rating yourself

apollyon said:
You are of course entitled to your opinion. For me it's a matter of integrity. And in regards to your above example...that's not the lesson I would want to teach my son.

Look at it this way...how do you think your son would feel if he knew the only reason he won is because his father was on the panel judging? Do you think that would earn him the respect of his friends and peers?

Please note Cinealma I am not attacking you personally, just offering up another way of looking at this. You are 100% entitled to your own opinion on the subject, and I do not presume I can sway you.

No offense taken. I firmly believe in one's right to an opinion and do not feel attacked at all, my friend.

My intention was to give an example of a "what-if" situation. Integrity in such matters would dictate that I decline the seat on the judging panel.

My kids are the best. Pure and simple. That's the father in me talking. No matter what they do, they are still going to be #1 in my book. Now, I might get the occasional, "Dad, WTF are you talking about? I sucked!" And then the conversation might turn to how they can become better. But for me, they are still #1 overall. Why? Because they're my boys. I don't think it translates as bullsh*t. It lets them know that I support and love them. Maybe BIASED is the word we are all looking for? :)

As filmmakers, we can be our own worst critics. On the flip side, to try and judge our own films, most of us would probably KILL our own films, because in our minds, the damn things are NEVER ever finished. But I save that kind of ca-ca for the editing room. :)

But the real answer here is for Jarred to ignore any "own film" scores. That solves the problem.

And I don't think integrity is an issue. Or else, most of us wouldn't be promoting/marketing our "great" films as such. It would be more like:

Cure for Writer's Block: No. 9
Not the best film, but I really hope you watch it anyway. Please.

"Acting was subpar. An average film" - JoeUser
"I could have done better with a disposable camera and a can of Pringles" - BobUser
"How about a cure for whatever mentally degenerative disease that made you come up with this piece of artsy sh*t!" - BettyUser


John G.
 
cinealma said:
Cure for Writer's Block: No. 9
Not the best film, but I really hope you watch it anyway. Please.

"Acting was subpar. An average film" - JoeUser
"I could have done better with a disposable camera and a can of Pringles" - BobUser
"How about a cure for whatever mentally degenerative disease that made you come up with this piece of artsy sh*t!" - BettyUser

John G.

This made me laugh :). I can see your point.

I was very hesitant to promote my own film...in fact I didn't other than just create a Thread, and I almost didn't do that either because of what you mentioned above. I almost went with "the Devil Inside: My first film, please don't hurt me. Please."

It's funny, I think we approach this from opposite sides; you are very upbeat about your own work (and rightly so) and I am very downbeat about mine. I wonder what that says about me...

You are correct, we are our own worst critics I think.

Your simple solution is correct also of course. Thanks for the discussion. :)
 
cinealma said:
And I don't think integrity is an issue. Or else, most of us wouldn't be promoting/marketing our "great" films as such. It would be more like:

Cure for Writer's Block: No. 9
Not the best film, but I really hope you watch it anyway. Please.

"Acting was subpar. An average film" - JoeUser
"I could have done better with a disposable camera and a can of Pringles" - BobUser
"How about a cure for whatever mentally degenerative disease that made you come up with this piece of artsy sh*t!" - BettyUser


John G.



This is how I thought the reviews would have gone because it would have been more
toward real reviews that I would probably read in a paper somewhere. Sometimes
I felt I was scaling back my criticism when I should have been turning up the heat
instead. Overall I would still standby all my statements thus far.

I would not vote for my own short because of bias but, I definitely see
cinealma's point. Therefore I agree that we toss out the personal scores for
each film.

As far as judging myself in every category.... hmm let's see, if I had a gun to my
head forcing me to score myself then I would. In all other instances you're
sort of judging yourself throughout the process of creation anyways. The numbers,
after the fact, are meaningless unless you want prizes. I think I can safely say
that feedback carries the most weight around here.
 
Ok. We're going to ignore the scores of your own film... I am going to get a hold of Barry_S and Jarred to make sure we do not add in the score you give your own film.
 
khmuse said:
I would install a filter the rejects the entire ballot of any participant that rated their film a 10 across the board (and would be suspicious of a 10 in any category as that implies perfection in that area and perfection is by my standard nearly unachievable).

Hm. I disagree with this. Every fest, one film gets all 10's from me. It's never been my own, but one film does.
 
Well Done Brandon. I think this is a great move!

I honestly think we are not qualified to judge our shorts right now anyway. Maybe in a year, but not as soon as we've finished them.
 
Brandon Rice said:
HM. I disagree with this. Every fest, one film gets all 10's from me. It's never been my own, but one film does.

Hey Brandon,

If you read my suggestion I stated "...any participant that rated their film..." this was to filter out an attempt to push up the rating of their film, not a filter which would disallow someone to rate a film a 10 (other than their own) across the board. Though I do find it hard to believe that there is or will ever be a perfect film across the board here or anywhere.

Regardless, I really think removing the self vote is a perfect approach.

Thanks for pushing this change through.
 
Restricting a self-vote and not restricting 10's across the board sounds impossible in excel because then you'd have to give each entrant a specific balot and that's just the same as ignoring the score for their self score.
 
My word

People actually admitting they'd vote for thier kid even if they sucked ? That won't teach your kid anything but favortism.

Come on; you know if your film is worthy or not.
 
John_Hudson said:
My word

People actually admitting they'd vote for thier kid even if they sucked ? That won't teach your kid anything but favortism....

And even worse, does little to prepare them for the real world.

Without an honest assessment how can one hope to improve? Applies to all children, those whom are actually young and those whom are not and call themselves filmmakers.
 
Without an honest assessment how can one hope to improve? Applies to all children, those whom are actually young and those whom are not and call themselves filmmakers.
I concur.

I, however, wouldn't go as far as to rip something apart and make someone feel bad. There has to be a certain amount of finesse when criticizing, otherwise you hurt peoples feelings... especially when they put so much time and energy into something.
 
Last edited:
John_Hudson said:
My word

People actually admitting they'd vote for thier kid even if they sucked ? That won't teach your kid anything but favortism.

khmuse said:
And even worse, does little to prepare them for the real world.


No, it's actually called parenting.

It looks like some people subscribe to the "tough love" point of view. But I'm not here to discuss parenting methods in a filmmaking thread.

Sorry I tried to relate a personal analogy to such, as now I feel some people are getting just a little TOO personal.

Peace out.


John G.
 
khmuse said:
Hey Brandon,

If you read my suggestion I stated "...any participant that rated their film..." this was to filter out an attempt to push up the rating of their film, not a filter which would disallow someone to rate a film a 10 (other than their own) across the board. Though I do find it hard to believe that there is or will ever be a perfect film across the board here or anywhere.

Regardless, I really think removing the self vote is a perfect approach.

Thanks for pushing this change through.

While not a bad idea to start with, this punishes films that have multiple users collaborating on them. If a certain film is made by 5 DVXUser members, that reduces the possible votes by much more than a film made by only a single member. I would imagine that with some of the films where multiple users take credit it could really impact the film if there votes (whether 10 or 5 or 1) were not allowed at all.
 
Back
Top