cinealma
Veteran
apollyon said:You are of course entitled to your opinion. For me it's a matter of integrity. And in regards to your above example...that's not the lesson I would want to teach my son.
Look at it this way...how do you think your son would feel if he knew the only reason he won is because his father was on the panel judging? Do you think that would earn him the respect of his friends and peers?
Please note Cinealma I am not attacking you personally, just offering up another way of looking at this. You are 100% entitled to your own opinion on the subject, and I do not presume I can sway you.
No offense taken. I firmly believe in one's right to an opinion and do not feel attacked at all, my friend.
My intention was to give an example of a "what-if" situation. Integrity in such matters would dictate that I decline the seat on the judging panel.
My kids are the best. Pure and simple. That's the father in me talking. No matter what they do, they are still going to be #1 in my book. Now, I might get the occasional, "Dad, WTF are you talking about? I sucked!" And then the conversation might turn to how they can become better. But for me, they are still #1 overall. Why? Because they're my boys. I don't think it translates as bullsh*t. It lets them know that I support and love them. Maybe BIASED is the word we are all looking for?
As filmmakers, we can be our own worst critics. On the flip side, to try and judge our own films, most of us would probably KILL our own films, because in our minds, the damn things are NEVER ever finished. But I save that kind of ca-ca for the editing room.
But the real answer here is for Jarred to ignore any "own film" scores. That solves the problem.
And I don't think integrity is an issue. Or else, most of us wouldn't be promoting/marketing our "great" films as such. It would be more like:
Cure for Writer's Block: No. 9
Not the best film, but I really hope you watch it anyway. Please.
"Acting was subpar. An average film" - JoeUser
"I could have done better with a disposable camera and a can of Pringles" - BobUser
"How about a cure for whatever mentally degenerative disease that made you come up with this piece of artsy sh*t!" - BettyUser
John G.