OHMYGAWD! Uncompressed BlackMagic 10bit recorder for $345

Yup - saw this a few minutes ago... it also looks like it covers all flavours of HD signal over HD-SDI & HDMI (which is also 1.4) so maybe the first out of the block for Sony's TC over HDMI?

The studio version (with LCD) looks very nice too.
 
The other popular external recorders record from 8-bit cameras to 10-bit codecs just fine, so I wouldn't be too worried about this one failing in that department.
 
That sounds quick and easy.

It is. :) I would rather copy the files directly off the SSD onto a GRAID or something though. I would want to utilize the fast copying capabilities of the drive and deal with the files later. That's me though. Having a codec choice after the fact is pretty awesome, not gonna lie.
 
Don't keep the uncompressed, just transcode the uncompressed to prores hq instead of copying off the drive. Then format and reuse.

Fast as hell.
 
Don't keep the uncompressed, just transcode the uncompressed to prores hq instead of copying off the drive. Then format and reuse.

Fast as hell.

Let's talk costs then.

At present price levels, what would 90 minutes of continuous uncompressed 10-bit 1080p30 422 cost with a solid SATA II or SATA III SSD drive run?

and any indication that the BM device could power that long of a continuous shoot?
 
David, search back in the thread, I already posted plenty about how much it would cost and how much you can fit onto what drive at what cost. We don't know anything about battery life yet, but according to their site it has to be pretty substantial. SSD are low power as well.

Since this product is cheap enough, I actually suggested the possibility of having two on hand charged up and ready to go. You could just swap it out. It would cost a lot less than some expensive 12V capable power pack and such (also covered earlier in the thread). About $800-1000 for drives that could hold 90mins of that...2x 256GB worth give or take a little bit.
 
If it is true that it can record from an 8 bit hdmi source and pad the top bits with zeros to get 10 bits, then;

what applications can normalize and smooth the embedded 8 bit data to 10 bits?
 
This reminds me of when the first P2 cards came out. Remember the 4gig cards? The price of SSD will come down as the size grows. I will use this like P2. Shoot, offload with DIT for compressing to something editable, wipe card and keep shooting.
 
+1 ...can't believe how ridiculous these threads can get.

Prores is NOT what this device was designed to do, so please get off the complain train. Go buy something else...

I wouldn't necessarily call it complaining. Uncompressed it pretty amazing, but I wouldn't need it all the time. My point is that if it can handle uncompressed, why not have an option to record in another format as well? Uncompressed it overkill for acquisition in many cases.

Stop complaining about complaining! LOL! :D
 
Sorry,
This has been dang entertaining but...

This is an uncompressed device, Right?
Meaning that it should be in a Quicktime wrapper that's universal, right?
So, that means that it should be a first encode to the codec of your choice off of the drives into the editor like the Gemini, right?
Soooo... I love it.

Also, the gemini comes with the docking station... I haven't heard talk of a docking station with this thing which, again, adds yet another nominal cost...
 
Because that's not the product for the price...

Unless BM has confirmed that there are no options in a firmware update to record to another codec, these type of questions are fine.

I've emailed BM about this and haven't received a response.
 
Last edited:
Also, the gemini comes with the docking station... I haven't heard talk of a docking station with this thing which, again, adds yet another nominal cost...

All you need is a simple dock for the SSDs...very cheap now. Even less than $75. Again, the best part about this is you can just transcode your files from the SSD if you don't intend to keep the uncompressed (which many dont need, and it'll be crazy fast as a SSD to transcode), and then delete the original files. Bingo, Prores422 HQ files just like any other recorder.
 
To compress the signal, you need horsepower. This device is basically taking the exact signal you are reading off the camera and dropping it unchanged to the SSD in a wrapper. Very little work to be done. If they added compression, then the price AND power starts to go up. I'm not complaining, I think it is awesome, but it is why I suspect there wouldn't be any codec compression options at this price.
 
To compress the signal, you need horsepower. This device is basically taking the exact signal you are reading off the camera and dropping it unchanged to the SSD in a wrapper. Very little work to be done. If they added compression, then the price AND power starts to go up. I'm not complaining, I think it is awesome, but it is why I suspect there wouldn't be any codec compression options at this price.

+1000...

This is what I've been trying to explain. It's simply a dumping station, and not meant to be much more than that. For me that's really the only use I want out of an external recorder, and this one lets me play back clips (it looks like based on the site) which makes it an incredible product. All I need is a simple way to get clips off the camera and into a format like Prores. It's just a wrapping tool, and that's perfectly fine with me. All I need is this, and a small SSD to get started (with a simple SSD dock), and I can invest in more SSD's as time goes on.
 
Back
Top