MattinSTL
Sound Modulator
To me this had the same aesthetic as The Wrestler, and would you say that's not a cinematic feel? I think the key to achieving an cinematic experience for your viewer is more like a recipe than any one thing, ingredients like characters, story, lighting, framing, sound, soundtrack, DOF all are added to create cinema, some people add more of a certain ingredient, some don't add one but add more of another, and that's where taste comes in, but there is a recipe for cinema by which all other recipes are derived.
So I'm a little confused by "I am not asking for any comments or opinions on the content/story of this film". I think too many times on here people just talk about the technical and not about the story, which is a huge mistake.
I think the OP is looking for input specifically on the look of this footage, as shot, lit, and edited... otherwise I agree with your points about the "whole" of a film = cinematic... and I would expect that most others would as well(?)
Perhaps the OP is excited about the new-found ability to mimic high budget i.e. "cinematic" productions... and just wanted to know if he was doing that? That's how I answered... agreeing with others that the lighting (and therefore the shots) looked flat.
That's not to say that "looking cinematic" is always a good thing... you're right, that the look should depend on the story. On that note, for my taste, the wrestler didn't look cinematic... save for a few scenes. I thought it looked like a documentary most of the time. That sure didn't hurt it's success though... if anything it probably helped.