XH G1 vs HPX170 for HD-SDI / NanoFlash recording?

[BigRedBarn]

I'm curious if anyone has compared the XH G1 with the HPX170 (in terms of image resolution and low light sensitivity) from their HD-SDI outputs only. All of the comparisons I've read thus far between these two cameras have focused more on MPEG2/HDV vs DVCProHD/P2.

I'm curious how these two cameras would compare if they were recording to a NanoFlash or other HD-SDI recorder or capture card directly. No tape and no P2 cards used.

 

[Huy Vu]

Recording to a Nanoflash or via the HD-SDI output would not affect features like sharpness or low light resolution. That's a function of the sensor. Previous comparisons have shown that the G1 is sharper than the 170 due to a higher pixel count but is less light sensitive due to the same reason.