DESIDERATUM - A Film By Ben Sliker

I thought this was a good film with a nice ending and acting. Yes, I was one of those people that thought it was going somewhere else, but that's okay, because that's how I write as well. I like to see films like these. You took a real life situation that people hardly ever talk about, but that millions of people struggle with and it's not easy. As men we many times have a very difficult time understanding a woman's emotions and how their minds work and even though I think this is a story about a man and a woman and their struggle together, this is just one of those many things that a woman goes through for a man. Very thought provoking film.

Marlon,

It's really interesting you say some of that because we really had to define our focus, in the beginning, I contemplated and wrote parts of the story where both of them were struggling (say that he was shooting blanks, etc.) But as I write, and then we shot, and then edited, it became more and more of a story about HER than anything else. I think it offered us an opportunity to frame the characters better (like would you feel resent, disappointment, etc if your wife couldn't bear a child?) We even worked some magic with the way we framed shots to downplay his feelings vs. hers (e.g. the dining room scene), in fact, in that scene, she's being the more rational one. Even after all that has happened to them, david still wants to go back and start from scratch. Elizabeth has resigned to the fact that this is the only way she'll get to have a child.

Thanks for the insight!
Ben
 
...

I liked the mostly understated performances and did find the film affecting - which is the ultimate goal so well done! Certainly pretty to look at but this is also a film with a clear message and an intelligent and thorough thought process behind it.

Great job!

Thanks for the thoughtful and nuanced review Sarah! I appreciate comments like this, they really make me look at my film in a different light.
 
No problem Ben! My pleasure . You seem really open to feedback and eager to improve - really nice to see! I expect we'll be seeing big things from you sir!
 
Ben,

Very powerful and beautifully shot film about one of the intimately difficult times in a couple's life. I got infertility treatment thing the whole time. I questioned it briefly when the rubber band hit the floor - hormone shots are usually given in the buttocks not the arm so that threw me (and my partner who is an R.N.). But despite that stumble, I was really sucked in to their story. I think you really captured that feeling of "How much is too much?" that couple's get when trying to start a family.

I don't think the adoption felt tacked on. Bringing the car in the middle of the film established it as being part of their journey. Then we flash back to what else they went through to get to that point. I have to say, as an adoptive parent myself, I really appreciated that they chose adoption - and an older child at that! Not that I think everyone should adopt in that situation, but that she was so happy with the decision in the end. Very positive. Thank you.
 
Ben,
Striking cinematography, fluid edits, sound and score all right there. I, for one, enjoyed being held at bay by wondering if it was about her addiction or some other medical condition because I felt it drew me in. I looked more intently at the characters and what they were feeling and sharing. I thought the ending was not inappropriate, but the way it was paced, it almost rushed by before I could get it. I think it bears a second viewing to see if that holds water, but that was my first instinct. I think it might be that I didn't follow right away.
This is really a fine piece and certainly of the highest quality. I have only looked at about five so far, but this is right up at the top.
Congratulations and thanks for sharing this,
Stephen
 
No problem Ben! My pleasure . You seem really open to feedback and eager to improve - really nice to see! I expect we'll be seeing big things from you sir!

Just had a brainstorming session for our next film. It's epic to say the least!!! It's also a bit daunting, being at the bottom of the mountain again...

AmyO and sschedra, thanks for the wonderful comments, i'm really glad you enjoyed the film. (and I guess I'll have to do even more research next time, find out which shots you get in the arm and which ones you get in the butt! lol.)
 
(and I guess I'll have to do even more research next time, find out which shots you get in the arm and which ones you get in the butt! lol.)
I was going to comment on this as to one of the reasons why I felt you were misleading the audience but I didn't want to seem like I was trying to pick everything a part. :)

I do want to say this... you guys still made a very powerful film and I'm glad that you shared it with us. Well done. :thumbup:

MAH
 
Hi Ben,

I can't really add anything, but will say it was a good watch and a very powerful film. It looked great and the actors did a very good job. The score was also excellent.

Well done.
 
I do want to say this... you guys still made a very powerful film and I'm glad that you shared it with us. Well done. :thumbup:

MAH

Hi Ben,

I can't really add anything, but will say it was a good watch and a very powerful film. It looked great and the actors did a very good job. The score was also excellent.

Well done.

Thanks Guys! It's nice to wake up and have a couple more positive comments. I really want to thank Joe Johnson and Sid Barnhoorn for their work on the sound design and score for this piece. I was a giant pain in the ass, I think Sid went through 8 drafts for the beginning and middle of the film, trying different things until we had something.

Joe was pretty much sound designing right up to the deadline for me. I have to say, I really cobbled the dialogue together for timing on the picture lock and listened to it that way for a long time. After he sent me a version of the clean dialogue it was like I was watching my film for the first time again. Sound was definitely half the picture this time around.
 
Wow, truly terrific. A very powerful and moving piece. I, like many, followed your false trail you were leading us on during this film, and was almost shocked with the twist. I was so expecting a drug addiction of some sort that I was almost losing interest, and once the real problem hit, I got right back in to it. Its such a topic that is so rarely thought about by so many, and I think thats what helps make it so moving. I have to say, the scene with her in the tub covered in blood gave me chills. That was the most moving shot of the whole film for me. Really, a great job. This easily beats out Chasing Kangaroo's for most moving piece. Great work Ben, and great work to Sid with the soundtrack. I still have that ending piano piece playing through my head.

Jake
 
Wow, truly terrific. A very powerful and moving piece. I, like many, followed your false trail you were leading us on during this film, and was almost shocked with the twist. I was so expecting a drug addiction of some sort that I was almost losing interest, and once the real problem hit, I got right back in to it. Its such a topic that is so rarely thought about by so many, and I think thats what helps make it so moving. I have to say, the scene with her in the tub covered in blood gave me chills. That was the most moving shot of the whole film for me. Really, a great job. This easily beats out Chasing Kangaroo's for most moving piece. Great work Ben, and great work to Sid with the soundtrack. I still have that ending piano piece playing through my head.

Jake

Thanks for the kind words Jake! There's at least 10 people I have yet to thank publicly for their contributions to the film, from my fiance for being the glue, or my boss for letting us shoot in his office. (i still have a job even AFTER i left a huge mark on his wall! eek.) One of the best (and worst) parts of being the director is getting all the praise (and the criticism), but being able to tell someone else that people liked what they worked hard on is really cool too.
 
I already commented on this film, but I forgot to say:

Beautiful work Joe! Your style is recognizable. I love your eye for details - your way of using depth of field for drawing attention to them. Your way of use the coloured lighting - the contrast of the coloured light - I mean the composition of blue and red for esample and also then the contrast with the cold white light. I think your work matched very well with Ben's eye for details like the choice of the costumes, props, interior of the house - always seeing the colours. Watching 'Desideratum' again, I also was very possitive impressed of the acting of the main actress.

Susanne
 
Thanks Susanne, I appreciate that. It's easy working with a director that has a real vision for what he/she wants, it makes the creative process so much more productive.

-Joe
 
Thanks Susanne, I appreciate that. It's easy working with a director that has a real vision for what he/she wants, it makes the creative process so much more productive.

-Joe

Yes, it seems to me that Ben is well prepared before shooting and a real perfectionist. Your can see that he is working with the most possible presicion - always giving the best. It must be a pleasure to work with him.

Susanne
 
Hey Ben! Okay... so I watched it again... and I definitely felt a lot better about it on a second viewing. There's definitely a poignancy to likening the desire to birth a child to that of a drug addiction. And it certainly pays off at the end with the reveal. The look of the film is nothing short of beautiful and you've once again proven your ability to make a quality film on a shoe-string budget.

I think my original sub-par feelings about the film came from an idea that was firmly rooted in my brain during film school.. and that was to avoid the dreaded "Four D's" that have become the cliche of student filmmaking - Drugs, Depression, Dorms, and Death. The set up of your film (along with the title) suggest a drug addiction.. to which I respond (almost instinctually) by groaning. The reveal did little to soothe this initially, but on a second viewing (now understanding the analogy) I found it quite touching. So yeah... learned my lesson!

With that said... in looking for something to nitpick about... I felt like the husband (assuming they're married) character wasn't given a fair amount of screen time. I don't mean the part needed to be bigger.. I mean literally the actor's face wasn't given much attention. Not sure if this is intentional, or if it just sort of happened in the editing, but he's sort of shrouded for the majority of the film... mostly seen from behind or in profile.. or covered up by someone/thing in the foreground. The first time we see his face from the front is at 2:37 and then we don't get another good look until 4:13 and that's it. Not that I'm particularly dying to stare at his face for extended periods of time, but it's hard to make a connection to his character when I'm not exactly sure what he looks like. I don't know.. it's nitpicky I suppose.. but I thought it's worth mentioning.
Anyway, congrats again and good luck!
 
I think my original sub-par feelings about the film came from an idea that was firmly rooted in my brain during film school.. and that was to avoid the dreaded "Four D's" that have become the cliche of student filmmaking - Drugs, Depression, Dorms, and Death. The set up of your film (along with the title) suggest a drug addiction.. to which I respond (almost instinctually) by groaning. The reveal did little to soothe this initially, but on a second viewing (now understanding the analogy) I found it quite touching. So yeah... learned my lesson!

This is very interesting for me. My initial thoughts about how I wanted people to watch my film were based solely on the fact that I didn't want them to bring any preconceptions about conception/birth/adoption to the table. I don't think I ever considered someone bringing their preconceptions about "a film about drugs" and how that would effect someone who is watching. Writing dramas is exhausting on the brain ...

With that said... in looking for something to nitpick about... I felt like the husband (assuming they're married) character wasn't given a fair amount of screen time. I don't mean the part needed to be bigger.. I mean literally the actor's face wasn't given much attention. Not sure if this is intentional, or if it just sort of happened in the editing, but he's sort of shrouded for the majority of the film... mostly seen from behind or in profile.. or covered up by someone/thing in the foreground. The first time we see his face from the front is at 2:37 and then we don't get another good look until 4:13 and that's it. Not that I'm particularly dying to stare at his face for extended periods of time, but it's hard to make a connection to his character when I'm not exactly sure what he looks like. I don't know.. it's nitpicky I suppose.. but I thought it's worth mentioning.
Anyway, congrats again and good luck!

There's a couple prominent shots of his/her wedding rings (so yes, they are married :) ) I stated earlier in the thread that as the film progressed from writing to planning to shooting, it became more and more a story about her instead of him, which was nice, cause i think to have them both have major issues would be too much for 6 minutes. One of the vehicles that I used to show this was the framing (instead of dialogue, picture focus, screen time etc.)

For instance, in the dining room scene, David's feelings are quite irrational... she's just had a miscarriage and this guy wants to hop back in bed and start from the beginning like nothing happened. So instead of a nice Shot/Reverse Shot, David gets a profile shot, with the dark side of his face showing, instead of the glamor shot that Elizabeth has. Same goes for in the Dr.'s office, much more focus on the woman. And if you notice in the frontal shot of the two of them outside, David is just a little head in the background.

So, if you thought that it devalued the character or his lines in comparison to the woman, YES! that's what I wanted. It's very subliminal, but I was kinda hoping someone would pick up on it. The film is more about her! (Now, whether you liked this decision or not, completely different conversation.)

Thanks for the long and detailed review. (Although, you kinda owed me after that bombshell of a first comment you left.) I think I was going to give you 24 more hours until a scathing PM was coming your way about bringing unfounded negativity to my otherwise peaceful and tranquil thread.... :D he he.
 
Haha 'unfounded negativity' eh?

I definitely agree.. the story is most definitely about her. And I admire that it was a CHOICE versus a happy ACCIDENT to sort of shroud David in the drama. I don't think it was a bad choice, I just think it it's worth mentioning to you that I had to pause the movie in order to see what the guy looked like. That's all. It's up to you whether or not that's something your okay with.


This is very interesting for me. My initial thoughts about how I wanted people to watch my film were based solely on the fact that I didn't want them to bring any preconceptions about conception/birth/adoption to the table. I don't think I ever considered someone bringing their preconceptions about "a film about drugs" and how that would effect someone who is watching. Writing dramas is exhausting on the brain ...

Oh the irony! Unfortunately, I don't think it's possible to make a film without having someone walk into the film sans preconceived notions about whatever topic the film tackles. It sucked in my case just because of those "Four D's" and how I was trained to hate them SO MUCH! Haha... funny story... While I was in film school, I used to go back and visit my old high school film department and to guest lectures on screenplay structure. I would always make a big point of shunning the Four D's in hopes that the students would aim a little higher with their creativity. (Though, high schools don't have dorms, so I had to replace one of the D's with an S..for Skatebording videos!) But yeah, my efforts were usually in vain... as they still ended up producing videos about skateboarders who do drugs, get depressed, screw up in school, and commit suicide. But it's not for lack of trying!
 
Haha, thanks again Mike, it's refreshing to have a good back and forth. I'll keep in mind the four D's in the future.

Yes, it seems to me that Ben is well prepared before shooting and a real perfectionist. Your can see that he is working with the most possible presicion - always giving the best. It must be a pleasure to work with him.

Susanne

I was the most prepared for this shoot than I ever have been. That being said ... you can never be prepared enough, quite a conundrum really, i just stopped before my head exploded this time, then yelled ACTION! Somehow it turned out alright. :)
 
Hey Man ... Great / Solid / Honest little drama ... Portrayed Beautifully (Visually) ... I really liked the concept ... and it's directed perfectly ... Good Job Man ... looking forward for your next movie
 
... and it's directed perfectly ... Good Job Man ...

HAHA! YES! Who's got two thumbs and rocks at what he does? *THIS GUY* Take that Joe! lol. :Drogar-Smoke(DBG):

In all seriousness, thanks a bunch Girgej! It means a lot.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top