ahalpert
Major Contributor
I was amused by this column in the NYT about "dad culture" evolving from one generation to the next. What do you associate with dadness for yourself or your own dad?
I think my biggest visceral association with my dad from childhood was his fat leather brown wallet, comically overstuffed with receipts and all manner of paper scraps he would never need again. I think that's why I use a similar wallet (without a sense of irony), although I try to filter out the useless contents on a regular basis.
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/06/16/style/millennial-dad-style-culture.htmlWhen I think about my stepfather, who raised me, I think about the way he wielded his grill tongs, padding around the deck in his tapioca-colored apron, as if it were the most natural act in the world. Or the way he turned down the volume on the national television broadcast of N.F.L. games in favor of the local radio announcers, who “weren’t idiots.” Or the way he sought out a maritime museum anywhere we went on family vacation. I’m now a father of two with three years of experience, but if I tried any of those things today, I would hear a little voice in my head, saying “look at the big dad man, dadding it up for his family!”
“Irony has seeped into the felt of any fedora that I have ever owned — not out of any wish of mine, but out of necessity,” the essayist George W.S. Trow wrote in 1980 of his father’s beloved headwear. “A fedora hat worn by me without the necessary protective irony would eat through my head and kill me.”
So many of the signifiers that spring to mind when we think about dads are like this: Dated, or goofy, or vestigial, or naive. Take the riding lawn mower, a relic from a time before climate change made us cringe at the smell of burning gas. Or the Playboy stash, an anachronism of print culture. Or the mechanical wristwatch, an antique you can’t even use to order pizza.
After three years of diaper blowouts and daycare-spawned plagues (ever heard of something called “pleurisy”? Neither had I), I’ve come to see the old dad ways a little more sympathetically, and with some measure of recognition. After all, our dads were responding to the same essential dad conflict we are: the tension between giving your life over to the needs of your family and keeping enough mental space for yourself to stay sane. In that context, the rider mower makes brilliant sense. It’s alone time (“What? Honey? I can’t hear you! This thing’s loud, huh!”) that accomplishes a putatively necessary domestic task.
Still, the touchstones of Boomer dad culture have outlived their descriptive usefulness for younger generations. What, we might ask, is dad culture in 2023? Does it even exist?
I think my biggest visceral association with my dad from childhood was his fat leather brown wallet, comically overstuffed with receipts and all manner of paper scraps he would never need again. I think that's why I use a similar wallet (without a sense of irony), although I try to filter out the useless contents on a regular basis.



