Super Test Film! (aka. the gh1 is back) - AVCHD "C" hack

Hunter Hampton

Carbonite Member
Maybe some other dvxusers remember that I imported a japanese gh1 before they were available in the US and much to my dismay, we started seeing the horrible codec problems. Today is a new day for the GH1. Many thanks to the "Tester" and donators- I can now actually use this camera as I had originally hoped.

So I present to you another pointless test film:
Be sure to watch on vimeo in HD/ and or download the h.264 file.

Vimeo Link: http://vimeo.com/12626420

SD Embed:


P.s. Feel free to post AVCHD hack videos on this thread.
 
Thanks-I have used the 24p patch and "c" settings only (found in the avchd mud free thread)- I havent messed with the MJPEG or any other patch.

Camera has performed flawlessly, never freezes, always playsback clips- nothing funny with the image I can notice. The card im using is a 16GB Patriot Class 6.
 
WOw! There was a person having problems with this Patriot 32gb class 10(which is what I have) and I was thinking of going to buy a sandisk 32gb extreme if it doesn't work. What are the difference with the "c" setting,"b" and "d"? I am seeing all these settings but I don't see a thread that shows all of them.
 
Here is what I used (from Jobless' post on AVCHD thread):

Video bitrate adjustment - c)40000000 d)50000000 e)60000000
Overall bitrate adjustment - c)46000000 d)56000000 e)66000000
Limiting bitrate adjustment - c)50000000 d)60000000 e)70000000
 
Thanks for all the info, Hunter.

Question: Do the bit-rate settings you list above affect, and seem compatible with, both 1080p24 & 720p60? Record & play in-cam? All with your lucky Class 6 card? :-)

Bonus Q: Have you had any problems using the 14-140mm kit zoom lens at diff. local lengths? (I ask because Vitaliy/Tester13 thought some Lumix lens auto CA correction may possibly intermittently stress the CPU.) Just curious if you've seen anything like this using the kit lens at various amounts of zoom in "codec high stress" scenes?
 
Peter- Yes, both 720/60p and 1080/24p work fine- both also play back well. I didnt buy the 14-140 lens again (nice zoom range but not my cup o tea), I found a body only this time. The only m4/3 lens Im using is a 20mm pancake which works fine with the hack in AF and MF. Im really not having any issues I know of in anyway.
 
It's been mentioned a couple times, but I think we should start doing a few tests related to aperture and the card's ability to keep up. If Hunter was using the 20mm 1.7 at 1.7, that means the shallow depth of field could make it easier for the camera to handle, right?

So what if we decrease the aperture with all the settings remaining the same? Perhaps the same card would have trouble keeping up with the extra detail?
 
Excellent. Thanks so much for the follow-up, Hunter.

OK, cool: I'll try Vitaliy's PTool @ these 44 mb/s data-rates with the 14-140 kit lens and see what happens. It'll probably be fine. My GH1(3) is currently running the mid-30s mb/s data-rates w/o issues.

(I also have an old Nikon 55mm f1.2 prime & the Lumix 20mm f1.7 pancake.)

Ack: If I may, another Q: If you're using FCP, for this test did you transcode to ProRes LT or ? When you export out, what type of file/codec did you use to upload to Vimeo?
 
I shot most of my first day's stuff on f/11 and f/8, I was trying to overload the detail and break the codec (and it almost completely refused to break!) Out of about sixty clips, my Class 6 card only choked once. So with AVCHD at least, it doesn't seem like that's much of a concern. MJPG, maybe.
 
Thanks, Hunter. Interesting: ProRes 422 instead of LT; duly noted. I assume YMMV.

You may not be as smart or as good-looking as Vitaliy Kiselev/Tester13, but you're still "a good man to have in a tight corner!"* :-)

Thanks again.

* I believe that's an accurate quote from "Brazil".
 
I shot most of my first day's stuff on f/11 and f/8, I was trying to overload the detail and break the codec (and it almost completely refused to break!) Out of about sixty clips, my Class 6 card only choked once. So with AVCHD at least, it doesn't seem like that's much of a concern. MJPG, maybe.


Did you have native 24p enabled?
 
Thanks, Hunter. Interesting: ProRes 422 instead of LT; duly noted. I assume YMMV.

You may not be as smart or as good-looking as Vitaliy Kiselev/Tester13, but you're still "a good man to have in a tight corner!"* :-)

Thanks again.

* I believe that's an accurate quote from "Brazil".

L&T meaning "Log and Transfer" in Hunter's msg I believe. LT is not referring to codec.
 
Back
Top