1 minute short film: Does this look cinematic?

Tracey Lee

Well-known member
Hey fellow film makers. I would like your opinions here. I will cut right to it. I am not asking for any comments or opinions on the content/story of this film. I only want your opinions/suggestions on the over-all cinematic quality of this piece.

Any and all responses are welcome. I just want to know if you think it has a cinematic feel to include all aspects: framing, coloring, dof, etc etc.

Thanks in advance!

http://www.thesmalls.com/members/tracey-lee/films/love-note.go

GH13
Nikon 35mm

PS Sorry it's not viewable in its HD glory...haven't gotten it up to vimeo yet.
 
Last edited:
It's kinda hard to decipher whatcha mean by look cinematic, because the difference between cinema is the content, tone and length and you've restricted us from commenting that ;)


Especially in today's age when you get converging mediums like adverts (30 second short films...) and TV. However, their standards are incredibly high and to throw the word 'this is cinematic' would dilute the terminology. Because if that looks cinematic, than these would be super duper cinematic, and actual cinema would be off the scale. Very rarely would anyone say that in regards to those mediums, unless they were super lush like- like BMW or Guinness adverts.

So is this work cinematic? Nope!

Is it competently shot and have tone? Yes, you did a great job! =]
 
I like it. Both the story and the look. I think your could have used one or two shots without something between the lens and the subject, but honestly it doesn't matter to me. I thought it looked pretty fantastic :)

Give us the link when it's on Vimeo!

And I agree with Lammy.
 
Saying that though, what should be classed as 'cinematic' are emotions that are brought from out of the audience - a catharsis. This could come from the entire length of the movie through the story, performance, the music, or heck, even 1 shot.

Beauty adverts do it very well, albeit in a shallow and short cut way. For example cars on open horizons, or a few subliminal voice-over primer words about life. - because those are things we havent got must show us where we can go. Make us feel wow the world is so deeeep and beautiful man.

The lady in your advert does seem to have her own happy at the end, but the audience has not joined this lady on her journey. Unless I'm just retarded and don't understand the shaving legs metaphor - hence why I'm saying more specifically why it doesn't look nor feel cinematic. =] Ack, sorry I'm talking about the content again rather than the technical aspects.

I guess shooting on 35mm (the candles and blown highlights would roll off better...), and lighting more harshly (to sculpt shadows, her wrinkles and give shape) would also make it look more professionally too...
 
The lighting is too 1 dimensional to be cinematic. Even film with very even lighting tend to have texture.

You have one shot where I can see a candle is lit. You would have been better suited to use more candle and some ambient lighting to help create more shadows and definition.

Still looks nice, but feels like you went in to the bathroom and flipped on a switch and that was it.

I like available light shooting as much as anyone; however, even then you need to work to bounce it and create dimension.
 
To me it's a matter of context. To echo Lammy 's comments, there's little emotional attachment to the subject, because of the length and the present lack of story.

And yes, the lighting be could be improved, as Rory mentions.

But some nice framing.

So IMHO, it could be cinematic in a bigger story, but because of its form, looks for now more like a commercial.
 
I have to say no due to lighting - lacks texture, depth, color, feels like a home movie to me. Exposure is part of telling the story and it's very flat leaning on underexposed and given the setting it ends up looking a bit dull. It doesn't look like you had control over the image, and I don't mean that to sound as harsh as it does, but to me something that looks cinematic has a certain "confident" look about it, it's solid, exposure is right, lighting and color are right, framing is right, depth/texture is right - now of course using the word "right" is all subjective, but I think in the end for any shot you just have to ask yourself "did I have control over this? Is this how I wanted it to look in my head?" if you end up answering yes to that, and what you want in your head is a cinematic image, then there's a good chance you'll have one on film.

I know it when my stuff looks good, and I know it when it doesn't, and that gap is huge. Look at the shot, if you could imagine it being projected in a movie theater as part of a movie of sufficient quality to be projected in a movie theater and it being in place there, then it looks cinematic, if you think it would look out of place under those circumstances, it probably is.
 
Last edited:
I just want to know if you think it has a cinematic feel to include all aspects: framing, coloring, dof, etc etc.

I personally did not feel the framing was cinematic. In addition, I found the camera movement distracting, but I do recognize that a lot of films have a "shaky" camera. I personally think you would do well to add (a lot of) weight to the camera if you're going to handhold it -- or get a Steadicam Merlin.

I know you said not to mention the story, but the biggest thing IMO to the "cinematic" look is that it tells a story. Story is the defining characteristic of (narrative) cinema. I did not sense much of a story in the admittedly short film, but it can be done.

Put another way, I didn't think the visuals told a story -- hence, not cinematic. I'd wager that the "confidence" thisisapocalypse is talking about is related to the "telling a story" thing I'm talking about. In cinema, everything about a shot is the way it is for a reason, and that reason is to tell a story. What you achieved is what I would call a "mood". Nothing wrong with that, but it's secondary to telling a story -- and most of the mood came from Moby's music anyway (as is true in most films).
 
Last edited:
#1 thing that makes this not cinematic for me is the dof. It's too flat.

#2 is the lighting, it's too flat.

#3 is the fact that there is sooooo much white! White walls,are the number one thing I avoid shooting against.

try shooting this same project with the same framing with shallower dof, three point lighting and in a better location and then compare the two results.
 
Rory beat me to it... lighting is everything.

It looked decent enough... but "cinematic"?... for that you gotta' have layers of light.
 
I don't know guys... I agree with you about lighting and framing adding up to a cinematic feel, that's obvious. But I think it's all about context too. The opening CUs I would say are cinematic in feel and look, save the double shadows on the bath tub.

To me this had the same aesthetic as The Wrestler, and would you say that's not a cinematic feel? I think the key to achieving an cinematic experience for your viewer is more like a recipe than any one thing, ingredients like characters, story, lighting, framing, sound, soundtrack, DOF all are added to create cinema, some people add more of a certain ingredient, some don't add one but add more of another, and that's where taste comes in, but there is a recipe for cinema by which all other recipes are derived.

So I'm a little confused by "I am not asking for any comments or opinions on the content/story of this film". I think too many times on here people just talk about the technical and not about the story, which is a huge mistake.

Asking us to discuss the cinema-ness of your film but not the story is like asking us to rate you as a basketball player, but ignore your jumpshot, you know what I mean?
 
Sean makes a good point,

Set design and aesthetics are huge as well. It's obvious your going for something sensual, lady in tub, candle light, ect.. I think you could have made it much better with changing the details, Blue nail polish says teenie bopper, mr bubbles, shaving legs, all of these are issues working against you in my opinion. I would have had the room lit with candle light, had her paint her toenails, a deep reddish color. Use a classy bottle of bubbles, something from victoria secret, or bed and bath. mr bubbles is pretty ghetto for the look your going for. scratch the leg shaving, just the sound of it is a huge turn off. I would have had a decent makeup job. It looks like she's been cleaning all day and she's jumping in the tub to shave her legs and run out to the grocerystore. Anything can be cinematic, it's the look and point of the story that counts.
 
Isay if you have a white set.... go with it... make it brighter. blast the room with light and make it almost like a white box.

If you dont have the ability to shape light... just put it everywhere.... andi mean EVERYWHERE. sometimes its just crazy looking enough to work....

Here:
http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/showthread.php?t=140498

Get started and shoot!..... :)
 
For me having deep focus was one of the things that made video a dead give away (I thought that was why we all went out and bought 35 adapters, and scrambled to get vdslrs in the first place?). To me 35mm film's dof is "cinematic" I'm not saying that every shot has to be bokah galore but having our focus as the audiance shifted to the subject instead of having every shot be deep focus would help. Only my 2 cents.
 
Back
Top