1 minute short film: Does this look cinematic?

Hello Tracey!

Very nicely shot!

But since you´re here: Any chance of ever sending me those tentacle parts we agreed on as replacement for my rng35 and which you forgot to pack with the rails (which are really good btw)?

I couldn´t help but noticing that we aren´t facebook friends anymore, so I´ve sent a pm to you with my new home adress for your convenience.

Regards!
 
Quick answer: NO.

Elaborated answer:

It's all about the subtle things really. You can't take your brand new GH1, 7D, 5D... shoot a few takes on your bathroom and expect it to look cinematic, because it won't.

The main problem I see it of course the lighting. It looks totally flat and you haven't even graded it in post. Please note that I'm talking about simple grading, not adding a strong look from Magic Bullet or something like that. Just adding some contrast and adjusting the overall color to something more pleasant would've been perfect.

She's got a candle lit but it doesn't do anything to the overall lighting, so it's pretty much useless. Never put useless stuff on the screen. It makes the whole clip look less professional.

Also you tend to overuse the shallow DOF putting things close to the cam without really composing the take or letting it breathe. You may think that helps to the cinematic look, but it's doing right the opposite.

Also always plan your shoot to show exactly what you want to show. Be careful with your horizon line and use strange angles when they're really useful for the story.

If you're starting, try to look for movies with similar scenes and don't hesitate to copy camera angles and movements, lighting, setups...
 
The shaky cam makes it look videoish. There are times when that look is appropriate - high intensity action scenes or "on the run" scenes come to mind. Tranquility, peace, harmony, love and shaky camera movement don't really fit.

As for the lighting, I agree with the others (even though I'm hardly qualified - I'm sure I'll be asking the same question in the not too distant future).

Also, what frame rate was this shot at? That can affect the look, too.
 
(Sergio Leone is one of my favorite film makers and one of the pioneers of EXTREME close ups, ie super shallow dof) .


While I've not watched GBU in quite a while, I did watch "Once Upon a Time in the West"(1968) recently, and one of the 'features' is 'deep focus' while maintaining a 'close up' look. Very often shots will have the actor in the 'near' foreground, sharp, and sufficent DoF to not fuzz out the background, distant... sometimes miles of distance...

One shot in the initial sequence has the actor's face nearly filling the screen top to bottom, but the shot framed so one can see the train steam engine coming down the tracks in the distance. While the distant engine is soft... it is not so soft as is popular with current shallow DoF styles... that it becomes some sort of 'impressionist' painting,
rather than a reasonably clear image, just slightly soft...

Ok, not my example above, but here's a similar setup...

once-upon-a-time-in-the-west-claudia-cardinale.jpg


Claudia Cardinale is sharp, but you can also read the lettering on the water tank in the distant background... and naturally, everything in between...
 
Back
Top