CharlesPapert
Director of Photography
Ever seen Billy Wilder's The Apartment?
Any format can be used for any subject. It's all in how you choose to use it. Personally one thing I find about anamorphic is that it can be great for showing two people in frame for a fairly intimate two-shot. Spielberg did this a lot in Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade. He wanted to play up the relationship between father & son and liked keeping the two of them in frame together, but at the same time not be stuck with lots of medium-wide shots.
Agreed about the framing possibilities for 2:39, but of course that can be done with spherical lenses and cropping to achieve similar compositions (allowing for the argument that the focal length differences and optical characteristics are added factors in how we perceive the frame). It is a funny era that we are in that aberrations and defects are now prized, and pristine optics are ridiculed. But as we have discussed--all things are cyclical and all trends will pass.
