HVX+ SGPRO Flip - color or black and white?

[Bertholt4]

We shot yesterday in an unused fabric - very cool location. It was at est for a film we are planning to shoot during the summer.

color

http://www.vimeo.com/1099597

bw

http://www.vimeo.com/1097739


Only for style testing - which one do you like better?

Thank you for watching!

 

[Steven Bogda]

I vote B/W. The color does look nice, but I like how B/W looks on my DVX & SGpro, and your HVX looks twice as good. Maybe if you crushed the blacks some more.

 

[DePalmoNewMedia]

I would have to agree with my man Steve. The b&w looks slightly deeper than the color version. Another suggestion, possibly try grading the color version to make it less warm. A cooler color approach might be a nice compromise between color and b&W.

 

[Kyle Stebbins]

Desaturate your colored one, and that's my vote.