Unforntunate IDX Sequel

jlames

Well-known member
Nothing pleased me more than to come back from a weekend shoot and relate the real-world results of field-testing the IDX batteries under real-world shooting (see previous post). IDX's Michelle was wonderful to provide us loaners to use which worked great... but now the bad news. The program leaves alot to be desired.

We purchased a total of 5 JVCs from EVS taking delivery of the last ones on 2-7-06. That's about $25,000 for what is, in our opinion, a great camera and precisely what we need for the next 18 months. BUT, today is 2-16-06 and we have still not received the certificates from EVS mainly because EVS has not received them from JVC; certificates which do noting more than provide us the opportunity to complete them, attach sales receipts and box cut-outs to them and mail them into JVC. And that's noyt for a lack of trying on EVS' part. Rush is on the phone daily with absolutely no results. So that's a total so far of 10 days that the cameras would have been siting idle save for outside power which is a complete hassle on the location shoots requiring lines to be run from inverters by juicers who cost us extra money when they could be used sewtting lighting. Even if the certificates get there by tomorrow, we're informed that we'll have to wait another 6-8 weeks for the paperwork to be processed and the batteries and mounting hardware to be delivered.

So here's the final analysis. I'm really sad to say that, no matter how good the camera is, no matter how well the IDX batteries perform, the IDX / JVC deal serves absolutely no purpose what so ever. For us, we'll wind up buying batteries and mounting hardware this week because we have serious, 4-camera location shoots coming up next week in distant Arizona and the following week in Nevada. We'd rent them but the cost would be about the same as buying them so we might as well just bite the bullet now and have the extras gathering dust in the truck. Besides, we can't find them to rent anyway from EVS... they don't have any. If they did, I'm sure they' loan them to us. So, for us, it's a needless expenditure of money that can't be recovered to buy equipment that'll eventually, probably find its way to us months from now. But for the serious independent who doesn't have our financial resources and needs to shoot footage now, it's a complete bummer for a company to raise expectations by advertising this "great deal" and then say, "Well, you'll have to use the junk batteries until we get around to fulfilling our promise" ... and that just stinks. The original JVC batteries are not of sufficient strength to carry a day's production for anyone so, in the end, the camera is basically useless unless you have the deep pockets to afford to buy or rent the IDX setup to get you through until the "great deal" arrives some 2-months later if then. Then you 're stuck with extra setups that shooters couldn't afford in the first place. I can't tell you how disappointing this whole deal is.

Now I know some of you are saying, "Hey, B&H or XYZ Company got me my cert in a couple of days." and "Well it only took a week for me to get mine." and that's all well and good. But the fact of the matter is that if that's the case, JVC and IDX should treat every retailer equally. At Blue Line Cinema and Hawkfeather Productions, we believe in loyalty and spending our money with people we trust and EVS is, for better or worse, our supplier of choice. We've already dropped about $30,000 with them since January and will probably spend the bulk of a $300,000 budget this year with them because 9 out of 10 times they come through. And if they can't come through because JVC or IDX isn't getting them the certificates or battery systems they need to get to us, we're not going to penalize them for that. Buyer beware is all I can say.

If I'd have known that 10-days after buying 5 cameras and taking delivery on 4 of them I wouldn't have the power I need to run them, I'd still have bought the cameras but I wouldn't have any great expectations of some great deal; ideas that have only been dashed and led to disappointment and this rant against JVC and IDX.

You know, I was going to apologize here for going off on this rant when normally I try to sit down each evening after the production day's over and review the forums I know about and lend constructive help and advice to people where I can ... and also read the postings of people like Barry Green and Jared Land and others who have forgotten more than I'll ever know; postings that serve to open my eyes, educate me and make me a better producer for my distributors and the audiences our work serves. But you know what? I'm not going to apologize. My rage is appropriate given the fact that this Board is dedicated to spreading the word between people who pay JVC's and IDX's employees' payrolls and I really hope that they read this. And to them I say, "For those of us who buy your equipment because it's the best we can find for the job we do, you're not helping us at all when those very cameras sit idle, not making us any money and in fact costing us money, while you get your paperwork together."

In another forum or maybe this one, I forget, a guy in South America, gustavotg I think his username is, just the other day blew up his new JVC, tried to contact JVC Customer Service and when he got nowhere, turned to this forum for help. I responded giving him the e-mail of the only person I knew who could help him and told him to contact me if there was no response from JVC. Why? Because I've been where he was and I have an unopened JVCHD 100 in my office. I was going to send him that new camera if JVC didn't respond to his needs. Now I know that's easy to say but Rush will back me up on this when I told him about my offer and he wondered what would happen if I never got my camera back? Well, I knew I would because members of this Board helps other members and if I have a way to help with a new camera I'm not using yet, I'll do it. Fortunately, in that post I read that a JVC Executive Vice President took care of the matter for the gentleman and I hope he's now completing his work down there. So to that Vice President I say, if you're reading this, "Do something about this program because as it stands, it stinks." I'd also say, honestly, "Don't worry, I'll still buy your cameras because I need 4 more in the next month but having to buy power systems for the ones I just bought to get my crew through until you figure out your paperwork is working a needless hardship on us. But then again, what's the downside for you and IDX? You're making a profit off of my situation and anyone else who buys the JVC and needs it right now so I guess your shareholders are happy. And besides, people who read this will forget about the issue in due time anyway. N o harm...no foul, Right?" That's what I'd say to you Mr. Executive Vice President. Oh, wait, I just did.

And finally, to emanuel I think, who once posted, "He sure likes to hear himself talk, doesn't he?"... I say, "This time I'm guilty as charged, but I sure feel better." I simply think that if you set, purposely or inadvertantly, expectations, you should hit the mark. We shouldn't have to, "Read the Fine Print."

OK, back to constructive stuff. Does anyone know where the spell check feature went? ;)
 
Click this. This is B & H's rebate form but aren't they all the same? Can you not put EVS as the dealer and follow the directions on the rebate form? On the rebate form there is a phone number. Call it and ask what to do.
 
Thanks for your post and the PM, Stephen. As I said in my response, I don't know. I'm on location in LA tomorrow about a mile from EVS so I'll ask Rush and see. Either way, thanks for the help and recommendation. Even if it doesn't work, your response proves that the people on this Board are the greatest and always willing to provide a possible solution.
J
 
I agree that the HD100 is a great camera and don't blame you for buying more but I think we need to take your disgust in this promotion and say it louder.

I understand that the people at IDX have been good to you but guess what, they are the other half of this promotion. It is their name that gets smeared by this unacceptable lag time. Would you lend your name or product to another person or company if you thought it was going to be handled badly? IDX needs to put pressure on JVC to come up with a faster way of doing this. Maybe IDX needs JVC more than JVC needs IDX but remember it's this promotion that is probably selling HD100's faster. I'm sure there is some contract between the companies but I would guess any smart lawyer would have put a clause in that would allow IDX to pull out of the promotion should their name be tarnished. This is a perfect case. Ok, so maybe I'm making it a bit dramatic and simple but seriously I'm not sure I would have bought this camera just yet had it not been for the promotion.

If JVC enjoys bad press or underestimates the power of these forums then they are foolish. The battery that comes with the HD100 is an insult. The charger is an instult. Heck, you can't even charge the battery at the same time you are using the charger to provie AC to the camera. Let me get this straight? You give me a worthless battery that forces me to use AC after a few minutes but I can't even charge the battery while still staying powered up?

The IDX is a great answer to this problem, it's a great deal, but as you said it is almost worthless as it means not using the camera until it arrives or buying batteries anyway. So you either forget the promotion and buy your own IDX or Aanton system, or you put the camera on the shelf for a few months while you wait. Gee, what an option. If I end up having to buy my own batteries, no offense IDX but I won't be buying yours. As I said, your name is attached to this promotion too.

As far as EVS. I love em' so far. However, if I was Rush I would really put the heat on and refust to carry anymore JVC products if they don't get those certificates asap. After all it doesn't help EVS any and why should B&H have printable certificates but not anyone else?
 
Last edited:
jlames, I'd say definitely do as Stephen advised and download/fill out/send in that coupon ASAP. Then I'd say to contact IDX directly and ask them to assist.

Third, have you considered renting Anton Bauers for the intervening time period? A/B has a plate out, don't they? Might be easier to find than IDXs at rental facilities. I don't know, I'm just trying to toss out something that might help you get through this.

Good luck.
 
Truer words have never been spoken, my friend. As I've said many times, especially at the DGA infront of 5 of their reps including their President/CEO, there are a few of us on this board there who produce network, a few who produce independent, a few who are retailers, a few who are wholesalers, a few who are distributors and thousands and thousands who are looking to buy who look to this Board for honest, accurate, unbiased, proven information when considering what to buy and when. And, as I've said many times, my decision for my production company on the JVC was due to the fact that, for our purposes, the HVX wasn't quite ready for our prime time. BUT... it's begining to look like by the time we get power for our JVCs, the P-2 cards will have come down in price, 8 Gig cards will be over the hump and working like a charm, workflow issues will have been smoothed, DTE will have been perfected and my "we selected JVC because we could work with it now" will have been relegated to nothing more than a bad decision and a complete waste of time and money. I'm regretting it already which is why we haven't placed the next JVC order with EVS. Gee, I can't wait to see what JVC has up their sleeves with their newest "killer deal" offering a 13X wide lense with the existing pair. I wonder if that's going to be another "Certificate Program," too?

BTW, I still can't find the spell check. Jared, is there a certificate I can fill out somewhere??? Just kidding!
 
Thanks so much for your recommendation, Barry. It was one that I really hadn't considered. When I was at the DGA the other week, AB was dying for us to go their route knowing our annual purchase schedule. Per your suggestion, I've notified IDX of our position and also noted that we have a pending, albeit unconfirmed order with EVS for 5 additional JVC cameras. Failure to cure this simple issue by JVC and/or IDX will lead me to believe that more complex issues may very well stymie JVC causing my production company further, unanticipated delays. Perhaps a move to Panasonic HXV may be in the cards for the next round of purchases from EVS and subsequent acquisitions as well. I'm sure it's all the same to Rush and company. Thanks again for the PM, the post and the idea.

Jonathan
 
Jonathan,

I purchased a camera from BH and downloaded the form from their website.

BH did not send me an original form, so I called JVC and talked to Mary (I think) her number is on the form. She was very friendly, returned my call, and told me that I could use the online form. Which I did. I have not received the battery yet, but I just sent the form last week.

I would call her.

Good luck.

Tom
 
B&H did not send me the form either, so I just used theirs, as I purchased from them anyway. I guess I'm glad I got steered away from EVS. I guess everything does happen for a reason.

I agree with what everyone has stated, just contact IDX/JVC and see if you can use the B&H. Rush did say they were different, but I'm sure they're all asking for the same items when mailing in.

It is a bummer we have to wait for them. I don't want to buy a bunch of JVC batteries I'm not going to use.
 
I'm not sure what's going on here, but why is it B&H is the only place that has certificates?
No doubt, this is going to PISS off dealers. My dealer knows about it.

I'm really impressed with the HD100, but I'm very UN-impressed how JVC is handling this promotion.

They are not only pissing off their customers, and dealers, but also swaying the customers that were "on the fence" towards the Panasonic HVX200.

What am I missing here???????????????????????????????????????????

Please send the certificates to YOUR dealers!

Miy dealer has been calling leaving messages!

To top it off, I was enticed into buying this camera by showing a camera with the IDX solution.

The battery/charger it comes with is a JOKE!!!!!!!!


Steve
 
Last edited:
Well, here we are. 2:00pm on Friday and it's the end of the week. No, I mean really the end of the week for me because I thought I was shooting tomorrow in the desert...but not without power. You see we had a scheduled shoot day tomorrow so I took everyone's advice and called IDX to see what could be done about getting us up and running. Remember yesterday when I said we'd be on location about a mile from EVS so I'd stop in and see them and ask their opinion on this whole fill-in-the-other-B&H-form idea you all came up with? Well, I did. In fact, I left the location about noon today while they were striking and headed right over. Rush was out so, with Randy, Tommy and the ever-present / ever-helpful, ever-faithful Toby sitting with me...and the place full of customers...I placed a call to IDX. Michelle, however was out so, really needing power tomorrow, I was switched to Andrea, allegedly Michelle's boss whereupon I attempted to explain that I had a $10,000/day payroll shoot tomorrow, no power and... Well that was about all I got our before she curtly interrupted me, told me to calm down and stop yelling. Here's the problem though; I was at EVS with conservatively 15 customers and three employees sitting there to see what was going to happen!!! Now would you raises your voice in that crowd??? Neither would I...nor did I. To make a long story short, she told me either to calm down or to call her back when I did and hung up. HUNG UP!. On ME! Well, not ME but me.

Not getting her name, I called back to discover it was Andrea who promptly told me she was not going to talk to me until I calmed down. I didn't even get the words out of my mouth to explain to her I was in the middle of a crowd at EVS and couldn't raise my voice before she hung up on me again. AGAIN!!! Tommy, Randy, Toby all sat there in complete amazement that a corporation...a major corporation supposedly at that... would treat a customer this way when all I wanted to do was explain to her that I was going to have to buy at least 2 battery backs that EVS didn't have in stock from EVS and drive myself down to Torrance, about an hour away, to pick them up. Apparently IDX not only doesn't want to give their battery deal to consumers, they don't want to sell them to us either!

So, with all of that said, with an entire company in my presence vouching 1) I'm not a volatile person anyway (producers can't be...we leave that up to Directors!!! We just figure a way to get the job done no matter what the job) and 2) I never raised my voice at all, I'm done with IDX and probably with JVC. With no way to power $25,000 worth of cameras in the desert tomorrow that are now sitting idly on a shelf collecting dust, I've had to cancel the call for 17 cast and crew and spend the weekend figuring out how I'm going to shoot this show. Generators? No. No way to muffle the sound. We're out in the middle of what is supposed to be a western setting with gunfighters. Oh, I could spring for the full quite-power rig but why would I expend $8,000 with TST and the generator company when a few bucks in batteries would do the trick. (Gee, Andrea, I only wanted to buy a couple of battery adapter plates from you. I already bought the batteries from EVS a $400 a crack!!!) Or maybe I'll just pull the motorcoach a hundred feet from the scene and string Home Depot extension cords from the on-board inverter system to each of the cameras. Yeah, that's the ticket! Actually, that's not a bad idea...completely unprofessional (Excuse me, Mr. Juicer, will Local 728 allow you to rig a Home Depot extension cord from my motor coach to my cameras...or is that a Local 600 request???) No, actually, I'm just going to give whomever asks the straight story and simply restate the facts of the JVC / IDX debacle.

Anyway, this is the last rant and rave. I promise. But this soap opera needed closure. Thank you to all of you who either posted replies and recommendations or PM'd me literally in the dozens and dozens. Bottom line: There's no way on God's Green Earth I'm going to deal with IDX anymore.

As for JVC...well, that remains to be seen. It's still one of the best cameras I have found (OK OK, I hear you HVX guys and girls... and Barry, I know the issue!!!) and, except for their batteries and their Focus Firestore issues which, by the way, isn't JVC's problem (in fact, kudos to JVC for sending the units they've received from Focus back to Focus because they didn't meet JVC standards and that benefits ALL of us who are in the field or on stage and really want to relegate tape to archive backup) if JVC will just get their program together AND, from my experience with Andrea and the whole, "Let's just hang up on this guy...twice deal!) find a better partner like Anton Bauer whom we never should have left in the first place except for the "killer deal", we'll stick with JVC. But jeeze JVC, you've got a great product AND a great deal. Just craft the deal as carefully in favor of the consumer as you did with your camera AND pick a better partner and I for one will stick with you. And I',m still mad at having to cancel and re-schedule our shoot tomorrow so you know as mad as I am right now, if I say I'll stick with you, I'll stick with you. Just get your act together and get that guy in New Jersey...you know, the one who hand-writes the certificates (yes, I've been talking to Rosenberg's assistant and know about the guy in New Jersey!!!) a computer...or at least another couple of Monks who can help him copy!

WOW, that feels better but on one final serious note. I hope, with all my heart, that these rants serve to straighten things out for all of us. None of us can afford a camera ... or five... that sit on a shelf until a decent power supply arrives. We make our living with these things, all of us, and no matter how great the picture quality is, if the tape never rolls...if the signal never gets processed, they're no better than a lawn ornament...wait, lawn ornaments include Gnomes...I love Gnomes...Gnomes are way better than cameras with no power!!!
 
In all of that I didn't gather whether you could use the B&H form or not. Could you replace B&H's name with EVS and use the same form?
 
Oh, there's another thread: I said:
Hey jlames,
I didn't read all of you post, (it was tad too long for me) but are you now out of power?
What sort of power do you need (specifications! volts, connector, etc.)
Wouldn't any external power source do in a pinch?

I have these here:
http://vidled.com/SLS-BMP.html

I guess I could rush a few to you FedEx tonight? I am not sure I see the lack of specific batteries a reason to halt a production? Sorry, I may have missed something, and I don't mean to offend.

Added:
I checked and the cam uses standard 7.2V, nothing dramatic for sure. I could whip up some batteries with chargers for you (Li-Ion or Li-Polymer) and send them to a FedEx location (hold at Fedex location) for you to pick up tomorrow or Monday.
 
No..or at least I don't think so. B&H didn't know and EVS had no idea either. Frankly, we're just going to stick with Anton Bauer after the way I was treated today at IDX. I don't really care what the customer does or says, within certainly reason, but you don't hang up on them. Now IDX's Andrea will probably have a truly inventive story to tell her bosses that I was loud or abusive but the problem is there that I was in a room full of people with no axe to grind one way or the other and I didn't even so much as raise my voice. In fact, Rush called me from home to tell me that Randy had called him to report the incident of how IDX was rude enough to hang up on me twice in the middle of a perfectly calm conversation. So the bottom line is we have a relatively large budget for a small, independent production company with first-look deals and the $300k or so I have budgeted for new HDV optical equipment this year and almost double that next year when we'll be looking at a move to true HD as soon as true HD shakes itself out will certainly go somewhere other than IDX and I can only urge anyomne erlse out there to seriously consider where they spend their own investment capital.

Thanks, truly, again for your concern and suggestion. Jusat another example of how this Board really ares about it's people.
Jonathan
 
I should preface this post by saying that I have connections to Anton Bauer and am obviously biased by those friendships....

But, having said that, I have to tell you, these guys are fantastic. I've seen what they've done to support their customers in some pretty remote places of the globe and these guys kick ass. They don't consider themselves a product supplier but rather a service provider. I think you will find a very different experience working with them. If you need me to help out, let me know.

Best of luck to you,

Matt
 
I hope this gets back to someone higher up at IDX. I'll go ahead and use the free IDX battery/charger I get but I won't be buying any additional IDX products. I'll go with the Anton Bauer and just keep the IDX around for that 1 spare battery fully charged in case of emergency.

Such a shame. Think about it...the slowness is probably mostly the fault of JVC so I would have supported IDX but hanging up on you twice? Wow, I wonder if her boss knows how much money that one "click" just cost IDX?
 
How great are you guys, vidled?!?!?!?!?!?!!!! Actually, as far out in the boonies as we're scheduled, no aux power is a biggie. But you know, everything works out for the best sometimes. I'm looking out my window right now and the rain is begining to fall and, for continuity, if it's wet tomorrow, we couldn't shoot anyway. So, with the wet forecast, the call-off was timely. But thanks so much for your concern and for your offer. Talk about above and beyond! We may have a show starting production in Quakertown, PA in a couple of months. How close that is to you I don't know but if we do, I'm coming by to shake your hand and say a personal thanks for the offer.
 
I hope she finds out in a big way, FullRez; not for retribution but just because no one should be subjected to that. Having been in this biz for a long time, I, like I'm sure you, have a pretty thick skin. We've been hung up on before...and yelled at and berated and, well, isn't that just the nature of the the studio industry? But for it to come from a little girl whose very paycheck comes from a company she's representing, a company that's able to pay her because of our purchases, well, I hope that there's some form of retribution for her actions.

And as for Matt C, no problem on the biased issue. You should be proud of Anton Bauer and your relationship with them. This one incident...not necessarilly the JVC but the Andrea at IDX incident should do more for their business than any planned public relations campaign ever could. We're with you, pal. I just hope JVC picks a better partner next time and that could be Anton Bauer. No matter what, JVC gets a black eye from this debacle as well but it was no where near as bad as after IDX's Andrea did her thing.
 
Cool, no worries then, so glad it is raining....huh? Well, you know what I mean! ;-)
Good you replied so soon, because I've been holding off from going inside (I am in an outside office), because FedEx closes in about an hour.

Good to see you have a pos attidude though still. It will be important for the success of your project, so HOLD THAT THOUGHT!! ;-)

Oh, BTW, Quakertown is about 75 miles away, I am in Paupack (near Scranton), but I am always happy to shake a fellow filmmaker's hand!
 
Back
Top