we don't want easy ways, we convert selection to special code, than convert this code to other code, and then use other conversion to get frames number. Company pays for this, anyways.

We know you will straighten it all out and make it better in the process. Maybe Panasonic will see this and want to hire you away one day? :Drogar-BigGrin(DBG)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
AGC
I can use Volume value now (available from menu). It is quite good option having 7 steps from 0 to 6. So, no more basic interface problems.

Does it mean that you can control volume manually? If yes, I am eagerly anticipating the next release of PTool for testing. :)
 
Back
Top