macgregor
Veteran
If this thing ships I am going to buy one. Maybe two. Here's why as it relates to a number of complaints I've seen in this thread.
1. Low light performance - Seriously? God forbid we actually have to LIGHT our films again instead of shooting everything at ISO 3200 and de-noising just so we don't have to place lights. I'm a cinematographer first, and actually enjoy lighting so this doesn't bother me. I light my DSLR shows, just like my other shows.
2. It's heavy. This coming from the same crowd that buy a pocket camera, put a metal cage on it, handles, broadcast batteries, counterweights for balance, external screens, external recorders, and all manner of accessories. I like that it's got weight to it. That means my handheld work won't have that cheap, frenetic look of a tiny DSLR. Go pick up a Dalsa Origin, or an Arri D21, or Viper, and get back to me.
3. It only has 12 stops of dynamic range. Ok, how many did the DVX100 have? Or the HVX? Or the RED One.
4. It uses expensive CFast media. Ummm, tell me about how much P2 media cost when it was as new as CFast. Or how much it is now. Or SxS, or AJA's media. Even SSD isn't cheap.
5. Blackmagic hasn't released firmware fixes for current cameras. So what. My BMCC works just like advertised. And it cost me less than my first purchase of SxS cards for my EX1.
6. It doesn't do 60p/120p. It's $6k. WIth the money you saved over buying a Scarlet package, rent a Flex4k.
7. BlackMagic ship cameras late. And RED. So don't plunk down on a pre-order. Keep your money in your pocket, and buy one when B&H has them in stock. Problem solved.
8. Why not just buy a used XYZ camera. Corporate accounting doesn't do "Used" cameras. If you're shooting for yourself, great. But I suspect a lot of these will find their way into corporate/government video departments, and that means new cameras only.
Here are my REAL concerns for this URSA camera.
1. Will it output frame lines onscreen... I want 2.40:1, 2:35:1, 16x9, and 4:3.
2. Can it run without a fan? That's a problem on the smaller cameras, but hopefully not on this one.
3. I think the 10" screen is too big. 7" would have been plenty. And I wish it had an EVF along with that screen so my puller could have a display to work from. But hey, it's cheap.
4. Will it ship anywhere near on time? I'm not in a particular hurry, but fiscal year planning makes this one tricky for me.
5. Will they solve the overdriven whites issue? At this budget level, they need that solved. On the $2k cameras, it's not fun, but more forgivable.
Overall, it's a nice effort and version 2 will probably be stunning. I just wish BM would get cameras like this in the hands of some ASC, BSC, etc., members to suss out some of the human interface issues before finalizing design.
WHile I don't like the BM camera that much, I have to say your post was very smart and I agree about all you're saying. Congrats.