Arrik
Well-known member
I actually haven't tried this route yet... I guess you could literally take the proxies straight in there and do your magic. The one aspect I dislike about the proxies is that you are technically sacrificing some image quality... but this ties straight into the old debate of codecs and datarate; where often we assume more is always better. Now this may be technically accurate but is it even visible to the eye? REDCODE is marvelous itself and it's nearly impossible for even the best to decipher between Redcode and Raw which are very different datarate wise.
So although you're technically sacrificing some bits to work with the proxies. Is it that big of a deal? I think that's completely up to your taste based on the final results you're seeing. I'd take some proxies into color, play around and render out to your deliverable format. I'd also take that same shot, do a quick one-light in Redcine or RedAlert and do the same work in color. See if it's worth it.
We just had this conversation last night at the diner. I was saying we should see a side by side because of the "technical" quality loss. There's gotta somebody who's already done this test on reduser though, right? I mean there's people on both sides of the fence who say it is and isn't noticeable.
But, if Mark's computer runs fine on the redQT rewraps then this isnt really an issue for him.
On a side note, Mark is a badmuthashutyomouth! Great working with.