1 minute short film: Does this look cinematic?

To me this had the same aesthetic as The Wrestler, and would you say that's not a cinematic feel? I think the key to achieving an cinematic experience for your viewer is more like a recipe than any one thing, ingredients like characters, story, lighting, framing, sound, soundtrack, DOF all are added to create cinema, some people add more of a certain ingredient, some don't add one but add more of another, and that's where taste comes in, but there is a recipe for cinema by which all other recipes are derived.

So I'm a little confused by "I am not asking for any comments or opinions on the content/story of this film". I think too many times on here people just talk about the technical and not about the story, which is a huge mistake.

I think the OP is looking for input specifically on the look of this footage, as shot, lit, and edited... otherwise I agree with your points about the "whole" of a film = cinematic... and I would expect that most others would as well(?)

Perhaps the OP is excited about the new-found ability to mimic high budget i.e. "cinematic" productions... and just wanted to know if he was doing that? That's how I answered... agreeing with others that the lighting (and therefore the shots) looked flat.

That's not to say that "looking cinematic" is always a good thing... you're right, that the look should depend on the story. On that note, for my taste, the wrestler didn't look cinematic... save for a few scenes. I thought it looked like a documentary most of the time. That sure didn't hurt it's success though... if anything it probably helped.
 
For me having deep focus was one of the things that made video a dead give away (I thought that was why we all went out and bought 35 adapters, and scrambled to get vdslrs in the first place?). To me 35mm film's dof is "cinematic" I'm not saying that every shot has to be bokah galore but having our focus as the audiance shifted to the subject instead of having every shot be deep focus would help. Only my 2 cents.


Yeeeaaah, except this video has a very shallow depth of field. Almost too shallow with the focus having to scan for her at times, combined with the shaky cam - it gives off a kind of trancey-accidental (if pervy) tone =]

But I also agree with other posters, shallow DOF does not equal "cinematic."
 
On that note, for my taste, the wrestler didn't look cinematic... save for a few scenes. I thought it looked like a documentary most of the time. That sure didn't hurt it's success though... if anything it probably helped.

No Matt I think you're totally right, but I think theres such thing as cinematic realism, if the story involves you. The Wrestler isn't cinematic as Seven was, but I believe it is in it's own brand, with movies like Primer, and In the Loop, and even The Bourne Identity.
 
No Matt I think you're totally right, but I think theres such thing as cinematic realism, if the story involves you. The Wrestler isn't cinematic as Seven was, but I believe it is in it's own brand, with movies like Primer, and In the Loop, and even The Bourne Identity.

I agree... The wrestler was a great example of storytelling with a shaky handheld camera to give you the impression you were there holding the camera yourself.
I think it's more about story than lighting, dof or anything else. This short looks and feels like a commercial because the story might have taken too much time on the woman prep to take a bath. After only a few seconds, i felt like I was being sold body wash or something.
 
I agree with the need to either light it really hot. Or go all candles.

The look of the wrestler is perfect for the content.

The look here doesn't fit the subject.

Take 4 large candles strategically placed and you can add shadow, depth, texture, and a gorgeous warm roll off into the shadows for a really great feel that would match the scene. Your white walls are no longer white. They're now grades of white, red, and black just by eliminating the stark nature of the ceiling pot lights.

The stark flat lighting makes me expect a murder. That can always work too if you want to play on genres. But you still need texture.

The wrestler may have been doc style available light shooting, but they shot 16mm to give it a grungy grainy look that perfectly suits the story about a run down wrestler living in despair.

If the actress in this had been lit with a more sensual pleasing tone in mind, it would go a long ways to having the look match the story and create an more cinematic feel overall.
 
Okay, I've seen citizen kane (as has every other film school grad lol) and the good, the bad, and the ugly (Sergio Leone is one of my favorite film makers and one of the pioneers of EXTREME close ups, ie super shallow dof) so while I understand where your coming from and appreciate what your saying those examples your using are not relevant to this post. The extreme dof shots in citizen kane have multiple planes of focus not one. TG,TB,ATU has wide open landscapes that are being shown off not white walls... Are you suggesting that this short reminds you of how those films were shot?Like I said, I'm not encouraging the op to shoot everything for a shallow dof effect, just have an idea what the subject of each shot is and frame, light, and focus accordingly. It's funny that so many people want to jump on my telling the op to keep his images within different planes of focus when we have people modding iphones with 35 adapters to get bokah lol.
 
An extreme closeup has nothing to do with super shallow depth-of-field. It can have that, but it doesn't mean it's a requirement.

well its kind of a by product of optics....

Shallow DOF on a closeup using a long lens is a matter of fact. unavoidable even at F22. Claiming its an aesthetic choice is like throwing a ball and taking credit for it hitting the ground as "a choice"....
 
well its kind of a by product of optics....

Shallow DOF on a closeup using a long lens is a matter of fact. unavoidable even at F22. Claiming its an aesthetic choice is like throwing a ball and taking credit for it hitting the ground as "a choice"....


Right, but it is a choice to use that lens vs. an 18mm or something
 
Okay, I'm not trying to argue. lets all make friends, I was just giving my advice, I'm far from Wells or Leone myself. As a matter of course I'll just say this, what makes something cinematic looking to each and every one of us will differ so we can at least agree that no one can be "right" in a debate like this. To the OP, sorry for derailing your thread.
 
it's true, big aperture is not only way to make shallow DoF. shallow DoF can be also achieved by long lense zooming on someone. i'm actually not familiar with the appropriate process/phenomena responsible for this effect but i know that it is pretty much inviolable. i.e. no matter what aperture you're at if you zoom in on a subject and focus on it, the rest will be out of focus, i.e. shallow depth of field.

anyways to chime in I agree with what most of you experts are saying, the most important thing is lighting. just slick framing of your shots alone will not give you a cinematic look, you have to utilize lighting to give depth and dimension to your scene. imagine your film as a painting, a living painting that you are constantly recreating in every frame of every shot rather than a home movie on camcorder. as someone else said give some texture to the shadows, crevices, surfaces by lighting, whether it's some extra candles strewn about or whatever...
 
To put it back on trek... if there are any Star Trek TNG fans here, I thought that series was awesome... many of the episodes were far better (in my opinion) then the theatrical releases with the same cast... BUT, the theatrical releases looked cinematic... for me, that's the difference.

Sure, it's everything... framing, SCALE, shooting style, etc... but using my above analogy... TNG was shot with similar lighting to a soap opera... but the lighting style evolved with the show's evolution. The theatrical releases had weak story, but were cinematic... in the beginning of the film and on the ship anyway.

Analogies like that are what I'm using as a basis for "does this look cinematic"... vs. "does this feel cinematic".
 
TimurCivan said:
you would only use an 18mm for a closeup if youre shooting a zany comedy, or something...

Aye, other exceptions are:

out of consequence due to tight location

if they want to see extra planes of focus (usually with a split focus diopter though)

"character's feels warped"

Michael Mann's latest films... Transpotting with drugs and babies... or Wong Kar Wai films... band music videos...


To put it back on trek... if there are any Star Trek TNG fans here, I thought that series was awesome... many of the episodes were far better (in my opinion) then the theatrical releases with the same cast... BUT, the theatrical releases looked cinematic... for me, that's the difference.

Analogies like that are what I'm using as a basis for "does this look cinematic"... vs. "does this feel cinematic".

Your analogy kinda works, but in order to feel cinematic, it has to look cinematic at the very least too. Otherwise you couldn't distinguish the terminology, you could say soap operas (some are bloody well written and make you cry...) feel cinematic. No, they don't.

The Wrestler has moments that look and feel cinematic, that tell alot (ie when he's rising above on the turnbuckle, when he's trying to relate to his daughter among the pier, etc the grungey cinema-verite feeling)

Star Trek TV episodes are better written, for sure, but the episodes never felt cinematic to me. With exceptions with of BORG 2 parters. Even the movies like Star Trek Insurrection didn't feel cinematic either, they just looked it.
 
Thanks for all your suggestions and comments. Much appreciated. There is some really good advice here. I have mostly been impressed with lighting suggestions. There is a lot you can do with lighting and I hope to do more with it in future films. Though I do love the use of natural lighting, I know at least bounce cards should always be used.

Thanks again.
 
it's true, big aperture is not only way to make shallow DoF. shallow DoF can be also achieved by long lense zooming on someone. i'm actually not familiar with the appropriate process/phenomena responsible for t..

It is called "compression." It is not the same as DOF but shallow DOF and compression from a longer lens can both blur the background.

I have a general question, does this film help by the hack? It seems that one can do the same with the original GH1, correct?
 
Thanks for all your suggestions and comments. Much appreciated. There is some really good advice here. I have mostly been impressed with lighting suggestions. There is a lot you can do with lighting and I hope to do more with it in future films. Though I do love the use of natural lighting, I know at least bounce cards should always be used.

Thanks again.

Natural light is great, but as you say bounce cards, but also the way you position your actors and/or camera in relation to tat light can make a world of difference.

Shooting your actors backs to a setting sun creates an entirely different dimension than if you had them staring into it.

Same light source but 2 completely different aesthetics and feel.
 
It is called "compression." It is not the same as DOF but shallow DOF and compression from a longer lens can both blur the background.

I have a general question, does this film help by the hack? It seems that one can do the same with the original GH1, correct?

thank you. i was always looking for the correct term for this phenomenon. can you tell me how it's not the same as DoF? Just wanting to learn more about it
 
Back
Top