By Hook or Crook - By Troy Ruff

Hey Troy, excellent job! Easily one of my top favorites of the fest. As we could surmise from your BTS images, the production value was excellent here.

I'm really mixed on the slow mo - I love the mood it evokes, and the tension that builds up at the beginning. On the other hand, it takes nearly 2 minutes to get to the meat of the story, and I really would've loved that extra time to know more about these guys.

However once the first shot is fired, it's great stuff. I love the angles and use of speed ramping. The reveals are all very cool, and it ends just the way it should.

Big thumbs up.
 
Hey Troy,

I'm Anthony, howdy.

This thing had a real classic feel. Loved what you did with the slowing down of time in parts to generate mood. It worked. The story was clean. Looked great, well acted. Loved the fall from the horse. It felt real. Music was Leone-esque.

My one crit would be that in the begining chase, I felt he wouldn't have missed that close, but it's a movie, right? The editing was boss. I loved the transition to and from the flashbacks. Kick a.ss job.
 
This was very nice, very solid. LOVED the wide shot with the reflection in the water. Liked the flashbacks, but I was unclear whether or not the dad initially thought he was chasing his son. The synopsis says he doesn't know, but that wasn't clear from the film.

Great location on this, very nicely shown in the opening credits.

I liked how simple this was, but it could have definitely had a bit more detail to it. Maybe narration would work well with this? From the perspective of the father of course. Just something to think about that might add more substance to the film.

Great job though, I'm sure you will do well in the fest with such a strong entry.
 
This seemed like an old western to me so really nice job there. I also loved the wide shot with the reflection in the water, Jason beat me to it. :)

I felt that more distance between them would have made all the missed shots more believable but that's nitpicking. Great action, horses, etc... Some really nice scenes as well.
Actors did an admirable job.

Nice work.

MAH
 
I've done shooting from horseback....aint easy to hit a moving target, especially when your moving too!
 
I've done shooting from horseback....aint easy to hit a moving target, especially when your moving too!

Which is why I've always wondered. Why not just shoot the bloody horse!?

Again, it's a small nitpick and as you pointed out, it's probably VERY difficult to pull off. Couldn't agree more.

MAH
 
Solid and simple and I mean that as a compliment. The horses were great! I had chills in the beginning as it was setting up.
 
Solid film! I knew this was going to be good and was not disappointed...great job.
I liked the story, the cinematography and camera movement was beautiful (loved that opening shot),
score and sound design....excellent.

Congratulations to all involved!
 
Well Troy, I watched all of the WestFest entries. In my humble opinion, your film is up there with any of the best in the fest. Great job!

:Drogar-BigGrin(DBG)
 
All the BTS and grabs lead to some high expectations for this film, and for me it definitely lived up to them. The intro shots were gorgeous, and the chase was fantastic - I loved your use of slo-mo there, it worked really well, especially combined with your sound work. Great work Troy.
 
Hi, this was an awesome film. I only watched about 4 or 5 of the fest so far but this one is definitely my favorite so far. Everything was really good and there was a few shots that truly tricked my eye and I thought I was watching an epic 35mm western. I thought there was a few shots that really needed proper jib pulls instead of hand held raises and such, a tad too much hand held for my taste but over all very good and realistic effort with some very professional shots and acting.

Question: did you use a hacked GH1 or was it nonhacked?
 
Hi, this was an awesome film. I only watched about 4 or 5 of the fest so far but this one is definitely my favorite so far. Everything was really good and there was a few shots that truly tricked my eye and I thought I was watching an epic 35mm western. I thought there was a few shots that really needed proper jib pulls instead of hand held raises and such, a tad too much hand held for my taste but over all very good and realistic effort with some very professional shots and acting.

Question: did you use a hacked GH1 or was it nonhacked?

We used two non-hacked GH1's. Time got away from us as we only had a window of one day to shoot the film. There were many more Jib shots and such, we just didn't have time for as the sun was our clock. Glad you liked it! :2vrolijk_08:
 
Hi, this was an awesome film. I only watched about 4 or 5 of the fest so far but this one is definitely my favorite so far. Everything was really good and there was a few shots that truly tricked my eye and I thought I was watching an epic 35mm western. I thought there was a few shots that really needed proper jib pulls instead of hand held raises and such...

We had our 21' Hypercrane all set up to do those jib pulls and ran out of daylight. A lot of what you think are hand held pulls are actually steadycam shots with movement purposefully added. :Drogar-BigGrin(DBG)
 
By Hook or Crook

Nice film. Good action with the horses. Well choreographed. Felt the beginning was too long in comparison to the "meat" of the story that was the last 1/3 of screen time. Would have liked some more information on their relationship. It felt like a "scene" not a complete story. Decent acting. Some weird camera wobbles in a few shots. Overall a nice piece, I can see you're improving!
 
wow thanks everyone for your kind words. I really happy you all like it. It was hard to get that shot off the horses, but that said I agree with you guys, I would have liked it a little more distance between them, but Im happy with it. We shot this in 12 hours in one day. I have already told myself no more one day shoots. From now on, at least two day to make sure not to rush. :) I will be going through everyones comments and responding soon. Again Thanks so much for your comments. It helps us all grow as film makers.
 
Hi, this was an awesome film. I only watched about 4 or 5 of the fest so far but this one is definitely my favorite so far. Everything was really good and there was a few shots that truly tricked my eye and I thought I was watching an epic 35mm western. I thought there was a few shots that really needed proper jib pulls instead of hand held raises and such, a tad too much hand held for my taste but over all very good and realistic effort with some very professional shots and acting.

Question: did you use a hacked GH1 or was it nonhacked?

thanks, when we shot this, it was not hacked. but it is now. :)
 
Very well done, I realy liked it.

For a while it looks that the horses are either frozen, or fake :-p

The shots where they stand very very still...

And I found it funny, at the end the horse going away... I know it's not ment to be funny...but for me it was funny. Ha !
 
Nice to see a Western in Westfest! :evil:

Loved the authenticity of your cowboys. Great story, those estranged father and son stories get me everytime. Some inspired shot choices, in particular the CU of the hand dropping bullets, and the final WIDE shot of the shooting.

Overall great job.

Top three from me. :beer:
 
Back
Top