@Jason - I used a Marantz 661 for the voice over (which I recorded in my car for lack of sound booth, etc), and a Sennheiser wireless mic kit for the interviews (plugged straight into the camera). I didn't think the audio was tinny on the original file, but will check if something lost in the vimeo conversion.
@ihart - I'm actually from Calgary too. I hear there's still snow on the ground! Exposure in camera was pretty good (I use the histogram religiously) and then corrected using the scopes in FCP so am surprised it looks overexposed. I used to underexpose by a stop for better saturation, but an editor friend at the channel I work for told me to get with the scopes (or he would) ...
i thought it was pretty good dave!
the exposure was much much better in this one. sure there were some shots of the main woman where the highlights on her face looked a little clipped, but those scenes were all very high contrast. if you had stopped down more you would've had a much darker deep shadowy image which may have had the opposite effect you wanted for the video. it would've had a very different feel to her interview. that said, you may want to test this yourself on the next one and see which you like, but i think you are now in the ballpark so to speak. =)
personally, i use the center (blue +) exposure metering and put it on the brightest part of the subject's face to set exposure. then i use the AE lock feature to lock exposure. this works really well for faces. in some scenes it may mean that super bright areas are blown out and deep shadows crushed, but my priority for interviews is getting exposure right for the subject. this is especially true in documentary/news shoots where you're not controlling lighting to bring the entire scene into range.
overall, the editing seemed fine. i didn't notice anything amiss or tinny about the audio myself. one thing i didn't see was any establishing or wide shots for your main interview subject. i think we talked about this last time too....are you capturing wide angle b-roll for each person/location? i feel that your stories could benefit greatly from some 'still life' type b-roll shots of these locations....they are great for quickly setting the mood or conveying a general sense of a location and are also fun to capture.
keep up the great work! what's the next story going to be about??
Thanks for all the help guys. I actually went online after reading ihartvideo's comments and read up on using FCP's scopes. After loading the video into FCP and looking at the vectorscope it appears all the video is seriously undersaturated (which was not the look I was going for). Was it the winter light and the snow? The sun certainly wasn't very warm during my brief time in Montana.
Averan, I'll try out your metering suggestions for interviews. I'll send you a message if I get stuck. The one thing I'm aware of is keeping the whites broadcast safe (if I don't do it someone in DC will).
I hear what you're saying about establishing shots. But in my quest to try and keep stories more people focused I seem to use more medium/tight shots than wide. I'll keep your advice in mind though.
Two more stories done here in Guate (family planning and disabled kids). Next one to pitch is the government's Mi Familia Progresa program whereby the government pays poor parents to send their kids to school. Some local (indigenous) call it Mi Familia en Pobresa ... La Cantina Riqueza.
interesting. so you basically are forced to underexpose your images? if whites can never be above 90% (i think that's the broadcast limit) then you'll always have a tough time.
i just read a few posts on this issue and it looks to me like you can always clip your blacks and whites to fit broadcast limits, so any blown out highlights will become grey instead of solid 255 white.
it looks like my advice would really help you. if you set exposure to the brightest part of a person's face you know they will be exposed perfectly and any bright highlights in the background can be clipped into safe limits. i think its more acceptable to have background colors crushed than to have foreground elements or your subject altered.
re: wide establishing shots -
you do actually use several such shots throughout your video, just not in the beginning where i think it is actually even more essential. it would only take 1 quick shot of the woman's farm/barn from afar to instantly give us a feel for where she's located.