Optimize RED for it's native strength: 35mm camera with 1080 HD output

Proteus

Well-known member
Focus the design efforts on optimizing the camera for a standard HD 1080p/i output (1920x1080) to make it more transferable, playable, editable, affordable. The majority of users will need and use this format for digital productions (e.g WMV, MPEG2 or h.264 on the new revolutionary media Blu Ray and HD DVD). Because the camera has a single sensor with Bayer matrix, it's resolution is already decreased so the full 4k data doesn't correspond to full 4k resolution. But it can give a really excellent picture on the standard HD res, competitive to very expensive 3-CCD HD cameras like the Sony F900. So I think the greater advantage of this camera will be as an excellent 35mm camera for 1080p/i output which by the way will be sharper than Silicon's because of the down-sampling from a 4k sensor, like it was an HD sensor without a Bayer matrix!

So If someone wants to transfer to film and prefers to process the full raw ccd data, make this possible but don't sacrifice the main strength and usefulness of this camera. Also, this could make the camera price start lower with optional add-ons for those who need and can afford them, so everyone will be happy!

just a suggestion
 
Last edited:
Resolution loss will depend on how sophisticated the de-mosaic algorithm is, on the anti-aliasing filter in front of the CCD, on the detail pattern and on the green amount of the image. Also, color definition will be much less. But even if the RED team achieves 90% of the 4k, who will use that res except those interested for film-transfer? The majority will benefit from the likely excellent HD output and won't need to take advantage of 4k nor will afford to do so.
 
I am really only interested in 1080p also. I agree. Maybe Red could make a dumbed down version for us. Adobe makes Photoshop elements for people who can't afford or don't need the full version of Photoshop. Red could make a model that did only 1080i/p and sell it for less. This would be great for the prosumer, but would Red make money selling a cheaper model?
 
acrochordon said:
Red could make a model that did only 1080i/p and sell it for less. This would be great for the prosumer, but would Red make money selling a cheaper model?

In my opinion, if RED keeps the 4k sensor and provide 1080p using all pixels, YES!
By the way, I saw in one of the RED sticky forums that a good de-mosaic algorithm can provide about 70% of the resolution, not 90%. This means that RED's 1080 downsampled output from 4k would be up to 30% sharper than Silicon's! Even 20% would be a lot of a difference. Also, it would be less noisy especially if all the process will be done in 4k. These are clear advantages and if RED objectively can at least provide a better image, it can sell to professionals, to prosumers and to anyone (including myself) that want just that: First of all, a better HD image! Why someone leave low-budget low-risk HDV and spend much more if the image won't be much better anyway?
 
Last edited:
You might only get >70%, but it sure as hell looks better than that with a good debayer :-) Also, there's not as much detail up at 4k as there is at lower resolutions, so you're missing less, and hence it looks better still.

Don't think like this: 4k will look not as good as 1080p, but....
Pixel for pixel, 1080p will look better than the already superb 4k.

Graeme
 
As you increase resolution, you get closer to the limits of all other camera components in the light path as is the lens, the iris and the filters, that will affect a larger percentage of the image quality that the given pixels could capture. And all this added to the 30% decrement from the Bayer matrix.

So because of the downsampling from 4k, at 1080p this camera should give you the maximum resolution you can expect, or else, more detail per pixel.
 
So why use 4k when shooting? There's been tons of arguments that 4k costs too much for the current market, when considering storage, editing, etc. etc. If 1080p is better, surely the requirements are much the same as that of the HVX200?
 
Hmm... I have explained "why" at least three times until now ...on the same thread...:shocked:
Anyway, in sort, shooting at double resolution is the only way to provide high quality HD output from a single sensor with Bayer matrix, period.

Also, there's no need to store and edit in 4k if you are only interested in HD.
BTW, no comparison at all with the HVX200, RED's *definition* and clarity at 1080p will be double from that camera...
 
1080p isn't better. It is probably better per pixel, but 4k gives you a lot more pixels. Do you want absolute rez - shoot 4k - absolute quality, scaled 1080p might look better under some circumstances. Either way, it's a great picture you're getting.

Graeme
 
Proteus said:
Anyway, in sort, shooting at double resolution is the only way to provide high quality HD output from a single sensor with Bayer matrix, period.

Actually even just cropping 1080p out of the middle of the sensor will look blinkin good. It's just that 1080p scaled from the larger area will look even better still.

Modern debayering algorithms like we're using are rather fine! Bayer is not this evil thing you know - you've got to understand it, but it's really the right way to go.

Graeme
 
Nattress, you are way smart. I looked at your website. I made a movie with FCP. I saw all the flaws in FCP and said why can't they fix these things. Man you are smart, you pluggins sound great. I am going to wait to buy anything new for my compuer untill I form a company and have my co. buy a new Intel based Mac. I guess Apple will build a machine just to edit RED. I am glad you are on the RED team. Too bad Apple can't have you on their team too. There is only so much Nattress to go around. Untill Apple makes a platform to edit RED, what are peole going to do with all this footage? I say RED should make it so I can use my old G5 and other two year old equipment with the new RED camera, to do 1080i/p. Eventually I would upgrade to a new Mac, but make RED compatible with my pre Intel OSX panther G5 and FCP HD.
 
Te He - Thanks!

I don't think we're going to do anything particular to lock out older computers. They should still work, although their horse power might not give the smoothest of rides. Makes sense?

Graeme
 
Back
Top